Chapter XXXVII: Section 6: ,216, same as 303, N. Y. P. C (18)

Coutagne,[835] in twenty-four necroscopies on subjects hung, found only slight or doubtful lesions in five cases; but of these, one was in a condition of advanced putrefaction, another was apparently weakened by loss of blood from wounds, and in the other three there were marks of violence. In seventeen cases the lesions of the neck were plain; hemorrhage in connective tissue or muscle.

The direction of the mark is usually oblique, following the line of the lower jaw upward and backward behind the mastoid processes; it may, however, be horizontal. If the ligature encircles the neck more than once, one mark may be circular, the other oblique. If a running noose is used the mark may be circular, and be seen all the way around the neck, looking like the mark of a strangulation. Taylor[836] states that if the noose should be in front, the mark may be circular, the jaw preventing the ligature from rising upward in front as much as it does behind. If it encircles the neck but once, its continuity is apt to be broken by the prominence of the hyoid bone, thyroid cartilage, sterno-mastoid muscles, etc.

In four-fifths of the cases (117 out of 143, Tardieu) the mark is found between the chin and larynx; in nearly all the remaining fifth, over the larynx; in a very few below the larynx; the last position is due to the protection of the neck by a handkerchief or beard, or where there is some anatomical or pathological peculiarity which prevents the ligature from going higher.

Hofmann[837] had seen two cases of tumor of neck; one in a woman, where the cord was below the larynx; and in a man where it was over the larynx. He quotes[838] as follows: Remer, above larynx, 38; over larynx, 7; below larynx, 2. Devergie, above larynx, 20; over larynx, 7; below larynx, 1. Casper, above larynx, 59; over larynx, 9. Roth[839] in 49 cases found the ligature mark above the hyoid bone in 5; between the bone and the larynx, 31; over the larynx, 8; below the larynx, 1. Hackel found the ligature in forty per cent of cases between hyoid bone and larynx; in sixty per cent lower down. The ligature always appears lower after the body is laid down than it was in suspension. Maschka found the furrow 147 times in 153 cases above the larynx.

The mark will vary in character according to the kind of ligature used, its mode of application, the vitality of the tissues, and the period that has elapsed since death. The result is different according as the knot or loop is single or double, a running or slip knot.

The mark may differ in character in one part of the neck from another. The same furrow may be soft in one part and dry in another. The width of the mark does not necessarily correspond to the diameter of the ligature. A double mark usually means that the ligature has been twice passed around the neck, although the marks may not be continuous or parallel. Tardieu states that a large single leather thong pressing on the neck only by its borders may make a double mark. The mark is usually _depressed_. The depth of the depression, groove, or furrow, as it is called, is greater the narrower and firmer the ligature, the longer the suspension, and the greater the weight of the body. The mark may be merely a slight depression, without color, or only a red blush, if the subject is young, tissues healthy, and suspension brief. Roth,[840] in 49 cases of hanging, found the furrow of the ligature was brown in 40, red-brown in 6, and 3 times bluish.

In about two-thirds of the cases the bottom of the furrow, the place of greatest pressure, is white, especially so where the knot is tied; while the edges of the furrow are usually slightly raised and red or livid. If the subject is very fat, there may be only a slight depression. Harvey[841] says that this hard, white, shining, translucent band from compression of the connective tissue is the first stage of the parchment or vellum skin, and is chiefly noticed in fresh bodies. The borders are swollen and œdematous, called by Lacassagne “_bourrelet de sillon_.”

The skin beyond the furrow is usually violet. Authors differ as to whether this is due to congestion or hemorrhage. Roth[842] in 49 cases found swelling below the furrow 27 times. Hackel found ecchymoses above the mark in thirty-five per cent of the cases of hanging. Hofmann thinks that the lividity of the upper border of the furrow is due to the stopping of the venous blood descending from the head.

The dry, hard, yellowish-brown, or reddish-brown “parchment” furrow, described by writers, is said to be common. Ogston[843] found it in one-third of his cases. It is found only when the body has remained suspended for several hours after death; indeed, may be produced by applying the ligature to the cadaver; is not at all, therefore, a proof of suspension during life. Liman states that constriction by a ligature even for some time does not necessarily cause a mummified or excoriated furrow. He saw cases in which the mark was soft, flat, scarcely colored, but little interrupted, and not parchmenty. The parchment skin seems to depend very much upon a previous excoriation of the skin. Its appearance can be prevented or delayed by examining a body soon after death or by rehanging it; and after it has appeared it will disappear on the application of some liquid. Taylor[844] compares this parchment mark to the cutis from which the cuticle has been removed for two or three days.

Slight abrasions and ecchymoses are sometimes found in the furrow. Ecchymoses alone do not indicate whether suspension has been before or after death; but abrasions with hemorrhage strongly suggest suspension during life. Devergie regards ecchymoses of the neck as strongly suggestive of homicide. Neyding[845] says that suggillation in the groove is oftener found in strangulation than hanging. And Bremme[846] that there is no hemorrhage in the subcutaneous tissue of the mark if death occurs at once and the cord is removed at once after death; but if the cord remains for some time after death there may be hemorrhage, or if death does not occur at once, whether the ligature be removed or not.

Roth[847] found ecchymoses or small bladders at the lower margin of the furrow, 9 times in 49 cases. Riechke found only once in 30 cases a hemorrhage beneath and on both sides of the mark. Chevers did not find ecchymoses of the skin of the mark in cases of hanging. Casper found no ecchymoses in 50 of 71 cases. Maschka has seen two cases where burns on the neck resembled mark of ligature.

The furrow, when once distinct, remains constant for a long time after death, even in putrefaction. Marks from soft substances, however, disappear sooner than those from strong and uniform compression.

The NECK nearly always appears stretched. According to Roth the mobility of the head is increased by this stretching. The HEAD is always inclined to the opposite side to that of the knot. In suicides the head is usually bent forward on the chest. The HANDS are often clinched so tightly that the nails are driven into the palms. This occurs more especially when the hanging has been done with violence. When the feet touch the ground, as often occurs in suicide, the hands may be stretched out. Roth found the hands and feet flexed in 44 of 49 cases. Taylor says that we may expect to find the hands clinched when constriction of the neck is sudden and violent. The LEGS are usually livid.

The FACE varies with the duration of the suspension; at first it is pale, afterward livid; congested and swollen, if the subject has been long suspended. Roth found the face pale in 43 of 49 cases. In about one-half the cases the features are calm and placid (syncope). Maschka found the lips bluish in 98 of 153 cases. The EYES are often prominent, staring, and congested, and usually the pupils are dilated. Lacassagne and Maschka[848] look upon ecchymoses of the eyelids and conjunctivæ, “_piqueté scarlatin_,” as important as favoring the idea of hanging or strangulation. Roth found in 49 cases the eyelids closed 28 times; half open, 12; congested in 6; ecchymosed in 2. Pupils dilated in 31; narrowed in 2. Dilated in 97½ per cent of Ogston’s cases (Cases 85, 86; rupture of crystalline lens). Harvey[849] says the blood was found flowing from the EAR in 6 cases of nearly 1,500, but no details were given. Ogston, one case. Hofmann saw a case in which there was bleeding from the ears. He says this is not due, as has been supposed, to rupture of the tympanic membrane, but to hemorrhage from subcutaneous vessels (Case 27).

The TONGUE is usually livid and swollen, especially at the base. According to Tidy, Dr. Guy looks on this as showing that suspension took place very probably during life. In about one-third of the cases the tongue is protruded and compressed between the teeth; sometimes bitten. Some observers found it protruded only as a result of putrefaction. The protrusion of the tongue is not believed to depend on the position of the ligature. Hackel in 67 cases found the tongue lying forward in all cases where the cord was between the larynx and the hyoid; in 55 per cent in front of the teeth, in 18 per cent between the teeth; where the ligature was lower down, the tongue was behind the teeth. He found by experiment that in the spasmodic expiratory effort the tongue was thrust forward; in the inspiratory movement, drawn backward. He concluded that the forward movement was the result of reflex action. Maschka[850] found the tongue between the teeth 58 times in 149 cases. Roth in 49 cases found the tongue projecting and bitten in 22, the teeth shut in 15 others; in 15 the mouth was open; the tongue was retracted in 30 cases.

Harvey, after examining reports of nearly fifteen hundred hangings, says: “In the majority of instances immediately after death the features were placid, the face pale, the eyes not unduly prominent, the mouth closed or half open, the tongue pressed against the teeth but not protruding; the superficial veins full, but the head, neck, and trunk free from lividity. After a longer or shorter time, however, and apparently after a very few hours, in India, all this is changed. Livid patches appear about the chest, back, and shoulders; the face and head become bloated and puffy, the tongue and eyes protrude.”

Bloody froth is sometimes seen at the nose and mouth.

SALIVA is invariably secreted and runs out of the mouth down on the chin and chest. Its presence is considered as evidence that suspension occurred during life. The URINE and FÆCES are sometimes found to have been expelled. These discharges occur in all kinds of violent death. Tardieu found them, however, but twice in 41 cases of hanging. Roth in 49 cases found discharges of fæces in 17 and urine in 4; in 15 cases not noticed.

Harvey mentions a case where internal piles had burst, and there were stains and clots of blood about the perineum and anus. In such cases without careful examination there would naturally be a suspicion of violence.

In about one-fourth of the cases the GENITAL ORGANS are congested. The penis is large and more or less erect; seminal fluid, generally prostatic, and sometimes mixed with blood, is often expelled. The fluid may pass only into the urethra and it may be necessary to press the urethra to secure it. The clitoris may be found erect, and there may be a sort of menstrual flow. Orfila showed by experiment that swelling of the sexual organs and emission of semen can be produced after death in those who had been suspended during life. The flow of semen is found in all kinds of death by violence. Roth in 39 cases of hanging of men found the penis enlarged 18 times and ejaculation in 19. Hackel found the penis swollen in 43 per cent of cases of asphyxia. Erection may come on soon or late, even days after death.

=Internal Appearances.=—The CONNECTIVE TISSUE UNDER THE MARK is usually white and condensed, the more so if the body has been long suspended. This dryness or condensation was found by Hackel in 52 per cent of hangings. Deeper-seated parts are injured only when the hanging has been violently done. The MUSCLES, especially the sterno-mastoid, are sometimes ruptured. Hofmann[851] reports several cases. Lesser[852] in 50 hangings saw 11 ruptures of muscle. Maschka never saw the rupture in suicides. The sterno-mastoid was ruptured in the case of Wirtz (Case 96) and Guiteau (Case 95). Hackel in 67 cases failed to find the muscle ruptured. Hofmann[853] believes that the rupture of the muscle is sometimes post mortem. Coutagne[854] found the sterno-mastoid muscle ruptured once in 24 cases (Cases 29, 89, 95, 96).

The LARYNX may be fractured or dislocated. These lesions are very rare in suicide; more frequent in homicide and judicial hanging, and in the old where the cartilages are calcareous. Remer found the injury in but 1 case in 101 of suicidal hanging. Barker found the larynx _lacerated_ in his judicial cases.[855] Harvey says that the TRACHEA was reported lacerated 11 times in nearly 1,500 cases; twice the laryngeal cartilages were separated from each other. In 5 these cartilages were fractured, but there was nothing to show under what conditions. Hemorrhage in vicinity of larynx, 43 times. Pellier[856] reports 1 case, and adds that the existence of the lesion easily escapes notice because of the mobility of the cornua. Roth in 49 cases failed to find any fracture. Pellier found the cricoid was injured oftener than the thyroid, which is the reverse of what is found in strangulation. Cavasse[857] was unable to cause fracture of larynx by hanging the cadaver. Chailloux[858] collected 6 cases of fracture of larynx in hanging. He concluded that the fracture could not be produced on the cadaver by hanging, and is, therefore, caused during life. Coutagne[859] in 24 cases found fracture of thyroid cartilage 8 times (Cases 9, 51, 82).

The HYOID BONE is rarely dislocated. Orfila mentions a case of fracture. Barker found the bone usually fractured in judicial cases. In the case of Wirtz (_supra_) the greater cornu was broken. Pellier reports 2 cases. Hofmann[860] says the hyoid cornua are often fractured, especially when the ligature is between the hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage. Coutagne found fracture of hyoid bone 8 times in 24 cases. He attributed the fracture to pressure against the spine. Pellier speaks of fracture of STYLOID PROCESS (Cases 51, 84, 88, 89, 95, 96).

Dr. Barker, of Melbourne,[861] states that in 50 cases of hanging by the old method there was not one case of _fracture or dislocation of vertebræ_. After adopting his suggestion to place the knot near the spine, he found that dislocation occurred between the second and third cervical vertebræ with fracture of the third and pressure on the spinal cord. Death was sudden and complete. The drop in these cases was short, three to four feet. Coutagne thinks that the ordinary mobility of the head, axis, and atlas on each other have led reporters into the mistake of supposing a dislocation of vertebræ. Roth failed to find fracture of vertebræ in any of 49 cases. These injuries are especially rare in suicide; but in violent hanging, dislocation or fracture may occur and also rupture of the ligaments. Harvey gives 5 cases of dislocation of vertebra and 4 of fracture of vertebra in suicides. Three of the latter were doubtful. Tardieu says these fractures have no significance as to the hanging having occurred during life. They can be produced on the cadaver; but infiltration of clotted blood around injured vertebræ shows that suspension occurred during life (Cases 5, 7, 8, 68, 76 to 79, 83, 84, 91, 92, 94).[862]

The CAROTID ARTERIES may be injured; usually the inner and middle coats are torn; and hemorrhage may occur into the wall of the vessel. The common carotids are the ones usually affected, and just below the bifurcation, but the external is also occasionally injured. The injury is said to be due to the stretching and squeezing of the artery, stretching being the most effective since the rupture often occurs at a distance from the mark of the ligature. Such injury of the artery does not prove that hanging took place during life because it has been produced on the cadaver; but hemorrhage into the wall of the vessel or wound or rupture after death is very improbable. Maschka says the lesion is very rare. Tardieu says that the injury to the carotid is rare and therefore unimportant. Pellier reports 4 cases of rupture of carotid in a total of 23. Levy records the experiments of Hofmann, of Vienna, and Brouardel and himself, of Paris, 5 in number. He concluded that compression of the carotid arteries, if it produces obliteration, can cause rapid loss of consciousness and death; and explains why in incomplete suicide the subject is unable to help himself. Coutagne found rupture of carotids 10 times in 24 cases. He insists on the importance of the lesion.

Hofmann[863] says the rupture is always transverse, may be simple or multiple and may occur in suicides; more apt to occur when the ligature is thin. Lesser[864] tabulated 50 fatal cases of suicidal hanging; in 29, he was satisfied that the hanging occurred during life. In 3 of these the skin of the neck alone showed any lesion; there was a double mark, the skin being otherwise bloodless. In 5 the deeper soft parts were the only ones affected. In 3 the skin showed lesions, the deeper soft parts none, but either the hyoid bone, larynx, or vertebræ were involved. In 12 the skin showed no mark, but the deeper soft parts and either the larynx or hyoid bone were involved; and in 6 the hyoid bone only or the bone and larynx were injured. In the remaining cases it was not possible to say that the hanging occurred during life. In 2 cases there were no marks at all; in 9 there were changes in the skin; in 4, changes in the skin and deeper parts; in 2, changes in the skin, deeper parts, and hyoid bone or larynx; in 3, changes in the skin and hyoid bone or larynx, or both. In 14 of the 50 cases the hyoid bone was fractured; in 20 the larynx; and in 1 the vertebræ. The common carotid arteries were injured in 6. The number and severity of the lesions bore no constant relation to the thickness of the ligature, nor to the force used, but rather to the position of the body.

Ecker[865] reported a case of suicidal hanging in a man, age 40, where the soft palate was swollen and filled up the passage so that the air evidently could not enter.

The LARYNX and the TRACHEA are usually deeply congested, of a red color; a violet color indicates putrefaction. Ogston reports mucus but not bloody froth 9 times in the pharynx, 6 in the trachea, and 4 in the lungs, in a total of 40 cases. In one case there was a quantity of blood in the larynx and pharynx. Taylor thinks that pinkish froth in the trachea indicates incomplete obstruction; and Chevers that it is due to spasmodic efforts to breathe when the obstruction is nearly complete. Chevers always found clear mucus in the larynx and upper part of trachea, each follicle being marked by a minute globule of mucus. Harvey states that this was noted a few times in his reports. Baraban[866] discusses the condition of the epithelium of the air passages in hanging.

The condition of the lungs and heart varies according to whether death is due to syncope or asphyxia. Ogston found, in 22 cases, the lungs were expanded in 4 and collapsed in 2.

Harvey says the LUNGS are congested in over seven-eighths of the cases; emphysematous in a few; and subpleural ecchymoses present in a few. Patenko[867] experimented on dogs by hanging them. When the constriction occurred after expiration the lungs were congested; when after inspiration, not congested. In the first case (p. 223) the blood flows from the periphery to the heart and thence to the lungs, but cannot flow from the lungs because of the difficult circulation in the dilated pulmonary vessels and deficiency of intrathoracic pressure. There is in both cases cerebral congestion in the region of the bulb. Tardieu holds that punctiform ecchymoses and apoplexies do not occur in hanging unless suffocation has preceded. Pellier,[868] however, found these ecchymoses 14 times in 22 cases. He says that the lesion is not characteristic of suffocation, and quotes Lacassagne, Grosclaude, Dechoudans, Vicq, Chassaing, and Legroux to the same purpose. Hofmann[869] says that the ecchymoses are relatively rare in adults. Maschka[870] found them 18 times in 153 cases.

Harvey states that the presence of serum in the PERICARDIUM seems more a matter of time elapsed after death than anything else. Still the fact is that it is found much oftener in strangulation than in hanging. The difference is explained by the comparative slowness of death in strangulation. Harvey finds that in about one-half of the cases, if the body is fresh, the right side of the HEART, pulmonary artery, and venæ cavæ are full of dark fluid blood, the lungs being also much congested, and the signs of death by asphyxia well marked. When blood is found in both sides of the heart, it is probable that death is due to neuro-paralysis. When decomposition is advanced all the cavities are often empty. Taylor says that if the examination is delayed for several days, the distention may not be observed.

The STOMACH is often much congested, and this fact might sometimes suggest the possibility of poisoning. The LIVER, SPLEEN, and KIDNEYS are usually much congested. Hofmann[871] says that this occurs in the kidney only when the body has been hung a long time.

The BRAIN is rarely much congested. In 101 cases Remer found hemorrhage but once; and in 106 cases Casper failed to find it. Tardieu[872] says the brain is oftenest anæmic. If, however, the body is cut down and placed horizontally, the blood-vessels of the brain may fill up. Evidence may be found in the brain suggesting insanity and therefore an explanation of a probable suicide. Harvey says that hemorrhages in or about the brain are found in a much larger proportion of cases in India than in Europe in cases of hanging. “No common condition likely to cause extravasation is apparent, only one man being noted as plethoric, but in many the rope seems to have been very tight.” Champouillon[873] reports a case of suicide in a man, age fifty-two; the rope broke and the body fell. The physician who made the necroscopy reported a rupture of the _pons Varolii_. Champouillon believed that the rupture must have been made in removing the brain from the skull. Wilkie[874] reports a judicial hanging in which a man age about twenty-five, fell about three and one-half feet. A recent clot was found in the brain. The experiments of Brouardel of hanging rabbits showed the brain anæmic.

The conjunction of the following appearances would suggest that the hanging had been of some duration: lividity of face, congestion and prominence of eyes, dryness of skin under the ligature, deep furrow, congestion of sexual organs, swelling and lividity of lower limbs, hypostatic congestion of lungs.

Page experimented on a young cat and young dog; both were hung in the same way. Examination of the cat showed the veins generally engorged; sublingual veins much engorged; tongue protruded slightly and much swollen; no frothy mucus in bronchi. In the dog the tongue did not protrude and was not swollen; right cavities of heart contained blood, left empty; brain and other organs normal. In the cat, the lungs were uniformly congested, dark red; no ecchymoses. In the dog, the lungs were much distended, posterior borders mottled violet; emphysematous patches on surface; no apoplectic effusions; subpleural ecchymoses bright red, irregular, clearly defined in outer surface, most numerous toward the roots and on the lower lobes.

Pellereau[875] gives an account of hanging as seen by him in warm climates. He had not seen the elongation of the neck described nor the erection of the penis, nor subconjunctival ecchymoses, nor fracture of larynx, nor rupture of walls of carotid artery, nor subpleural ecchymoses, nor fracture of vertebra. He always found a mark on the neck; the left cavities of the heart always empty, the right always full of black blood. Mackenzie says that in 130 cases of suicidal hanging, the protrusion of the tongue between the teeth, the open and protruding eyes, clinched hands, and blue nails were very frequent, the tongue was found bitten many times, there were urethral and rectal discharges and rupture of carotid artery. The penis was found erect several times. The hyoid bone fractured 24 times in 93 cases. In no case was the larynx or vertebra fractured. In 73 cases ropes were used; in 30, portions of clothing. The marks of ropes were always well defined, indented, and parchment-like; the marks of soft ligatures faint and reddish. In no case were the muscles of the neck, the larynx, trachea, or large bronchi injured, and in none was there subcutaneous hemorrhage or blister.

PROOF OF DEATH BY HANGING.

As in strangulation, no single sign in any given case is sufficient of itself to prove that death was caused by hanging. But the sum total of the lesions found, viewed in the light of the surroundings of the body, will suffice to lead to a definite conclusion.

The fact that a body has been found suspended does not of itself prove that hanging caused the death, because the victim may have been killed in some other way, and the body afterward hung up to avert suspicion. Chevers records many cases of this kind.

The value of the presence or absence of marks on the neck and the characters of the marks has been questioned. Orfila, Casper, and Vrolik have shown by experiment that if a body is hanged within one or two hours after death the furrow, parchment skin, lividity, and the density of the connective tissue will appear just as is seen when suspension has occurred during life; but ecchymoses and infiltration, clotted blood in the skin, connective tissue, and muscles of the neck suggest suspension during life.

If a cord is removed _immediately_ after death, there may be scarcely any mark at all.

Tardieu collected 261 cases of suicide by hanging where the subject was not entirely off the ground. In 168 the feet rested on the ground; in 42 the subject was kneeling; in 29 lying down; in 19 sitting, and 3 were huddled up or squatting. Fatal hanging may, therefore, occur in almost any position of body. He shows incomplete hangings by thirteen plates. Taylor also collected reports of 11 cases in a few years; in 3 the subjects were nearly recumbent; in 4, in a kneeling position; in 4, sitting. Remer in 101 cases of suicidal hanging found in 14 that the body was either standing or kneeling; in 1, sitting. Duchesne published 58 cases of partial suspension, 26 of which were new. Some of these failures of complete suspension were due to soft and elastic cords.[876]

Taylor says that “that which is difficult to a conscientious medical jurist in confining himself to the medical facts is often easily decided by a jury from these as well as the general evidence afforded to them.”

The limbs may be secured by the suicide before hanging himself. Persons even with some disability of the hand have suicided by hanging. Blindness is no obstacle, nor age; a boy as young as nine and a man as old as ninety-seven.

Burger[877] fully discusses the question whether the hanging is before or after death.

HANGING—SUICIDAL, HOMICIDAL, OR ACCIDENTAL?

Hanging is usually =suicidal=. Lesser[878] states that for three years, 1876-79, there were admitted to the Berlin morgue 274 bodies of “hanged,” of which 272 were suicidal; 2 infants of three and eighteen months, homicidal. One man had first tried to kill himself with sulphate of copper; another by cutting his throat; a woman by cutting her arm. The other cases were uncomplicated. Pellier states that the number of suicides in France from 1876-1880 was 13,445, and nearly all were by hanging. Taylor[879] states that 2,570 persons committed suicide by hanging in England in five years, 1863-67; four-fifths of these were males. Harvey[880] reports for three years 1,412 cases of hanging in India, of which 2 were accidental, in 3 there was presumption of homicide, the rest probably all suicidal.

Feebleness of body does not preclude subjects taking their lives in this way. They sometimes also wound or poison themselves first and hang themselves afterward. A subject being found suspended in a room fastened on the inside, would be suggestive of suicide. The absence of signs of struggling or of any marks of injury also favors the idea of suicide.

The possibility of a suicide breaking a rope, being injured by the fall, and rehanging himself successfully, must be admitted (Cases 57, 58). The possibility of blood flowing after death must not be forgotten.

It is worthy of note that after beating or other violence children and women may commit suicide from shame. Again, as Tardieu says, many have hung themselves while partially intoxicated, and it is likely that some such have just previous to the suicide met with falls or other accidents which have left marks like those of violence. He also records the case of a woman who fastened a cord to a bed-post, put her head in a noose while kneeling on the bed, and made a deep wound in her arm with a razor. She closed the razor, laid it aside, and fainted from loss of blood. She must then have fallen forward and died from the pressure of the cord on her neck.[881]

=Homicidal= hanging is rare but does occur. Where the hands are tied together; where the injuries produced by the cord are severe; where there are contusions and well-marked ecchymoses; where the laryngeal cartilages and hyoid bone are fractured or the cervical vertebræ dislocated or fractured; or where the carotids are injured or there is hemorrhage into their walls; where there are severe wounds, the hemorrhage from which would be sufficient to threaten syncope; where there are many marks of violence on the body; where there is evidence of a severe struggle—in all these cases murder may be reasonably suspected. The number, situation, extent, and direction of must be carefully noted and weighed. If these are out of proportion to the ligature, the suspension, etc., they strongly suggest homicide, although they may occur in suicide (see Cases 4, 11, 18, 20, 28, 29, 44, 52, 55, 59, 66).

Homicidal hanging may be committed by an assailant who is strong on a subject who is weak, on a child, a woman, an old person; on one stupefied by liquor or narcotic poison; or by many combined against one person.

Cases are reported where injuries were inflicted or poison given, and the subject was afterward hanged to avert suspicion. Most of these cases are those of murder either by strangulation or suffocation (Cases 64, 65, 67, 68, 69, 70, 74).

Sometimes hanging is =accidental=. Children and even older persons play at hanging successfully. Taylor mentions the case of a boy who witnessed a hanging and afterward tried the experiment himself to ascertain the sensation, and caused his own death.

Tardieu[882] relates the case of a man, T., age 37, of small stature, feeble constitution, very thin, of sinister face, eyes hollow but lively, cunning nose and mouth, who meeting a man aged 81, learned that he had some trouble with his leg and promised to cure him. The old man lived alone. T. told him to buy a strong cord as thick as his little finger and one and one-half yards long, and keep the whole thing a secret. T. would see him at his room at 7 P.M. The old man became suspicious and had T. arrested. The investigation showed that already T. had made away with three old men by hanging, who were known to be opposed to suicide. Their bodies showed no trace of violence. Two others had escaped when the cord was passed around their necks.

Tardieu gives a number of cases of suicidal hanging which were falsely attributed to criminal violence, in which the pressure of public opinion joined to circumstances improperly explained by inexpert physicians caused deplorable judicial errors.

ILLUSTRATIVE CASES.

SUICIDE.

1. _Harvey: Indian Med. Gaz., 1876, xi., p. 2._—Man, age 30. Found hanging by turban to bars of cell door; slip-knot around neck; heart beating feebly; died in about a minute after being cut down. “The point of suspension was forty-seven inches from the ground, the position of the noose twenty-eight inches, and the feet were forty-two inches away from the door supported on the toes.” Experiment showed that the turban could not have borne the full weight of the body. He died from strangulation.

2. _Ibid., p. 3._—Insane man, age 60. Put his neck in a V-shaped fork of a tree and let his body swing. A broad abrasion found on each side of neck. Scalp, brain, and membranes much congested; reddish serum in lateral ventricles; two ounces clear fluid in pericardium. Lungs congested; all the heart cavities contained blood.

3. _Ibid., p. 5._—Woman, age 28. Two marks of ligature on neck; one deep and circular passed up behind left ear; the other passed from the circular mark behind, crossed it on either side under lower jaw, thence up to chin. Appeared at first to be a case of strangulation following hanging; but the two marks were finally explained, that after the body was taken down it was ordered up again until the police should arrive.

4. _Ibid., p. 5._—Man, age 45; first cut his throat and then hung himself. “He had probably only just had time to hang himself before dying.”

5. _Ibid., p. 30._—Woman; hung herself with a twisted cloth. There was much ecchymosis about the neck and upper part of chest; lungs much congested; fibrin clot in left mitral orifice; liver, spleen, and stomach congested; transverse ligament of atlas ruptured.

6. _Ibid._—Man, age 39. Distinct mark of cord around neck; no other mark of violence; laceration of larynx and dislocation of odontoid process; hands clinched; involuntary discharge of semen; thoracic and abdominal organs normal.

7. _Ibid._—Man, age 70. Mark of cord around the neck, superficial in front, deep behind; second cervical vertebra dislocated; tongue slightly protruding; fingers clinched; meningeal vessels engorged; lungs tubercular, congested; right heart contained a little coagulated blood.

8. _Ibid._—Sex and age not given. Found hanging on a tree; usual signs; odontoid process fractured; rope in a double noose without knot, a common _dooree_, such as is used for drawing water.

9. _Ibid., p. 32._—Man, age 50. Face livid, eyes red and protruding; teeth clinched; lower jaw retracted; tongue behind the teeth; hands and feet contracted; anus covered with fæcal matter; circular depressed mark of cord around neck, hard as parchment, slightly ecchymosed along edges; some infiltration of blood in connective tissue beneath the cord; some tearing of soft parts; laryngeal cartilage displaced. Brain and membranes congested. Right cavities of heart distended with dark blood. Trachea congested.

10. _Hurpy: Ann. d’ Hygiene, 1881, vi., pp. 359-367, with illustration._—Woman, age 77, suicided by hanging in the following way: a short cord was fastened by one end to a table leg; the other end was around her neck; she lay on the floor, face downward, clothing not disordered. The brain was congested; lungs congested and emphysematous; left side of heart empty (see Fig. 23).

11. _Champouillon: Same journal, 1876, xlvi., p. 129._—Man, age 62; first tried to suffocate himself with charcoal smoke and then hung himself, but the rope broke and the body fell. He lived two days.

12. _Pellier: Lyon thesis, 1883, No. 188, p. 72._—Boy, age 16, hung himself; rope broke; he was resuscitated; reddish circular furrow on neck, not like parchment; he had erection and ejaculation; buzzing in his ears and flashes before his eyes.

13. _Lacassagne: Pellier thesis (supra), p. 71._—Man; hung himself; was cut down and sent to hospital; was aphonic for four days; then a severe bronchitis set in, and at the end of a week a gangrenous expectoration. The mark of the cord lasted fifteen days.

14. _Maschka: Archiv. de l’anthrop. crim., Paris, 1886, i., pp. 351-356._—Man, age about 60, found dead under a tree in the woods near Prague. No sign of violence. A cord thick as a sugar-loaf around the neck; another cord attached to a branch of the tree. There was at first a strong suspicion of violence, but the conclusion reached was that he had hung himself and that the body had fallen from breaking of the cord; that death was due to asphyxia was shown by the furrow on the neck, the dark liquid blood, and the congested lungs. There was no infiltration below the furrow in the neck, and no lesion of larynx. The man had shown signs of melancholy.

15. _Friedberg: Virchow’s Archiv, 1878, lxxiv., p. 401._—Suicidal hanging. Examination twenty-eight weeks after death. The front of the neck showed a groove above the larynx, firm and of gray color; ecchymosis in subcutaneous tissue.

16. _Bollinger: Friedreich’s Blätt. f. ger. Med., 1889, xl., p. 7._—Man, age 48; found dead. Had made a ligature out of a night-gown and tied it around his neck, the other end around top of a low bed-post; his neck hung by the ligature placed below the larynx. _Illustrated._

17. _Med. Times and Gaz., London, 1860, ii., p. 39._—Woman; had collected accounts of celebrated persons who had been hanged; finally hanged herself.

18. _E. Hoffman: Mitt. d. Wien. Med. Doct. Colleg., 1878, iv., pp. 97-112._—1st. Woman, age about 25; found dead sitting in bed, a handkerchief around her neck fastened to the bed-curtain. The police thought she had been killed and then hung, but the physician concluded that she had committed suicide. An examination of the stomach showed that she had previously tried to poison herself with arsenic.

19. 2d. Woman, age 51; found hanging in half-lying position.

20. 3d. Man, age 50. First tried to kill himself with phosphorus, then sulphuric acid; finally hung himself in a half-kneeling position.

21. _Müller-Beninga: Berlin. klin. Woch., 1877, xiv., p. 481._—Man, age 40; hung himself. There was no swelling of genitals and no soiling of clothing. Necroscopy showed death from asphyxia, and in urethra near meatus quite a quantity of seminal fluid, as shown by microscopical examination.

22. _Tardieu: Op. cit., p. 18._—The Prince of Condé was found hanging in his room, August 27th, 1830. He was suspended by two handkerchiefs to a window fastening, his feet, however, touching the floor. The knot was at the back of the neck (as shown by the illustration), the face turned slightly to the left, the tongue protruding; face discolored; mucus at the mouth and nose; arms hanging and stiff; fists shut; heels raised; knees half bent. The text says that the knot was nearly under the right ear, but the illustration shows a different position (see Fig. 22, p. 743).

23. _Allison: Lancet, 1869, i., p. 636._—Three cases of suicide by hanging, in which there was no mark: 1st. Woman, hung herself with a piece of sheep-net band; cut down before death. 2d. Man, hung with plough-string; cut down in about six minutes. 3d. A heavy man.

24. _Tardieu: Op. cit., pp. 93-105._—Woman, died of coma and asphyxia from suicidal hanging, according to report of Drs. Costan and Facieu. Tardieu approved their report. It was at first thought a case of homicide with subsequent hanging, more especially because of the kind of knot used, _nœud d’artificier_. But Tardieu showed that it was also a _nœud de batalier_. Her feet touched a chair, and her knees were bent. There was a neckcloth in front of her mouth, but it did not seem to have interfered with respiration.

25. _Ibid., pp. 67-72._—The famous case of Marc-Antoine Calas, who committed suicide by hanging (see Voltaire, “Traité sur le tolérance,” etc., in _Nouv. Philos. Histor._, 1772, xxxii., p. 30). He hung himself to a door. No sign of violence. The city hangman said it was impossible for a man to commit suicide in that way. The father was accused and convicted of homicide. Tardieu shows that the act was a suicide.

26. _Ibid., p. 72._—Another famous case. A woman, age 30, hung herself to the key of her bedroom door. Her husband cut her down. He was accused and convicted of the crime and condemned to prison, where he died. Tardieu showed that the case was one of suicide.

27. _Hofmann: Wien. med. Presse, 1880, xxi., p. 201._—Man, age 68, suicide by hanging. There was profuse hemorrhage from both ears.

28. _Ibid.: 1878, xix., pp. 489-493._—Woman, found dead sitting in bed. She first tried to poison herself with arsenic, then hung herself.

29. _Ibid._—Man, tried to poison himself with phosphorus and sulphuric acid, then hung himself. There was a transverse rupture of the sterno-cleido mastoid muscle and suffusion in its sheath.

30. _Maschka: Wien. med. Woch., 1880, xxx., pp. 714, 747, 1075._—Man, age 63. It was at first a question of suicide by hanging or homicide by strangling. He concluded that it was the former.

31. _Ibid._—Also man, age 58. Similar case. Same opinion.

32. _Ibid. 1883, xxxiii., pp. 1118-1120._—Woman. age 23. Question whether she committed suicide by hanging or was strangled and then hung. Opinion, that it was a case of suicide.

33. _Hofmann: Allg. Wien. med. Zeit., 1870, xv., pp. 192-214._—Man, age 60. Suicide by hanging or homicide; opinion, that it was the former.

34. _Van Haumeder: Wien. med. Woch., 1882, xxxii., pp. 531-533._—Suicide by hanging or homicide. There were many wounds in the head; these occurred during the delirium of typhus.

35. _Maschka: “Sammlung gericht. Gutacht.,” etc. (Prag), Leipzig, 1873, p. 137._—Boy, age 9; found dead in sitting position. Injuries on neck and elsewhere. Question, had he hung himself or been choked? Were the injuries inflicted before or after death? Opinion, suicide.

36. _Ibid., p. 144._—Boy, age 13. Found hanging in sitting position. Question whether murder, suicide, or accident. Opinion, suicide.

37. _Ibid., p. 149._—Woman, age 60; found hanging, sitting position. Suicide or homicide. Opinion, suicide.

38. _Ibid., p. 156._—Woman, age 30; found hanging. Opinion, suicide.

39. _Ibid., p. 165._—Man, age 63. Suicide by hanging, or homicide by strangling? Opinion, suicide.

40. _Berliner: Viert. f. ger. Med. und öff. San., 1874, xx., pp. 245-253._—Woman, age 30; found hanging. Opinion, suicide.

41. _Deininger: Friedreich’s Blät. ger. Med., 1884, xxxv., pp. 47-59._—Woman, age 61; found hanging. Opinion given, suicide.

42. _Mader: Bericht d. k. k. Rud. Stift., Wien. (1875), 1876, p. 378._—Woman, age 43; tried to hang herself. She was at once cut down, bled, and taken to hospital unconscious. Next day, face red; pulse and temperature normal. Third day, conscious and could speak, but not aloud; tongue twisted and turned to right; paralysis of right hypoglossal nerve. Uvula drawn to left. Skin of right limb felt “furry.” Applied electricity and gave strychnine; phonation was more distinct during the use of the battery. Two months later she was still aphonic, but the vocal cords were in better action. The right hemiparesis was lessened.

43. _Grant: Lancet, 1889, ii., p. 265._—Man, age 48; found sitting against a door, hung to the knob by a handkerchief.

44. _White: Lancet, 1884, ii., p. 401._—Woman, age 53, insane. Made several attempts at suicide; once with a stocking around her neck, once with an apron; the last time by fastening a portion of her dress to a ladder. She was quickly cut down, cold affusion applied, and artificial respiration (Sylvester). The eyes were prominent and glassy, pupils widely dilated, no reaction to light; conjunctivæ insensitive; lips livid; tongue swollen and pale; face pale; oblique depressed mark on neck, most marked on left side; skin cold; no pulse; no heart-beat recognizable; no respiration; no reflex action. Galvanism failed to arouse any muscular action. The details are too numerous to give all of them. There was reduplication of heart-sounds for several days, due to interference with pulmonary circulation. She recovered both bodily and mental health.

45. _Richards: Indian Med. Gaz., 1886, xxi., p. 78._—Man, age 20; suicide; was cut down and lived for four days.

46. _Kite: Univ. Med. Mag., 1888-89, i., p. 475._—Man, age 69; suicide.

47. _Terrier: Prog. Méd., 1887, vi., pp. 211-214._—Two men, age 29 and 25, insane. Attempted suicide by hanging. Both resuscitated.

48. _Nobeling: Aertz. Intellig.-bl., 1884, xxxi., p. 213._—Two suicides by hanging; men, ages 24 and 40.

49. _Ritter: Allg. Wien,. med. Zeit., 1886, xxxi., p. 375._—Soldier, found hanging. Cut down in ten minutes. Artificial respiration applied; fifteen minutes later, an effort at respiration; face changing from blue to white and then to red; pulse small, irregular; still unconscious; mark of ligature distinct; a few hours later had a maniacal seizure; gave morphia hypodermically and he slept; was also aphonic. Gradually recovered and returned to duty.

50. _Strassmann: Viert. f. ger. Med., 1888, xlviii., pp. 379-381._—Three cases of suicidal hanging in men, ages 27, 37, and 40. The last was found kneeling.

51. _Balta: Pest. Med. Chir. Presse, 1892, xxviii., p. 1244._—Man, age 45-50; hanging; suicide. Thyroid cartilage and hyoid bone broken.

52. _Hackel: Op. cit., p. 35._—Man, found hanging to a beam by a sheet. Had previously tried to choke himself with his hands.

53. _Ibid._—Two cases of suicidal hanging where the cord made no mark. In the first the body hung free; in the second the body was partly supported. In the first there was no rubbing of the skin; in the second the body was soon cut down.

54. _Freund: Wien. klin. Woch., 1893, vi., pp. 118-121._—Man, found hanging; cut down, but could not be resuscitated. Ligature between hyoid bone and larynx, then crossed over itself about middle line of neck, passed up along each side of face, knotted above the head, then thrown over a beam, and on the other side the loop was caught between his legs.

55. _Hoffman: Op. cit., p. 525, illustrated._—Case communicated by Dr. Rosen, of Odessa. Man, age 21, and woman, age 17, hung themselves by same ligature thrown over an open door, one of them on each side. They had previously tried other means of suicide without success (see Fig. 24).

56. _Ibid., p. 530._—Man found hanging by handkerchief to branch of tree but sitting on the ground. Mark of handkerchief superficial and pale. When the necroscopy was made the mark had disappeared. Also a similar suicide where there was no mark at all.

57. _Ibid., p. 541._—Man found hanging to a window. Another man cut the cord and the suspended one fell into a cellar, fracturing his skull.

58. _Ibid._—Man found hanging; cut down; the fall caused rupture of liver.

59. _Ibid., p. 539._—Drunkard hung himself; there was evidence that he had previously injured himself during his drunkenness.

60. _Ibid._—Boy hung himself because he had been punished by the schoolmaster. There were marks on his back and lower limbs from the punishment.

See also Taylor, “Medical Jurisprudence,” pp. 451-452; Tidy, “Medical Jurisprudence,” _incomplete_ hanging, Cases 33 to 36 and 62; Hofmann, “Lehrbuch,” p. 538.

HOMICIDE.

61. _Harvey: Indian Med. Gaz., 1876, xi., p. 3._—Woman, age 20, feeble. Her mother-in-law had kicked her; she probably had fainted; supposing her to be dead, the husband hanged her to a tree within half an hour after the supposed death. Autopsy: No marks of injury; oblique mark of cord on right side of neck; tip of tongue between the teeth; face somewhat livid; right side of heart full of dark blood; lungs congested posteriorly.

62. _Ibid., p. 4._—Woman, age 38. Rope close under the chin passed upward behind the ears. Head bent on chest. Large wound above clavicle. Under the rope was a depression (made after death) but no hemorrhage. Much blood in abdomen and a hole in the liver. Kidney bruised and blackened. Right lung torn through; blood in pleuræ. Wounds were supposed to be gunshot, but the husband confessed that he had thrust a sharp solid bamboo into her body and afterward hung it up. She died of hemorrhage.

63. _Rehm: Friedreich’s Blät. f. ger. Med., 1883, xxxiv., pp. 332-362._—Man, age 73; first roughly maltreated; afterward hung.

64. _Tardieu: Op. cit., p. 125._—Woman found hanging in her room. Circumstances indicated homicidal strangulation and that the hanging was done to avert suspicion. Post-mortem examination showed the base of the tongue ecchymosed, and ecchymosis extending up to the soft palate; mucous membrane of pharynx congested; connective tissue and mucous membrane between hyoid bone and larynx congested posteriorly; epiglottis showed slight ecchymosis, mucous membrane red. These ecchymoses were not caused by the cord, for the latter was placed below the hyoid bone and this bone was not broken. There were also marks on the collar-bone like the mark of two hands.

65. _Ibid., p. 124._—Girl, 15 years old. Body found hanging. Post mortem showed beyond doubt that she had been violated, then strangled, then hung. Her head showed many ecchymoses from either the fist or the foot; blood flowing from left ear. Brain slightly congested. Tongue between teeth, bitten and bloody. On front of neck were two marks: the lower were impressions of fingers close together, nearly uninterrupted, and which had bruised, flattened, and tanned the skin, which here was dry, hard, and horny. This lesion was above the intraclavicular notch and extended toward the sides of the neck with regularity of curve and neatness of imprint, evidently made with the right hand. Above the first furrow under the skin was a kind of track, less extended, more regular, a bruising of the same nature as the preceding, but continued, due to the pressure of the index finger and thumb of left hand. A little below the jaw was a livid place on the skin, which was otherwise unaffected by the ligature. There was nothing to indicate a circular action of the ligature. Froth in larynx and bronchi. Lungs apparently normal. Food had passed from stomach into œsophagus and air-passages.

66. _Ibid., p._ 122.—Woman found hanging in her room, and was resuscitated. She stated that the man who lived with her had tried to strangle her and then hung her. Tardieu saw her in hospital. Respiration short and embarrassed; pains in neck and jaw. Found narrow, circular, sinuous, horizontal, uninterrupted line around the neck below thyroid cartilage; line everywhere equal, deep, and three to four mm. wide; the skin excoriated and covered with thick crust. Below this were several superficial excoriations. There were many contusions on other parts of the body. Tardieu concluded that the mark on the neck was from attempt to strangle; the wounds elsewhere to prevent resistance. She had at the time pulmonary consumption. She died of this disease aggravated by the assault.

67. _Ibid., p. 106._—The Duroulle affair. Woman found hanging. Presumption of homicide; arrest of husband; acquitted. She was found with her face to the floor, one end of a cord around her neck; another similar cord attached seven feet above to a rafter, over which it passed three times. Bidault and Boulard reported it a suicide. The results of the post mortem were as follows: Skin of a red-violet color; face swollen; eyes prominent and congested; conjunctivæ a vinous red; lips violet; tongue swollen, tip between teeth; froth in air-passages; lungs congested; brain congested; blood fluid. Circular depression around neck with congestion of skin above and below; ecchymosis in subcutaneous tissue on level of angle of jaw and about one centimetre in size, supposed to correspond to the knot. Tardieu reported that the marks rather resembled those of strangulation than hanging; the ecchymoses were more like those produced by the hand over the mouth. The marks on the face supposed to have been made by a supposed fall of the body were by him considered to have been caused by violence. He believed the woman had been strangled and then hung.