Chapter II: Part 2

“No, I never have seen them together,” she said. “No reason why not. After all, Harry Colton isn’t too good, in spite of his money. Now that his father is broke, I don’t know what he will do.”

Aunt Judy came out on the porch to cool off.

“Who are you folks plottin’ against?” she asked.

“The forces of evil, Aunt Judy,” replied Nell.

“Well, it must have been pleasant plotting--the way you’ve been smiling. Isn’t she a sweet girl, Hashknife?”

“Aunt Judy!” protested Nell.

“I’ve been thinkin’ that all along,” grinned Hashknife.

“How come you never got married?” asked Aunt Judy.

“Well,” replied Hashknife thoughtfully, “I don’t reckon I’ve ever had time. My old Dad was a range-ridin’ sky-pilot up on the Milk River in Montana. He had a houseful of kids, and mighty little money to take care of ’em. When I was still a sprout, I got a horse and a riding rig. I had itchin’ feet. Dad said, ‘Son, I’ve been watchin’ yuh a long time--lookin’ at them hills. You want to see what’s on the other side. When you was born the good Lord put a wanderin’ brand on yuh. I’ve seen that brand growin’. You’ll never call any place home, never be held by any ties. I’ve tried to teach yuh to shoot square--it’s the best I can do.’”

“And you started wandering,” said Aunt Judy.

“All my life, Aunt Judy-- Dad’s prophecy was right. Sleepy is of the same breed--we can’t stay put.”

“Helping people,” said Nell quietly.

“Who told you that?” he asked.

“Eddie Connors. I think it is wonderful. We need help, Hashknife.”

Hashknife squinted thoughtfully across the hills. After a long pause he said, “Yeah, I reckon yuh do, Nell.”

“Johnny and me were going to get married Christmas Eve.”

“That ain’t far away, Nell, and there ain’t much to work on, but we’ll hope that it’s all written our way in the Big Book.”

“Big Book?” queried Aunt Judy quickly.

“There is a big book, yuh know, Aunt Judy,” said Hashknife.

“I’ve never heard of it before.”

“I’ve never seen it,” smiled Hashknife. “No mortal’s eyes have ever seen it--but the finger of Fate writes in that book. It shows what we do, how we live, how we die--and when.”

“That’s fatalism!” exclaimed Aunt Judy. “You don’t believe in that, do you, Hashknife?”

“I believe,” replied Hashknife, “that you’ll never die until your number is up on the board, Aunt Judy. Bein’ careful is a human trait, but it won’t save yuh. Men have gone through hell and high water all their lives, only to trip over a chair in the dark and break their neck. What’s yore argument against it, Aunt Judy?”

“Well, I--when you started, I had several--but I guess I’ve forgotten what they were.”

“School is dismissed,” grinned Hashknife.

* * * * *

It was a wonderful supper. Aunt Judy was a fine cook, and Sleepy almost ate himself under the table. They got back to Tomahawk Flats about nine o’clock, and were standing in front of the Pasatiempo Saloon, when a horse and buggy drove up. A man had just come out of the saloon, and the driver called to him, asking directions for finding Thomas Colton’s home. Then the buggy turned and went back up the street. The man had leaned out of the buggy, his face full in the lights of the saloon. Hashknife said quietly, “Did you see that feller, Sleepy?”

“No, I didn’t pay any attention. Sort of a fat man, wasn’t he?”

“Sort of--yeah. I’ve seen that face before, but I can’t quite place him. C’mon.”

“Are yuh goin’ to try and run him down?” asked Sleepy.

“I hadn’t thought of that--but I’m curious.”

Thomas Colton’s home was only two blocks off the main street, but there were no lights on the street, and the night was dark. They found the horse and buggy at Colton’s front gate. There were lights in the house, but the windows were shaded. Sleepy wanted to know why they ever came down there, in the first place. Didn’t Mr. Colton have any right to have a visitor.

Hashknife laughed. “That visitor,” he said, “is a man we both knew in Wyomin’, Sleepy. His name was Slim Regan. What it is now, who knows?”

“Slim Regan?” queried Sleepy. “I ’member him. He was a gambler and a promoter, wasn’t he?”

“That’s the person--I’m dead sure. Maybe he didn’t recognize me--my back bein’ to the light, and we ain’t seen him for at least five years. Maybe he’s livin’ straight now--who knows?”

They started back, when they heard footsteps on the wooden sidewalk, coming from the opposite direction. The walker was wearing spurs. It was too dark for them to see him, but he turned in at Colton’s gate and went to the house. There were no lights, when the door was opened, but they heard it close behind him.

“Maybe the Coltons are havin’ a party,” suggested Sleepy.

Hashknife didn’t offer any suggestions, but started down the road, heading in the direction from which the spur-wearing person came. After a short distance they cut over to the sidewalk, and went on, until they found the horse, tied to a tree almost at the outskirts of town. It was a tall roan animal, and with the aid of a match they were able to decipher the Bar N brand on the animal. Sleepy said, “That’s Buck Nolan’s mark, Hashknife.”

They sat down in the darkness and waited possibly fifteen minutes, but no one came along.

“Even if he did come for the horse, it’s too dark to recognize him. Anyway, there ain’t no law,” said Sleepy.

“I reckon yo’re right,” agreed Hashknife.

“No use settin’ here.”

They were almost back at Colton’s house, when they heard the rasp of buggy-wheels, as the vehicle was turned around. A few moments later the horse and buggy came past them, traveling fast, heading back toward where the horse was tied. The Colton house was dark.

“Well,” remarked Sleepy, “what’s funny about that?”

“I didn’t say it was funny,” replied Hashknife.

They went up to their room at the hotel and went to bed. Sleepy said, “Ain’t we even goin’ to try and get prices on ranches?”

“We’ll let Colton see what he can do first. After all, he knows values better than we do.”

* * * * *

They met Thomas Colton next morning, and he asked them if they had discussed prices with any of the ranchers.

“We’re leavin’ that to you, Mr. Colton,” said Hashknife.

“Well, that is right, Mr. Hartley. No use of both of us working on the same idea. Are you leaving here soon?”

“I’ll tell yuh,” replied Hashknife soberly, “if we can buy at a good price, we might take over a spread ourselves.”

This seemed to confuse Colton. He said, “Well, I--yes, of course. I had no idea you--well, why not?”

“If we got it cheap enough,” said Hashknife. “We like this range. After all, a feller ought to settle down.”

“Yes, I believe--we will talk about it again, Mr. Hartley.”

Mr. Colton went on. Sleepy braced against a porch-post, looked inquiringly at Hashknife.

“Settlin’ down, eh?” he remarked. “That’s wonderful. Goin’ to buy a ranch. Total assets about twenty-five dollars.”

“If we could get it cheap enough--” said Hashknife.

* * * * *

Aunt Judy and Uncle Andy came to town before noon, and were talking with Hashknife and Sleepy in front of the sheriff’s office, when Buck Nolan came riding up to the office. He nodded to them, started for the office doorway, when the sheriff came out.

“Nick, there’s a buggy wrecked in Horseshoe Canyon,” said Nolan. “I saw where it went over the rip-rap, and it’s down there about a hundred feet below the grade. I was comin’ down from Northgate and--”

“Yuh mean--a buggy and team went off the grade, Buck?”

“It sure looks like it, Nick. Yuh can see some of the buggy, all smashed up on the rocks down there.”

“I’ll get Frenchy. You take us back there, Buck. Maybe Hartley and Stevens will go with us; we’ll need plenty help. I wonder who went off the grade.”

Hashknife looked curiously at Buck Nolan, big, raw-boned, just a bit gray. Buck was riding a sorrel, bearing his own brand. Then Hashknife and Sleepy hurried to the stable to get their horses. Sleepy said, “I’m wonderin’ a little, too, Gardner.”

“We don’t know the man--if its Regan,” said Hashknife.

“I know what yuh mean,” said Sleepy.

It was several miles out to Horseshoe Canyon. Frenchy went along, but showed little interest. He was sober, but his brown eyes were bloodshot from too much whiskey.

The coroner went in a spring-wagon, taking plenty ropes along. The wheelmarks on the edge of the grade were very plain, and they could see part of the smashed buggy. There was a trail into the canyon just above the wreck, and they went down on foot.

Slim Regan had been thrown clear of the buggy, but straight into a jumble of jagged rocks. The scent of whiskey still lingered on the dead man’s clothes, and there was a smashed bottle in the bottom of the buggy. They took the body to open ground, where the coroner examined the pockets of his clothes, but all they found was a pocket-knife and a few dollars in silver coin. There was not a scrap of paper to identify him.

It was quite a task, getting the body back to the grade. The coroner said that there was no question of its being an accident. Hashknife made no comments. The coroner could be right, except that the wheel marks on the edge of the grade showed the buggy traveling south, instead of north. Sleepy had noticed that detail, too.

As they rode together off the grade, the latter said, “If Slim Regan wanted to pile his carcass into the canyon, why did he turn the buggy around and make the dive? It’s just as fatal, goin’ north as it is south.”

Hashknife nodded grimly. He said, “Keep yore eyes open, pardner--there’s brains workin’ down here. They didn’t want anybody to know that Regan was in Tomahawk Flats last night. Regan rode up in front of the Pasatiempo Saloon and asked a man where Tom Colton lived. Who was the man he asked, Sleepy?”

Sleepy scowled thoughtfully, and finally said, “Hashknife, I ain’t exactly sure. Yuh see, I wasn’t payin’ much attention, but I kinda seem to remember that it was Gus Staley. I can’t be sure--but I think it was. He works for that feller Hack.”

“Yeah, that’s right. Regan went to see Tom Colton, stayed there maybe half an hour, and then pulled out. Regan is a gambler.”

“Was,” corrected Sleepy, “until he hit bedrock. What do yuh make out of it?”

Hashknife didn’t say. He thought it over and finally remarked, “Sleepy, I wish we knew who the man was who walked in the dark and wore spurs.”

“And rode a Bar N roan,” added Sleepy. “But what does it add up to?”

“I dunno. Doc Talbert said he’d make a complete examination of the body. That might help our case.”

But Doctor Talbert’s examination didn’t help them any. Any evidence of foul play, except by gun-shot, would have been wiped out by the man’s fall onto the rocks. Nick McGarvin asked that everybody take a look at the body, hoping that someone would identify him, but to no avail. The keeper of the livery-stable at Northgate had rented him the horse and buggy, but had no idea where the man was going. He gave the name of Jim Hendricks, paid in advance for the rig, and said he would be gone overnight. Asked about Hendrick’s having any baggage, the stableman said he wasn’t sure, but believed the man had a small valise.

Hashknife met Sam Hack and Gus Staley on the street and stopped to talk with them.

“Did you look at the dead man, Staley?” he asked.

“Yeah--sure, I seen him, Hartley. I don’t--”

“Think back,” said Hashknife. “Wasn’t he the same man who drove up in front of the Pasatiempo that night and asked you how to find Thomas Colton’s house?”

Gus Staley looked blankly at Hashknife. “I dunno what yuh mean,” he replied. “I never seen the man before. You must mean somebody else. I never seen him in a buggy in my life.”

“I see,” murmured Hashknife. “Well, it don’t matter.”

“Didn’t the man run off the grade _comin’_ here?” asked Hack.

“Yeah, it looks thataway,” replied Hashknife. “A couple hundred yards further along the grade is a place where he could turn his outfit around. Maybe he was comin’ back--I dunno.”

“You ain’t sure he _ever_ was down here, are yuh?” asked Hack.

“Him or his ghost.”

“Ghost?” Staley spat viciously into the dusty street. “You don’t believe in ghosts, do yuh, Hartley?”

“I know what I have seen,” replied Hashknife seriously, “but I never try to impose my ideas on other people.”

“That’s all damn foolishment!” snorted Staley. “When yo’re dead--yo’re dead, and that’s all there is to it.”

“That’s the best way to look at it,” remarked Hashknife.

* * * * *

Hashknife and Sleepy did not go to the funeral of Chiquita Morales, but they heard that Frenchy Arnett paid most of the expenses. Thomas Colton had approached Uncle Andy regarding selling the AD, but Uncle Andy avoided making any definite price. He knew he would have to sell eventually, but held off. Hashknife talked with Johnny at the jail, but Johnny was little help. He stuck to his story that he’d traded the ring to Chiquita for a pinto horse, and that she didn’t wear the ring to that dance in Mexico. Hashknife didn’t tell Johnny that he’d found the ring in the Morale’s buggy. Johnny said, “I’m stuck, Hashknife. If Chiquita had lived, she could have testified that I didn’t own the ring.”

“That,” said Hashknife, “is why she died. Johnny, do yuh know of any man around here she liked well enough to give that ring?”

Johnny shook his head. “Chiquita, I believe, was a good girl. She liked a good time, and she didn’t have to want for men to take her places. She wanted money, fine clothes and all that. Yuh see, a cowpoke’s wages don’t cover that, Hashknife.”

“Where did she get her finery, Johnny. Pete Morales couldn’t afford to buy things for her.”

“Yeah, that’s right--I never thought of that. Well, she never tried to get money from anybody--as far as I know.”

“Johnny, did Harry Colton ever go out with her?”

Johnny leaned against the bars of his cell and thought it over. Finally he said quietly, “I’m just wonderin’.”

Johnny might have said more, but Frenchy Arnett came in. He was sober, but grim-faced. Hashknife said, “Frenchy, wouldn’t you like to know who shot Chiquita?”

Frenchy shut his eyes tightly for a moment and his jaw tightened. “Sure would,” he said quietly, but firmly. “I know she went to a dance with Oren Blakely. That was right; Oren didn’t do it. Damn right, I’d like to know, Hartley.”

“Maybe you can help us find him, Frenchy. Did you ever give her money to buy clothes?”

“Give Chiquita money? No! Why do you ask that?”

“They say she wore nice clothes.”

“Chiquita always looks nice--silk skirt, pretty shoes.”

“Pete Morales didn’t have money to buy them with, Frenchy.”

Frenchy thought it over. Suddenly he faced Hashknife, his eyes hot. “You mean to say somebody gave her money--Chiquita?”

“Keep cool,” advised Johnny. “Hashknife wants to help.”

“She was my girl,” said Frenchy huskily. “If she wanted money, I’d give it to her. Who gave her money? Oren Blakely didn’t have money to give to women. Who gave her money?”

“You knew about Johnny tradin’ her that ring for a pinto?”

“Sure--I heard that. That is all right--the pinto belonged to her.”

“Frenchy, Chiquita loaned or sold that ring to the man who killed her. Johnny is in jail for a robbery, and the evidence is that ring he traded Chiquita. She could have told who had that ring. She didn’t tell, because she didn’t want that man in jail--but he didn’t take a chance.”

Frenchy shrugged his shoulders. “Chiquita go out with other men. Sometimes I warn not here--sometimes I have no money to spend. I am not her husband--I can’t say no. Maybe she don’t tell me. That is her business.”

“Frenchy, did she ever go out with Harry Colton?” asked Hashknife.

Frenchy’s lips shut to a thin line and he walked over to a barred window, but came back.

“I think she did,” he said quietly. “I accuse her of it, but she just laughed at me. How did you know this, Hartley?”

“I didn’t--I just wanted to find out what men she went out with. Chiquita is gone now, Frenchy. Nothing can change that. Our job is to find the man who did it.”

“Sure, she’s gone--now,” breathed Frenchy and walked away, his eyes filled with tears. Hashknife looked at Johnny and shook his head. “I’ll see yuh later,” he told Johnny.

* * * * *

Hashknife met the sheriff and Sleepy in the office. Hashknife said, “Nick, I’ve had a talk with Johnny and Frenchy.”

“Yeah? Did yuh find out anythin’ yuh already didn’t know?”

“If anybody asks yuh, Nick,” replied Hashknife soberly, “you can tell ’em that Dancin’ Devil is in for some surprisin’ things--very soon. In fact, before Christmas.”

Nick McGarvin’s jaw sagged a trifle. “Yuh mean--yuh know somethin’, Hashknife?”

“You’d be surprised, Nick.”

Leaving the sheriff to think this over, Hashknife and Sleepy walked back toward the hotel.

“He’d be surprised, eh?” remarked Sleepy.

“That’s what I told him, Sleepy.”

“What’d he be surprised about?”

“The few things I know, pardner. Listen, will yuh? Our only chance to find out somethin’ is to scare the guilty into doin’ somethin’. It works, when brains fail--and I don’t mind admittin’ that mine have failed.”

“I know what yuh mean,” said Sleepy quietly. “We paint black circles around our heads, with a bull’s-eye in the middle.”

“That’s right. Nick’s human. He’ll pass the word.”

“Well, all I can say is that we better find a quiet, remote spot, where we can practice dodgin’ bullets,” said Sleepy. “Yuh know, I think I like it better than settin’ around, pardner. This ain’t our idea of a good time, anyway.”

“But just remember, Sleepy; we ain’t dealin’ with dumb rustlers in this game--but I figure that even the smartest men will get scared and make a break--when they’re scared, enough.”

* * * * *

Tomorrow night would be Christmas Eve. They brought m a big fir tree for the little church, but it seemed that the Christmas spirit was lacking. Someone told Hashknife that Thomas Colton was going to be the Santa Claus for the church celebration. The Davidsons and the Frawleys were in town, and Uncle Andy told Hashknife that Colton had asked him to make a price on the AD.

“He wanted it in a hurry, too,” declared Uncle Andy. “I told him it wasn’t anythin’ I could hurry with.”

“Did he suggest any price?” asked Hashknife.

“Well,” replied Uncle Andy grimly, “he said I’d be lucky to get much more than the cost of the mortgage.”

“What about Frawley?”

“He’s goin’ to talk to Colton this afternoon, he said.”

“Tell him to hold off makin’ any deal, Uncle Andy.”

The little cowman looked quizzically at the tall cowboy.

“What’s time got to do with it, Hashknife?” he asked.

“Well, maybe a better price. Anyway, you’ve got plenty time, after the notice of foreclosure to redeem the property.”

“Not with the mortgages from Colton. It specifies that when the bank shuts down on the mortgage--yo’re through.”

“I see. Mortgage expires--ranch gone, eh?”

“That’s the only way he’ll loan money, Hashknife.”

A few minutes later he met Ed Frawley, who drew him aside.

“What’s goin’ on?” asked Frawley quietly. “A man over in the Pasatiempo told me that--well, he said somethin’ was goin’ to happen before Christmas--somethin’ you said. At least, that’s the rumor.”

“I hope it’s right, Frawley. Funny how things like that get in the wind.”

“You mean--there’s ain’t anythin’ to it, Hashknife?”

“_Quien sabe?_” replied Hashknife soberly. “A lot can be done in an hour--and Christmas ain’t until day after tomorrow.”

He found Sleepy in front of the hotel, and told him, “I reckon Nick McGarvin spread the word.”

“I heard it,” nodded Sleepy. “Frenchy Arnett cornered me, and wanted to know. He said, ‘If yuh know who shot Chiquita--don’t arrest him; just let me know who he is.’ I said we would. Aw, I didn’t mean it--but what else could I tell him? He ain’t no deputy sheriff now--he’s a wolf with the rabies, pardner.”

The Davidsons and Frawleys stayed in town for supper. Hashknife and Sleepy stayed together, ate supper in a little Mexican restaurant, where they could sit against the wall. The Mexican who operated the restaurant, usually very voluble, was quiet, serving the enchiladas and frijoles hurriedly, one eye on the door.

“I wonder what he’s thinkin’,” remarked Sleepy.

“I wonder what he _knows_,” said Hashknife. “They tell me he was Chiquita’s uncle. Maybe he don’t want his place messed up with us.”

It was dark outside, as they paid their bill. With a hand on the knob, Hashknife drew back, turned and came back to the little counter, where the Mexican was at his cash-box.

“_Amigo_, is there a back door to this place?” he asked*

“Sure,” nodded the Mexican. “Go t’rough the keetchen.”

They went swiftly through the kitchen, redolent with spices and other odors, out through an old door and into the alley. There was a short, narrow alley, leading to the main street, and they could see the silhouette of a man, leaning against the right-hand wall, evidently watching for somebody. Hashknife kicked a wooden box aside, making a clatter, and the man moved quickly, stepping up on the wooden sidewalk.

Hashknife didn’t hesitate, but led the way up the alley. The man had passed the little restaurant and was standing at the edge of the sidewalk just beyond. It was too dark for them to see what he looked like, except that he was tall. Finally he went on up the street toward the hotel.

“Do yuh think he was tryin’ to dry gulch us?” asked Sleepy.

“Who knows? He was waitin’ for somebody, but we scared him away from the alley. He could look through the window and see that we’re gone.”

They went slowly up the sidewalk, watching closely, until they were at the front of the hotel. Hashknife peered through the window, as he heard Frank Olds, the hotel man, speak sharply to someone. Olds was over near the foot of the stairs, looking up toward the hallway, when he suddenly lifted his arms, shaking his head and protesting, but began walking up the stairs, both hands up.

Hashknife jerked away from the window, whispered sharply:

“Stay here! Trouble in there,” and ran down the alley toward the rear stairs of the hotel.

Sleepy moved over to the open doorway of the hotel. The sheriff was crossing the street, and Sleepy said, as he came up:

“Hold it, Nick--until we hear from Hashknife.”

“What’s wrong?” asked the big sheriff.

“I don’t know, Nick. Hashknife saw somethin’ through the window, and he ran around to the back stairs. He told me to--”

Sleepy stopped, when two, closely spaced shots rattled the windows beside them. Both men sprang through the doorway, into the hotel, as a figure staggered into view, sagged at the top of the steps and came pin-wheeling down into the lobby. Hashknife ran to the top of the stairs, gun in hand, stopped for a moment, but came on down. Behind him came the disheveled, excited hotel man, waving his arms.

The stranger was sprawled at the foot of the stairs, tall, gaunt, unkempt. Hashknife was looking down at him, as Sleepy and the sheriff came over. The excited hotel man was jabbering:

“He stuck me up, I tell yuh! Made me come up there, or he’d kill me. Hartley, how on earth did you ever beat him? He heard you comin’ up the stairs. How did you beat him?”

“I didn’t beat him--he missed me,” said Hashknife coldly.

“That’s Cass Trent!” exclaimed the sheriff. “Why he’s-- Hartley, there’s a half-dozen rewards for this hombre. He’s livin’ across the border for over a year. He’s a killer.”

“Was,” corrected Sleepy, and looked around at the crowd, swiftly gathering. The sheriff said:

“What was Cass Trent doin’ here--stickin’ up a hotel?”

“He wasn’t stickin’ me up,” denied the hotel keeper. “He was goin’ to bush somebody in that hallway. I came and peeked down the stairs and I seen him. I told him to git out of here, and I was goin’ up and run him out--but I didn’t. Man, the bore in his gun looked like a tunnel in a hill!”

“Goin’ to bush somebody?” queried the sheriff. “Who?”

No one seemed to know. Nick McGarvin looked at Hashknife and found the tall, lean cowboy smiling a little. The sheriff said, “Oh,” and waited for Doctor Talbert to arrive.

A search of Trent’s pockets revealed five hundred dollars in currency, all in a packet, and the usual impediments carried by cowboys. They took the body to the doctor’s place. Nick McGarvin said, “He got what was comin’ to him. Hashknife--yore cleared--and congratulations. They say Cass Trent never missed.”

“They all miss sometimes, Nick,” said Hashknife soberly.

“But why would he try to bush you?” asked the sheriff. “You didn’t even know him.”

Hashknife shook his head. “No, I didn’t, and I never heard of him, until now. He was hired to kill me, Nick.”

“Hired? Good gosh! Who hired him, Hashknife?”

“I can’t tell yuh--’cause I’m not sure.”

* * * * *

The excitement was mostly over, as soon as the body was removed, but there was still a lot of discussion going on. Trent’s name was well-known down there. Hashknife and Sleepy went over to the Pasatiempo Saloon, listening to the gossip. Harry Colton was at the bar, already more than half-drunk. Hashknife shoved in beside him, and Colton resented it. However, he looked at Hashknife, and decided to give him room.

Hashknife was only at the bar a few moments when the sheriff came in. Men were asking him questions about the affair at the hotel, when Hashknife drew him aside, whispered a few words. The sheriff looked at him in amazement, but finally nodded. About a minute later the sheriff arrested Harry Colton, who tried to shove the law officer away, swearing indignantly. The incident brought a lot of attention, but the sheriff was firm.

“Harry, yuh better go peacefully,” he said.

“You’re crazy!” snarled the young man. “Why arrest me? What’s the charge?”

“Murder,” said the sheriff coldly. “You killed Chiquita Morales.”

“That’s a lie!”

“It’s the truth, Harry. You’ve still got that turquoise ring. It’s in yore pocket. Take it out--and deny it!”

The arrest had sobered Harry Colton. Swearing his innocence, he felt in his pocket and took out the turquoise ring. He took one good look at it and flung it at the back-bar. The next moment the big sheriff had crashed Colton against the bar and deftly handcuffed him. Harry Colton was not swearing nor protesting now, he seemed too stunned to even notice the crowd, as the sheriff led him outside. The bartender recovered the ring, and gave it to a man to give to the sheriff.

Word that Harry Colton had been arrested for the murder of Chiquita Morales spread swiftly. The sheriff was in a quandary as to what to do about Frenchy Arnett. Hashknife got Frenchy aside and explained to him that arrest didn’t mean that Harry Colton was guilty. Frenchy laughed shortly, but promised to keep his trigger-finger under control.

“I think yo’re wrong, Hashknife,” confided the sheriff.

“Maybe I am,” admitted Hashknife, “but it’ll stir things up.”

“It shore will, if a mob decides to lynch Colton.”

Sleepy showed up, having been on a mission, and reported quietly, “Sam Hack went to tell Thomas Colton, but he’s back at the Pasatiempo. I heard Colton tell him he’d be right up to the jail.”

“You stay here and keep yore eyes open, pardner,” ordered Hashknife, and went swiftly up the street.

Hashknife wasn’t sure of anything. When he had dropped that turquoise ring into Harry Colton’s pocket, he was acting on a vague sort of hunch; a hunch that this was the time to force the issue. There was a light in the living-room of the Colton home. Colton hadn’t been to the jail. Hashknife came straight to the house, so it was evident that Thomas Colton was taking his own sweet time in reacting to the arrest of his son. Hashknife circled to the rear of the house, working along a low fence, when he heard a door close quiet. A moment later someone came toward the fence, climbed over it and headed south. The man was evidently carrying something, which he lifted over the fence.

* * * * *

Hashknife trailed him as close as he dared. The man crossed the street, far from any lights and walked swiftly down the road, which led south from Tomahawk Flats. But he only went a short distance and stopped off the road. A minute later he was coming back. Hashknife dropped flat, as the man went past him, panting a little. He saw him turn into the main street.

Hashknife saw the man was not carrying anything when he returned; so he went on in the darkness, just off the road, searching as well as he could in the darkness, and almost fell over a valise, which had been left behind a small clump of brush, only a dozen feet off the road. The heavy valise was locked, and Hashknife didn’t bother to try and open it. He picked it up and went back to Colton’s house, where he left the valise against the low fence.

There was a light in the house, but the blinds were down.

Hashknife tried the kitchen door and found it unlocked. Quietly he opened the door, and listened, but there was not a sound. He closed the door, moved ahead to the partly opened doorway, which opened into the living-room, stepped aside against the wall and waited for something to happen.

He had been there about ten minutes, when he faintly heard footsteps on the plank walk, which led from the street. There was a sharp knock at the front door, and then the door opened. He was unable to see who had come, but heard more than one come in. A voice called:

“Colton!”

* * * * *

When there was no reply, he heard a man swear bitterly, damning the Colton family back several generations.

“Where the devil did he go? He never came to the jail. Yuh don’t suppose--?” a voice began.

“Suppose what?” asked another man.

“Never mind. Where did Hartley go? I seen Stevens there, but I didn’t see that long-legged bloodhound. That damned Trent! He made a mess of the deal. Five hundred dollars, all shot!”

“Never mind the five hundred dollars,” said the other nervously. “We’ve got to find Colton. Don’t yuh realize that Harry will talk? He ain’t got the guts of a cottontail. Let’s head south.”

“No, we won’t head no place--not till we find Colton. Damn it, we’ve got to find Colton! Where did that ring come from?”

“That beats me. I threw it away, I tell yuh. I heard it hit the buggy--maybe that fool Harry found it. He’s half-crazy, anyway. He should have been dumped into the canyon with Regan. We’d have been safe, that’s a cinch.”

“Regan got what was comin’ to him. Askin’ the Association to send a man down here to buy ranches! Said it’d look legitimate. Legitimate--hell! They sent Hashknife Hartley. He found it out, and lost his nerve. Scared to write or wire us--came down himself, and wanted to get out of the deal.”

“Never mind what happened to Regan--what’ll happen to us?”

“Nothin’!” snapped the man. “Maybe we’re through here, but we can live like kings in Mexico. Yuh see--”

The man stopped short. Hashknife heard the door click shut, and Colton’s voice saying, “Keep your hands where they are--both of you.”

“What’s eatin’ you, Colton?” asked one of the men anxiously.

“What did you two do with that valise?”

“Are you crazy? What valise?”

“Don’t lie to me--you got it. I cached it beside the road, got Harry’s horse and saddle, and when I got back there--it was gone. I’ll give you ten seconds to tell me where--”

There was the sound of a scuffle, the thud of a falling body, and a voice drawled:

“Jist set right there, my fine-feathered friend! Pick up his gun, before he gits any bright ideas. Standin’ on a loose rug ain’t safe, Mister Colton--not when I’ve got m’ toe through a hole in one end of it. All right, all right! This gun’s easy on the trigger, my friend. Start tellin’ us where yuh put the money.”

“Money!” panted Colton, his voice husky. “You fools, I want to know where _you_ put it. Put that gun away. Listen; I couldn’t leave the money here; so I cached it. along the road--in a valise--but it’s gone, I tell you!”

“Ain’t he a cute thing?” queried a voice sarcastically. “Why, you lyin’ pup! Scared somebody’d find it! You was goin’ to pull out with the money, and leave us to face the music. I’ve got a damn good notion to blow yore head off, Colton. Maybe I will. If you don’t--”

“Sh-h-h-h-h!” hissed a voice. “Somebody comin’!”

“Git in that chair, Colton! Guns out of sight!”

Someone knocked on the door, and one of the men said, “Come in!”

Hashknife heard the door open, and a voice said, “Come in, Sheriff. Oh, Mr. Stevens, too!”

Hashknife stepped into the doorway, shoving the door wider. He could see Colton, white-faced, sitting in a chair, looking toward the doorway. He could also see part of one of the other men, and he held a gun behind him, and cocked.

“Colton, you didn’t show up,” Nick McGarvin said, “and--and we’ve got to tell yuh. Harry had a gun hidden on him some’ers--and he shot himself. No, he ain’t dead, but--he-e-ey! What’s this all about?”

“Set down!” rasped one of the men. “Keep yore hands in sight. All right, Colton--where’s that money? Our money? Our only chance is to get out of here now--and we don’t go without that money.”

“I told you,” husked Colton, “that somebody got it. If you two didn’t----”

“You ain’t lyin’, Colton?”

“Would I lie--now? I’ll hold these two. Get your horses, and we head for Mexico.”

“Broke? Colton, I don’t trust you--not a bit. Tell us where that money is, or I’ll shoot yuh flat. If we can’t get the money, why should we bother with you, you sneakin’ coyote. Either you get that money--and we all go south--or you die here and we pull out together.”

“He ain’t givin’ yuh much choice, Colton,” said Sleepy. “Yuh might as well play square with ’em.”

“Keep yore nose out of this, Stevens!” snapped one of the men. “One cinch, when we leave here--_you_ won’t be on our trail.”

“Hashknife will,” reminded Sleepy calmly. “And if yuh ask me, I don’t believe yo’re goin’ any place. Yuh see, yuh don’t know where he is.”

“Hartley!” whispered Colton. “Maybe he followed me an’--”

“I’m gettin’ out!” declared a man.

“Money be damned--my hide’s worth more’n any money.”

The man wasn’t taking any chances with his partners. With his forty-five tensed at his hip, he began backing toward the doorway to the kitchen. The door was open just wide enough to let him through--but he didn’t make it. A dull thud sounded, just as he was almost out of their sight, and he went right back, head down, shoulders sagging, buckled at the knees and sprawled flat onto his face, almost into the sheriff.

* * * * *

For a moment it seemed that everyone except Sleepy was off guard. Sleepy shot out of his chair and dived into one of the men, blocking his gun-hand, and the force of his dive crashed over the table, knocking the lamp off, and plunging the room into darkness. A gun flashed twice, but the spurts of flame went straight toward the ceiling. Hashknife flung the door wide open, as a man came at top speed, but the tall cowpoke dropped to his knees and the man tripped, going into the air and coming down with a crash against the old kitchen stove.

Hashknife was on him like a flash, gathering in the man’s two arms.

“Light somethin’, will yuh?” Sleepy was yelling. “I think this hombre is petterfied, but I’d like to be sure.”

The amazed and excited McGarvin managed to light matches. Sleepy was astride Sam Hack’s back, his hands locked behind him, and Sam Hack was having trouble getting enough air. McGarvin quickly handcuffed him.

“When yuh get a little time on yore hands,” Hashknife called, “I could use some rope or somethin’. Better find a lamp, Nick; you’ll burn yore fingers with all them matches.”

Sleepy came out with a rush, lighting matches, while the sheriff found and lighted a lamp. Thomas Colton had struck his head against his own stove and was in no shape to try a getaway. They dragged him into the living-room, and stood back, panting a little. Gus Staley groaned and sat up, trying to caress his aching head. He peered at the three men, who were looking at him, groaned dismally and lay down again.

Someone had heard the two shots, which knocked shingles off the roof, and in a few moments plenty of folks were running forward. Sleepy tried to keep them back, but it was no use. Uncle Andy and Ed Frawley were there, Buck Nolan, Frenchy Arnett, and most everybody else, who could get in. The sheriff was at a loss as to what to do next; so Hashknife took charge.

“Folks, will yuh give us room, please? Gus Staley! Gus, do yuh know what I’m sayin’?”

“To hell with you!” groaned Staley. “I don’t talk.”

“If you don’t, one of the others will. And the man who talks first gets off easiest. Shall I wait for the others?”

Gus Staley, his eyes just a bit off center, looked at the faces around him and decided to talk. He said, “I didn’t do it.”

“All right,” said Hashknife, “we’ll start from the first, Gus. You and Hack and Harry held up the bank and took all the money.”

“It wasn’t stealin’,” whined Staley. “Colton planned it. His idea was to break the county--and buy it back, cheap.”

“And Harry wore that turquoise ring, eh?”

“He bought it from Chiquita--and forgot he had it on.”

“You shot Oren Blakely, Gus.”

“That’s a lie!” husked Staley. “Hack killed him. He refused to go in on the deal, got scared and pulled out. Hack was afraid he’d talk. I liked Oren. Hell, I wouldn’t have done it--myself.”

“Why did you kill Chiquita Morales?”

“Hack got scared,” whispered Staley. “Harry was a fool to wear that ring. Chiquita could have told who had it. Harry wanted to make Chiquita swear that he never had the ring, but Hack said the safest thing was to shut her mouth. I wasn’t there--it was Hack and Harry. Yuh can’t kill women and have yore luck last.”

“Who hired Trent to shoot me tonight, Staley?”

“Colton. He paid him five hundred dollars.”

“Gus, we know why and how you fellers killed Regan. Wasn’t he usin’ the name of James Morrison?”

“Yeah--he was the syndicate--the yaller pup.”

“Folks,” said Hashknife wearily, “you’ve heard the story. I can’t tell yuh any more. In fact, if Gus hadn’t been scared, I couldn’t have told yuh half that much.”

Uncle Andy and Ed Frawley shoved their way over to the sheriff, and Uncle Andy said, “It all came too fast, Nick. Does this mean that Johnny’s free?”

“Why, shore he’s free. Don’t paw me around--go and paw Hashknife.”

But Hashknife wasn’t in sight. He and Sleepy had gone through the crowd and were outside, heading for the main street. Uncle Andy went galloping past them, intent only on finding Aunt Judy and Nell Frawley. They paid their bill at the hotel. The old hotel keeper said, “Some excitement, eh? I heard there was more trouble down at Tom Colton’s home. What happened down there--or don’t yuh know?”

“That’s right,” nodded Hashknife and they walked out, smack into Aunt Judy, Nell Frawley and Uncle Andy. Uncle Andy grabbed Hashknife by the sleeve and turned him around, while Aunt Judy planted a kiss on his cheek. Not a word had been said, until Hashknife said, “Aw, gee!” He turned Aunt Judy around, facing the lights of the hotel, and she was crying.

“I thought that kiss kinda ran a little,” he said. “When yuh see Nick, Uncle Andy, you tell him that valise-full of money is jist outside Colton’s south fence.”

“No, yuh don’t!” whispered Uncle Andy. “No, yuh don’t. Eddie Connors said that you two allus pull out on folks. You’ve got yore war-sacks with yuh--but yuh ain’t goin’. Nossir, yuh ain’t. This time, yuh don’t go. Hashknife Hartley, tomorrow night is Christmas Eve--and you brought peace to Dancin’ Devil. Johnny’s free to marry Nell t’morrow night--we get our money back--and you just _try_ to leave here!”

“You won’t go--will you?” asked Nell, her voice choked. “You can’t even think of it, Hashknife--not this time.”

“Well,” said Hashknife quietly, “I reckon we _can_ stay.”

“Can stay!” snorted Uncle Andy. “You’ll stay, if I have to hog-tie yuh. You ain’t the right size nor the right shape, but if Sandy Claus ever came to Dancin’ Devil Valley, yo’re him.”

“Let’s go get Johnny,” said Aunt Judy quietly. “The sheriff just went down there.”

* * * * *

Hashknife and Sleepy, still holding to their war-bags, stood in the hotel doorway. Frenchy Arnett came past, stopped and looked at them. Sleepy said, “How’r yuh comin’, Frenchy?”

“I’m all right,” replied Frenchy. “Everythin’ is all right. Yuh see, Chiquita _sold_ that ring; she wasn’t tradin’ it. Yeah, I reckon it’s all right.”

Frenchy went on. Sleepy said, “Well, yuh can’t run away from everythin’. Maybe they’ll make you best man. But tell me somethin’, Tall-Feller; how’d you manage to suspect Tom Colton?”

“’Member the first time he talked with me, Sleepy. He had a telegram from James Morrison, who turned out to be Regan. After we took this job, Regan didn’t have time to get a letter about us, and the telegram didn’t mention who we were. But Colton said, ‘After all, the Cattlemens’ Association wouldn’t recommend a man who wasn’t capable.’ How would he know who recommended us, unless he had another wire ahead of the one I read?”

“That wasn’t much to go on,” said Sleepy.

“It was enough,” smiled Hashknife. “Maybe I better send a telegram to Bob Marsh, and tell him the ranches ain’t for sale.”

“Yeah, that’s a good idea, pardner; and when yuh write it--give him my regards, will yuh?”

They grinned at each other, went back and registered again.

[Transcriber’s Note: This story appeared in the October 25, 1948 issue of _Short Stories Magazine_.]