Chapter XII: Part V: Browning’s “ben Karshook” (3)

_Ha-Tikwah_ owes its fame to the directness of its sentiment. What makes for weakness in it as a poem makes for strength in it as a song. The most effective national hymns are not usually the most poetical. “God save the King” is doggerel; “Rule Britannia” is bombast. But both put patriotic thoughts in straightforward terms, both are happily wedded to simple tunes within the range of average voices. _Ha-Tikwah_ satisfies both these tests. The melody is beautiful and easily sung by large masses of people. The opening line of Imber’s refrain: “Our hope has not perished yet” is certainly derived from the National Song, “Poland has not perished yet,” to which the Polish legions marched. So the melody of _Ha-Tikwah_ is said to be a Polish folk-tune, but it closely resembles a favorite melody of the Sephardim. Various settings of the tune differ in detail, and the same is true of the current versions of Imber’s words. It is strange that the versions--all known to me--retain unanimously the ungrammatical second stanza. It would, I admit, be difficult to correct it without destroying the rhythm, and poetical license has worse things to answer for. Indeed the grammatical lapse, to which I refer, is regarded by some authorities as perfectly normal and admissible in the new Hebrew.

The power of _Ha-Tikwah_, as has just been said, arises from its directness. There is no subtlety in its thought, no changes through its nine verses. Just as few ever sing through “God Save the King,” so few sing all the verses of _Ha-Tikwah_. The stanzas tend to become monotonous. They all say the same thing; and it is not surprising that the number of verses is curtailed in some printed editions (thus in Idelsohn five of the nine verses complete the song). The burden of all the verses is identical. The hope of a return to the land of Israel will never die, so long as this or that endures. Each verse adds a this or a that to the count. While myriads of Jews go as pilgrims to the sepulchres of the fathers, while a single eye is left to drop its tear over the ruins of the temple, while the waters of the Jordan swell between its banks and fall with a rush through the sea of Kinnereth, while a drop of blood courses through a Jewish vein, while Israel retains his national aspirations, still may he hope for their fulfilment. Some of these appeals are genuinely pathetic, and the final appeal is magnificent in its strength. Only with the end of the Jews will come the end of the hope. This is the only way to write a popular song. There must be no nuances, but just a confident assertion. Imber supplies exactly that; nothing less, and nothing more.

Nothing more, for the song is not in any sense a declaration of the end. It deals only with the means, making them into an end. Unquenchable, he cries, is the hope of a return; no one has expressed this hope more vigorously and takingly. But what is to be the result of the return? With what ideals are the patriots filled? _Ha-Tikwah_ is silent on these questions. Imber was not qualified to reply to them. He had no depth of spiritual feeling, and though he was capable of inspiriting, he was incapable of inspiring. Hence the absence of all Messianic thought in _Ha-Tikwah_. Compare it, for instance, with _Leka Dodi_; the Friday night hymn is like _Ha-Tikwah_, a song of the return, but, unlike _Ha-Tikwah_, it is Messianic, and is also a song of the rebuilding. When the history of the neo-Zionist movement comes to be written, this fact will undoubtedly come into due prominence: namely, that we have been passing through a phase in which the hope of the return has been divorced from the hope of the rebuilding.

It is remarkable that some versions of the refrain remove the only words which possibly can bear a Messianic construction. I have not before me the original words of Imber himself, and I have a notion that Mr. David Yellin is responsible in part for the chorus. Be that as it may, in the last line Jerusalem is described as “the city where David encamped.” The phrase comes from the opening line of the twenty-ninth chapter of Isaiah. “Woe to Ariel, Ariel, city where David encamped”--Ariel is either “Lion of God” or, as the Targum takes it, “Altar-hearth.” The Rabbis combined both senses. Ariel was the altar, yet they saw something lion-shaped in the sanctuary. In Isaiah the passage is one of doom, Ariel is to be humiliated by the Assyrians. Curiously enough, the ancient Greek translation gives also a hostile turn to the words “city where David encamped,” rendering “against which David encamped.” But this is erroneous. The meaning is: the city in which David dwelt, selecting it as the royal capital. David, it is true, did not build the temple, but he brought the ark thither, and offered sacrifices on the occasion, and later on built an altar. Not only, then, is Ariel justly to be termed the city where David encamped, but the use of the phrase in _Ha-Tikwah_ supplies the missing Messianic hope, for David is the type of this hope. In the version of _Ha-Tikwah_ printed by Idelsohn four verses are omitted, and some of those which are retained are set in an inverted order. More culpably, the refrain is weakened into “the city of Zion and Jerusalem,” thus removing the Davidic touch. The change does not merely offend against reason; it also sins against rhyme; thus adding another instance to many others of the destructive tamperings with masterpieces which some editors seem unable to avoid.

One other striking merit of _Ha-Tikwah_ must be observed. Unlike many other poets of Zion, Imber does not denounce. He makes no attack on those who do not share his feelings. He points to the continued existence of the hope for the return, but he refrains from condemning, except by the merest implication, those who have no consciousness of the hope. There is true art here, which I am able to appreciate, far removed as I am from Imber’s nationalism. For, on the one hand, art is best when it pleases some without paining others. Imber pleases those who agree with him without paining the rest. On the other hand, art is strongest when it does not recognize that there are others to be displeased. The confident note is the artistic note. The poet assumes that what he feels is the only thing to feel. To talk of doubters is to throw doubt on himself. A popular song cannot stoop to argument. It is categorical. Thus Imber’s _Ha-Tikwah_ can be enjoyed by those who do not accept its message. And its melody is sung at table, to Psalm 126, by some who never sing the tune to Imber’s words. “When the Lord turned again the captivity of Zion, we were like unto them that dream. Then was our mouth filled with laughter, and our tongue with exultation; then said they among the nations: The Lord hath done great things for them.” Psalm 126, when all is said and done, is the most exquisite Song of the Return ever written. “They that sow in tears shall reap in joy.” We can all realize the pathos and the hope, even though we are not at one as to the nature of the harvest that is to be reaped.

INDEX

Abarbanel, 53.

Aben Ezra, 176;
_see also_ Abraham Ibn Ezra.

Aboab, Isaac, 102, 107.

Abraham Ibn Ezra, 66, 261, 269;
_see also_ Aben Ezra.

Acosta, Uriel, 240-246.

Addison, Joseph, 153, 236, 237.

Addison, Lancelot, 153-159.

Adler, H., 288.

Adler, Michael, 228, 270.

Adler, Nathan M., 288, 335.

Æsop’s Fables, 18, 22, 35, 84.

Aguilar, Grace, 247-253.

Ahad ha-‘Am, 185, 289.

Ahikar, the story of, 17-23.

Al-Fasi, 63.

_Alfieri and Salomon_, by Landor, 260-266.

Al-Harizi, 79, 81.

Allenby, General, 328.

Allingham, William, 82.

Alnaqua, Israel, 102, 103.

Anti-Maimonists, 85.

Apion, Josephus against, 32-38.

_Arabian Nights_, 18.

Archagathos, 43, 44.

Aristeas, Letter of, 116, 117, 119, 120.

Aristobulus, Jewish Hellenist, 44.

Aristotle, 78, 79.

Arnold, Edwin, 233.

Arnold, Matthew, 32, 42, 207.

Artom’s Sermons, 297-302.

_Aruk_, the, by Nathan of Rome, 60-66.

Ass-worship, libel of, 34.

Auerbach, Berthold, 242.

Baedeker’s, Handbook for Palestine, 353-358.

Bandmann, A., 240.

Bar Abun, Solomon, 97-101.

Bar Hisdai’s _Prince and Dervish_, 84-90.

Baratier, 270.

Barb, Issac, 304.

Barbary Jews, Lancelot Addison on the, 153-159.

Barlaam and Josaphat, romance of, 88, 89.

Belinson, 291.

_Benevolent Jew_, the, by George Walker, 192-198.

_Ben Ezra, Rabbi_, by Robert Browning, 269-275.

_Ben Karshook_, by Browning, 269-275.

Benisch, A., 254, 255, 256.

Benjamin of Tudela, 270.

Bernstein, 282.

Berdoe, 271.

Black’s Guide to Jerusalem, 353.

Blanco White’s Sonnet, 220-225;
_see also_ White, Joseph Blanco.

Bodenschatz Pictures, the, 160-165.

Bonajuto, 116;
_see also_ De Rossi.

Book of Tobit, 17, 18, 22, 23.

Bornstein, H. J, 304.

Box, C. H., 136.

Braham, 208, 209.

Briggs, C. A., 225.

Brooke, Stopford, 274.

Browning, Robert, 265, 269-275.

Buddha, life of, 88.

Buffon, French naturalist, 32.

Burke, Edmund, 168.

Burne-Jones, 95, 96.

Buxtorf, J., 62.

Byron, 199, 324.

Byron’s _Hebrew Melodies_, 194, 207-213, 265.

Caecilius on the Sublime, 39-45.

Caine, Hall, 240.

Carigal, rabbi, 176.

Cassel, Paul, 110.

Cervantes, 109.

Cheyne, T. K., 321.

Chilmead, Edmund, 138, 139, 140, 141.

Chwolson, Daniel, 110.

Cicero, 33.

Cobbett, William, 200.

Cohen, F. L., 101, 208.

Cohn, 26.

Coleridge, S. T., 214-219, 224.

Coleridge’s _Table Talk_, 214-219.

Conder, 325-332.

Conybeare, F. C., 25, 26.

Cowley, A. E., 80.

Crawford Haggadah, the, 92, 96.

Creighton, bishop, 113.

Crump, C. G., 260.

Cromwell, Oliver, 138, 139, 147, 337.

Cumberland, Richard, 191, 193, 201, 275.

Da Costa, H. Men., 174.

Dahl, Basil, 304.

Dalman, G., 62.

Dante, 263.

De Rossi, Azariah, 116-121.

De Rossi’s _Light of the Eyes_, 116-121.

De Sola, 79, 80.

Degli Mansi, Italian Jewish family, 60, 118.

Deity, depicting of the, 92, 93, 152.

Delitzsch, Franz, 340-346.

Demosthenes, 33.

Deutsch, Emmanuel, 190.

Dickens, Charles, 227.

Didot, M., 151.

Disraeli, Benjamin, 226-232, 336.

Disraeli’s _Alroy_, 226-232.

Disraeli, Isaac, 229.

Dobson, Austin, 125.

Doré, biblical pictures of, 254.

Drake, C. F. Tyrwhitt, 328.

Dutuit, M., 151.

Efros, Israel, 102.

Eichler, German artist, 161.

Eisenmenger, 189, 288.

Eliezer, son of Hyrkanos, 273.

Eliot, George, 229, 321.

Elisha ben Abuyah, 244, 348.

_‘En Ya’akob_, 102-107.

Ephrathi, Joseph, 265.

Epictetus, 32.

Espinasse, Francis, 153.

Erasmus, 110, 113.

Essenes, the, 20.

Eusebius, 48, 330.

Ezekielos, Jewish Greek poet, 46-52.

_Faithful Shepherdess_, by Fletcher, 127.

_Family Papers_, by Wilhelm Herzberg, 283-289.

Fettmilch riot, 130.

Finzi, David, 118.

Fishberg, Maurice, 345, 346.

Fletcher’s _Faithful Shepherdess_, 127.

Frankel, Z., 288, 352.

Frankfurt, Moses, 103.

Franzos, Karl Emil, 276-282.

Friederich of Brandenburg, 160.

Furnivall, 269.

Gaffarel, J., 136.

Gaster, Moses, 172.

Gautier, 325.

Geiger, Abraham, 349.

Geiger, L., 72.

Gellius, Aulus, 33.

Gibbon. E., 233.

Gidney, W. T., 353.

Gifford, 48, 49, 50, 51.

Ginzberg, L., 54, 221.

Gladstone. W. E., 276, 317.

Glenelg, Lord, 233.

Goethe’s _Faust_, Hebrew translation of, 306.

Goldsmid, Isaac Lyon, 183.

Goldsmith, Oliver, 136, 334, 335.

Gordon S. L., 304.

Graetz, H., 44, 62, 71, 72, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 129, 184, 187,
188, 189, 228, 287, 350, 352.

Grant, Robert, 233-239.

Green, A. L., 335.

Grossman, Louis, 348.

Grotius, 214.

Guarini and Luzzatto, 122-128.

Güdemann, M., 65.

Günzburg;
_see_ Stassof and Günzburg.

Gutzkow’s _Uriel Acosta_, 240-246, 265.

Haes, Frank, 92, 93, 96.

Haggadah, of Sarajevo, 91-96.

Hahn, Joseph, 129-135.

Hahn’s Note Book, 129-135.

Hai Gaon, 53, 66.

Halper, B., 9, 18, 274, 304.

_Hamlet_, Hebrew translation of, 304.

Handel, 265, 290, 291.

_Ha-Tikwah_, by N. H. Imber, 359-364.

Havell, H. L., 40.

Heine, H., 81, 321.

Henry, Michael, 311-318.

Herder, Johann Gottfried von, 184-190.

Herder’s Anthology, 184-190.

Herodotus, 46, 51.

Herzberg, A., 288.

Herzberg, Wilhelm, 283-289, 339.

Hesiod, 51.

Hillel, tanna, 53, 251.

Hoffmann, G., 18.

Homer, 40, 41, 57, 263.

Hühner, L., 176.

Hurwitz, Hyman, 216, 217.

Hutten, Ulrich von, 109.

Huxley, 218, 219.

Ibn Ezra, Abraham, 66, 261, 269;
_see also_ Aben Ezra.

Ibn Gebriol _Royal Crown_, 77-83.

Ibn Gebriol, Solomon, 77-83, 97.

Ibn Habib, Jacob, 105, 106, 107.

Idelsohn, 360, 363.

Imber, Naphtali Herz, 359-364.

_Iris_, by Franz Delitzsch, 340-346.

Isaac Pinto’s Prayer-Book, 171-177.

_Isaac’s Lamp and Jacob’s Well_, 102-107.

Israels, Josef, 307.

Italia, Salom, engraver, 151, 152.

Jacob ben Nissim of Kairuwan, 54.

Jacobs, Joseph, 84, 88, 89, 90, 270, 271, 274.

James, William, 182.

Jastrow, Marcus, 62.

Jastrow, Morris, 176.

Jeffery, 213.

Jellinek, Adolf, 245, 300, 301.

Jellinek, Hermann, 245, 246.

Jellinek, Moritz, 245.

Jerome, 353.

_Jews of Barnow_, by K. E. Franzos, 276-282.

Johanan ben Zaccai, 274.

_Johanan Hakkadosh_, by Browning, 270, 271.

Johnson, Samuel, 136.

Johnson’s Rasselas, 87.

Josaphat;
_see_ Barlaam and Josaphat.

Josephus, 32-38, 44, 273.

Joubert, 110.

Judah ha-Levi, 28, 79.

Judah the Prince, 55, 57, 58, 59.

_Judas Maccabæus_, by Longfellow, 290-296.

Juvenal, 109.

Kalir, 79.

Kalisch, Marcus, 333-339.

Kalonymos ben Kalonymos, 109.

Karpeles, Gustav, 81, 82.

Kaufmann, David, 287.

Keats, John, 95.

Kimhi, David, 46, 86, 87.

_King Lear_, Hebrew translation of, 304.

Kinnaird, Douglas, 208, 211.

Kipling’s _Recessional_, 193.

Kirchner, 162.

Kirkpatrick, 222.

Kohler, K., 273.

Kohut, Alexander, 62, 64.

Kohut, G. A., 172, 174, 175.

Krassensohn, N. P., 303.

Krauss, S., 34, 330.

Kuiper, 47.

Lactantius, 49.

Lamb, Caroline, 210.

Landor, 260-266.

Lavater, 161.

Lazarus, Emma, 319-324.

Lee, Sidney, 170.

Leeser, Isaac, 182, 247, 249, 252, 254-259.

Leeser’s Bible, 254-259.

Leibnitz, 109.

Leon Modena’s _Rites_, 136-143.

Lessing, 166-170, 184, 188, 194, 269, 273, 303.

Lessing’s First Jewish Play, 166-170.

Letteris, Meir, 306.

_Letters from Obscure Men_, 108-115.

Levi, David, 254.

Levi, Lyon, 201.

Levy, S., 101.

_Life Thoughts_, by Michael Henry, 311-318.

Lilien, E. M., 95.

Longfellow, 290-296.

Longinus, 39-45.

Lucas, Mrs. Henry, 77, 80, 98, 99.

Luria, Isaac, 28, 158.

Luther’s version of the Bible, 309.

Luzzatto, Moses Hayyim, 122-128.

Lyon, Solomon, 211.

Lytton, Bulwer, 207, 213.

Macaulay, Thomas, 58, 159, 277.

MacDonald, George, 276.

Mackay, popular versifier, 317.

Maimonides, 24, 58, 84, 140.

Mallock, W. H., 337.

Mandelkern, S., 213.

Marlowe, Chris., 194.

Martyrologies of the Jews, 68.

Massel, Joseph, 291.

Meir, tanna, 244.

Meisel, W. A., 86.

Menasseh ben Israel, 147-151.

Mendelssohn, Moses, 166, 167, 178-183, 187, 188, 189.

Mendelssohn’s _Jerusalem_, 178-183, 254, 269, 303, 313.

Mendes, F. de Sola, 287.

_Menorat ha-Maor_, 102-107.

_Meor ‘Enayim_, 116-121.

Michaelis, 167.

Middleton’s _Descriptive Catalogue of the Etched Work of Rembrandt_,
149.

Mieses, Fabius, 303.

Milton, John, 36, 237, 306.

Modena, Leon, 136-143, 166.

Molière, 227.

Montefiore, C. G., 29, 343.

Montefiore, Sir Moses, 168.

Monypenny, 226, 227, 228, 229.

Moore, Thomas, 200, 213.

More, Sir Thomas, 113.

Moses, Longinus on, 40, 41.

Müller, Johann Conrad, 161.

Müller, Max, 66.

Müller and Schlossar, publishers of Haggadah, 91.

Murray, Fairfax, 151.

Murray, Gilbert, on “The Rise of the Greek Epic,” 57.

Murray, John, 207, 208.

Murray’s Palestine Handbook, 354, 355.

Musafia, Benjamin, 62.

Nathan of Rome’s Dictionary, 60-66.

Nathan, Isaac, 194, 207-213.

Neubauer, A., 55, 56, 69.

Niemeyer, 168.

Nieto, Isaac, 171, 172.

Nordlinger, Joseph;
_see_ Hahn, Joseph.

Nusbiegel, G., 161.

Ockley, 139.

Oesterley, 136.

Orr, Mrs. Sutherland, 271.

_Othello_, Hebrew translation of, 303-310.

_Paradise Lost_, Hebrew translation of, 306.

Pascal, 109, 113, 261.

Pass, Ernest de, 316.

_Pastor Fido_, by Guarini, 122-128.

_Path and Goal_, by Marcus Kalisch, 333-339.

Pfefferkorn, 110, 112, 113, 288.

Philippson, Ludwig, 254.

Philipson, David, 348.

Philo, 24-31, 35, 44, 120.

Phoenix of Ezekielos, the, 46-52.

Picart, Bernard, 162.

_Piedra Gloriosa_, 147, 151, 152.

Pinto, Isaac, 171-177.

Pinto, Joseph Jesurun, 174, 175.

Piyyut by Bar Abun, 97-101.

Plato, 337.

Pliny, 33.

Plutarch, 44.

Pompey, 43.

Pool, David, 171.

Possart, 170.

_Pronaos_, by I. M. Wise, 347-352.

Prothero, 211.

Rabelais, 109.

Rashi, 63, 65.

Raspe, Rudolf Eric, 194.

Reinach, Théodore, 41, 42, 43, 44.

_Rejected Addresses_, by Horace Smith, 199-204.

Rembrandt, 147-151.

Renan, E., 108.

Reuchlin, J., 111, 112, 115.

Roth, C. M., 161.

Rousseau, 184.

_Romeo and Juliet_, Hebrew translation of, 304, 310.

Rothschild, James, 305.

Rothschild, Lionel de, 336.

_Royal Crown_, by Ibn Gebriol, 77-83.

Rubin, Salomo, 241.

Ruskin, 307.

Sa’adya, 46.

Sabbatai Zevi, 228.

Sachs, Michael, 78, 79, 80.

_Sacred Poems_, by Robert Grant, 233-239.

Salaman, Mrs. R. N., 77, 97.

Salfeld, 69, 70.

Salkind, Solomon, 305.

Salkinson, I. E., 303-310.

Schiller, F., 305.

_Salomon_;
see _Alfieri and Salomon_.

Samuels, M, 183.

Sarajevo Haggadah, the, 91-96, 152.

Schelling, 214.

Schlegel’s translation of Shakespeare, 305.

Schlossar, _see_ Müller and Schlossar.

Schmidt, Cæsar, 286.

Schopenhauer, A., 82.

Schudt, anti-Semite, 114, 115, 288.

Schürer, E., 43, 44.

Schurzfleisch, 42.

Scott, Walter, 193, 194, 195, 196, 200, 204, 210.

Scott’s _Ivanhoe_, 193, 194, 196, 231.

Shakespeare, William, 89, 184, 214, 224, 274, 294.
Hebrew translations from, 303-310.

Sheridan, 333.

Sherira, Letter of, 53-59.

Sidney, Philip, 266.

Singer, Simeon, 32, 172, 173, 248, 300.

Slousch, Nahum, 306.

Smith, Horace, of the _Rejected Addresses_, 199-204.

Smith, James, of the _Rejected Addresses_, 199-204.

Smolenskin, Perez, 303, 309, 310.

Solomon, S. J., 95.

Solomons, I., 150, 151, 152.

_Sorrows of Tatnu, the_, 67-73.

Spicer, H., 240.

Spinoza, Baruch, 181, 241, 242, 244, 245.

_Spirit of Judaism_, by Grace Aguilar, 247-253.

Stassof and Günzburg, publishers of the Haggadah, 91.

Steele, Richard, 114, 115.

Steinschneider, M., 78, 88, 175.

Stern, 69.

Stevenson, 213.

Stiles, Ezra, 176, 177.

Stobbe, 69.

Stokes, Francis Griffin, 111, 114.

Sublime, Caecilius on the, 39-45.

Suidas, 42.

Sully, James, 184.

Surrenhusius’ Latin Mishnah, 162.

Swift, J., 112.

Swinburne, A. C., 207.

Symonds, John Addington, 123, 124.

Tacitus, 34.

_Tatnu, Sorrows of_, 67-73.

Tennyson, Alfred, 290, 317, 318.

_Tent Work in Palestine_, by Conder, 325-332.

Tertullian, 72.

Thackeray, H. St. J., 119.

Theobald, 309.

Theocritus, 128.

Therapeutae, 26, 28.

Thomson, 325.

Tiberius, emperor, 33.

Titus, 61, 117.

Treitschke, German historian, 71.

Tree, Herbert, 240.

Trench, 186.

_Uriel Acosta_, by Gutzkow, 240-246.

Vaughan, Henry, 238.

Vaughan, R., 162.

Vogelstein, 62.

Voltaire, 109, 175, 303.

Vossius, Isaac, 147, 149.

Wagenseil, 288.

Walker, George, 191-198.

Walker’s _Theodore Cyphon_, 191-198.

Wellhausen, Julius, 186, 333, 350.

Wendland, 26.

Wharton, Edith, 112.

Whewell’s _Astronomy_, 222.

White, Joseph Blanco, 220-225.

Williamson, 154.

Wise, Isaac Mayer, 347-352.

Wolf, Lucien, 226.

Wordsworth, William, 166.

Yellin, David, 362.

Yellin method, the, 248.

_Yosif Omez_, by Joseph Hahn, 129-135.

Zangwill, Israel, 80, 88, 228, 240, 359.

Zedner, J., 103.

Zunz, Leopold, 97, 98, 102, 116, 118, 119, 120, 254.

The Lord Baltimore Press

BALTIMORE, MD., U. S. A.

Transcriber’s Notes

Punctuation errors have been corrected.

Page 93: “to repoduce the whole of the text” changed to “to reproduce the whole of the text”

Page 126: “moveover that the happy period” changed to “moreover that the happy period”

Page 242: “had beeen” changed to “had been”

Page 314: “pomote peace” changed to “promote peace”