Chapter I: Illustrators of Cheap Editions 219 (1)

II. CONCERNING "EXTRA ILLUSTRATIONS" 227
III. DICKENS IN ART 243

INDEX 249

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS

_No. of
Plate._ _Subject._ _Artist._

1. Portrait of CHARLES DICKENS SOL. EYTINGE, Junr. Frontispiece
2. Portrait of GEORGE CRUIKSHANK BAUGNIET Facing page 1
3. "Jemima Evans."--_Sketches by Boz_ G. CRUIKSHANK „ 4
4. "The Four Miss Willises."--_Sketches
by Boz_ „ „ 6
5. "Thoughts about People."--_Sketches
by Boz_ „ „ 8
6. "The Parish Engine."--_Sketches by Boz_ „ „ 10
7. Studies for Scenes and Characters.--_Sketches
by Boz_ „ „ 12
8. "Mr. Bumble Degraded in the Eyes of the
Paupers."--_Oliver Twist_ „ „ 14
9. "Mr. Claypole as he Appeared when his Master
was Out."--_Oliver Twist_ „ „ 16
10. "Oliver Amazed at the Dodger's Mode of
'Going to Work.'"--_Oliver Twist_ „ „ 18
11. Studies for Bill Sikes, Nancy, and the
Artful Dodger.--_Oliver Twist_ „ „ 20
12. Studies for Bill Sikes in the Condemned
Cell.--_Oliver Twist_ „ „ 22
13. Study for "Fagin in the Condemned
Cell."--_Oliver Twist_ „ „ 24
14. First Idea for "Fagin in the Condemned
Cell" and other Sketches.--_Oliver
Twist_ „ „ 26
15. Portrait of ROBERT SEYMOUR TAYLOR „ 29
16. "Mr. Pickwick Addresses the Club."--_The
Pickwick Papers_ R. SEYMOUR „ 32
17. "The Pugnacious Cabman."--_The Pickwick
Papers_ „ „ 34
18. "Dr. Slammer's Defiance of Jingle."--_The
Pickwick Papers_ „ „ 36
19. First Study for "The Dying Clown."--_The
Pickwick Papers_ „ „ 38
20. "The Runaway Chaise."--_The Pickwick
Papers_ „ „ 40
21. "The Pickwickians in Mr. Wardle's
Kitchen."--_The Pickwick Papers_ „ „ 42
22. Portrait of ROBERT W. BUSS R. W. BUSS „ 47
23. Unused Design for the Title-Page.--_The
Pickwick Papers_ „ „ 48
24. "The Break-down."--_The Pickwick Papers_ „ „ 50
25. "A Souvenir of Dickens" „ „ 52
26. Dolly Varden.--_Barnaby Rudge_ „ „ 54
27. Florence Dombey and Captain Cuttle.--_Dombey
and Son_ „ „ 56
28. Portraits of HABLÔT K. BROWNE and ROBERT
YOUNG From Photographs „ 58
29. "A Sudden Recognition, Unexpected on
Both Sides."--_Nicholas Nickleby_ H. K. BROWNE „ 64
30. Studies for the Cheeryble
Brothers.--_Nicholas Nickleby._ „ „ 68
31. Master Humphrey and the Deaf
Gentleman.--_Master Humphrey's Clock_ „ „ 72
32. "The Dombey Family."--_Dombey and Son_ „ „ 76
33. "Paul and Mrs. Pipchin."--_Dombey and Son._ „ „ 80
34. "Mr. Peggotty's Dream comes True."--_David
Copperfield_ „ „ 84
35. "Mr. Chadband 'Improving' a Tough
Subject."--_Bleak House_ „ „ 92
36. Dolly Varden.--_Barnaby Rudge_ H. K. BROWNE „ 98
37. Miss Haredale.--_Barnaby Rudge_ „ „ 110
38. Portrait of GEORGE CATTERMOLE From a Photograph „ 121
39. Quilp's Wharf.--_The Old Curiosity
Shop_ G. CATTERMOLE „ 124
40. The Death-bed of Little Nell (Two
Studies).--_The Old Curiosity Shop_ „ „ 126
41. The Night Watchman and The "Maypole"
Inn.--_Barnaby Rudge_ „ „ 130
42. The Murder at the Warren.--_Barnaby Rudge_ „ „ 132
43. Portrait of JOHN LEECH Sir J. E. MILLAIS, P.R.A „ 138
44. "Richard and Margaret."--_The Chimes_ J. LEECH „ 140
45. "John, Dot, and Tilly Slowboy."--_The
Cricket on the Hearth_ „ „ 142
46. "Caleb at Work."--_The Cricket on the
Hearth_ „ „ 144
47. "The Tetterbys."--_The Haunted Man_ „ „ 146
{From a Photograph, and}
48. Portraits of RICHARD DOYLE and
D. MACLISE, R.A. {from the Painting by } „ 149
{E. M. Ward, R.A }
49. Portraits of CLARKSON STANFIELD, R.A.,
and FRANK STONE, A.R.A From Photographs „ 153
50. "War" and "Peace."--_The Battle of
Life_ C. STANFIELD, R.A „ 156
51. "The Tower of the Chimes" and "The
Spirit of the Chimes."--_The Chimes_ D. MACLISE, R.A. „ 162
52. "Milly and the Old Man."--_The Haunted
Man_ F. STONE, A.R.A „ 176
53. Portraits of SIR JOHN {From a Photograph, and}
TENNIEL, R.I., and SIR {from the Painting by }
EDWIN LANDSEER, R.A {Sir F. GRANT, P.R.A} „ 180
54. Portraits of F. W. TOPHAM and
SAMUEL PALMER From Photographs „ 182
55. "The Villa D'Este."--_Pictures
from Italy_ S. PALMER „ 186
56. Portrait of MARCUS STONE, R.A From a Photograph „ 192
57. Studies for "Mr. Venus Surrounded
by the Trophies of his Art."--_Our
Mutual Friend_ MARCUS STONE, R.A „ 194
58. Monsieur Defarge and Doctor
Manette.--_A Tale of Two Cities_ „ „ 196
59. "Black and White."--_American Notes_ „ „ 198
60. "Taking Leave of Joe."--_Great
Expectations_ „ „ 200
61. Portrait of LUKE FILDES, R.A From a Photograph „ 204
62. Study for the Head of Neville
Landless.--_The Mystery of Edwin
Drood_ L. FILDES, R.A „ 206
63. Studies for Edwin Drood.--_The
Mystery of Edwin Drood_ „ „ 208
64. Studies for Mr. Jasper.--_The
Mystery of Edwin Drood_ „ „ 210
65. Study for "Good-bye, Rosebud,
Darling."--_The Mystery of Edwin Drood_ „ „ 212
66. Study for Mr. Grewgious.--_The Mystery
of Edwin Drood_ „ „ 214
67. Do. do. do. do. „ „ 216
68. Portraits of ALFRED CROWQUILL
(A. H. Forrester) and FREDERICK
BARNARD, R.I From Photographs „ 228
69. Portraits of F. W. PAILTHORPE and
CHARLES GREEN, R.I. „ „ 232

_The Frontispiece Portrait of Charles Dickens was photo-engraved by Mr. E. Gilbert Hester, and the Collotype Plates were prepared and printed by Mr. James Hyatt._

PLATE II

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

From the Lithograph by

BAUGNIET

This Portrait is a reproduction of a proof impression, showing the retouching by Cruikshank himself.

DICKENS
AND HIS ILLUSTRATORS

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

First Start in Life--Early Productions--"SKETCHES BY
BOZ"--Introduction to Dickens--First and Second Series of the
"Sketches"--Extra Plates--Additional Designs for the Complete
Edition--Portraiture of Artist and Author--Historic Value of
Cruikshank's Illustrations--Some Slight
Inaccuracies--Frontispiece of the First Cheap
Edition--Tentative Sketches and Unused Designs--"OLIVER
TWIST"--Incongruities Detected in a Few of the
Plates--Thackeray's Eulogium--Working Tracings and
Water-Colour _Replicas_--Trial Sketches--A Note from
Cruikshank to Dickens--Sketches of Bill Sikes in the
Condemned Cell--How the Design for "Fagin in the Condemned
Cell" was Conceived--A Criticism by Ruskin--The Cancelled
Plate--Cruikshank's Claim to the Origin of "Oliver
Twist"--Designs for Dickens's Minor Writings in BENTLEY'S
MISCELLANY--"The Lamplighter's Story"--Cruikshank's Last
Illustration for Dickens--"Frauds on the Fairies"--The
Artist's Remuneration--Death.

The name of George Cruikshank, which stands first in the long and imposing list of Dickens Illustrators, is familiar to every one as that of a pencil humorist of no common calibre, whose genius as a designer and whose marvellous skill as an etcher have evoked enthusiastic praise from John Ruskin and other eminent critics. He undoubtedly inherited his artistic talent from his father, who was not only an etcher and engraver, but (as George himself has recorded) "a first-rate water-colour draughtsman." So experienced an artist was therefore thoroughly capable of training his sons, George and Isaac Robert, for the same profession.

Like most boys, George dreamt of the sea, aspiring to become a second Captain Cook; but, happily, the death of his father compelled him to take up seriously the work of designing, in order that he might assist in maintaining his mother and sister. His first start in life originated in a publisher seeing some of his sketches, which indicated such unusual talent that he was immediately engaged to illustrate children's books, songs, and other cheap literature peculiar to the period. Then the young artist essayed the more profitable arena of political caricaturing, distinctly making his mark as a satirist Realising at this time his imperfections as a draughtsman, he determined to acquire the art of drawing with correctness, entering the Royal Academy as a student; but, finding it difficult to work on pedantic lines, his resolution soon waned, and, after one course of study, he left the place for a short interval of--forty years! Although he never became the learned artist, nor was able to draw with academic accuracy, he wielded his pencil with a facility and vigour that delighted all beholders, and this deftness, combined with a remarkable sense of humour and satire, speedily brought him commissions from every quarter.

It was as a book-illustrator that George Cruikshank undoubtedly excelled, and some idea of his industry in this direction (during a period of eighty years of his busy life) may be obtained from G. C. Reid's comprehensive catalogue of his works, where we find enumerated more than five thousand illustrations on paper, wood, copper, and steel. This, however, by no means exhausts the list, for the artist survived the publication of the catalogue several years, and was "in harness" to the end of his long career. If the works described by Mr. Reid be supplemented by the profusion of original sketches and ideas for his finished designs, the number of Cruikshank's productions may be estimated at about fifteen thousand!

Before his introduction to Charles Dickens in 1836, the versatile artist had adorned several volumes, which, but for his striking illustrations, would probably have enjoyed but a brief popularity. His etchings and drawings on wood are invariably executed in an exceedingly delicate manner, at the same time preserving a breadth of effect unequalled by any _aquafortiste_ of his day. "Only those who know the difficulties of etching," observes Mr. P. G. Hamerton, "can appreciate the power that lies behind his unpretending skill; there is never, in his most admirable plates, the trace of a vain effort."

* * * * *

[Sidenote: =Sketches by Boz, 1833-36.=]

Dickens's clever descriptions of "every-day life and every-day people" were originally printed in the _Monthly Magazine_, the _Evening Chronicle_ and the _Morning Chronicle_, _Bell's Life in London_, and "The Library of Fiction," and subsequently appeared in a collected form under the general title of "Sketches by Boz." Early in 1836 Dickens sold the entire copyright of the "Sketches" to John Macrone, of St. James's Square, who published a selection therefrom in two duodecimo volumes, with illustrations by George Cruikshank. It was at this time that Charles Dickens first met the artist, who was his senior by about a score of years, and already in the enjoyment of an established reputation as a book-illustrator. That the youthful author, as well as his publisher, realised the value of Cruikshank's co-operation is manifested in the Preface to the "Sketches," where Dickens, after appropriately comparing the issue of his first book to the launching of a pilot balloon, observes: "Unlike the generality of pilot balloons which carry no car, in this one it is very possible for a man to embark, not only himself, but all his hopes of future fame, and all his chances of future success. Entertaining no inconsiderable feeling of trepidation at the idea of making so perilous a voyage in so frail a machine, alone and unaccompanied, the author was naturally desirous to secure the assistance and companionship of some well-known individual, who had frequently contributed to the success, though his well-known reputation rendered it impossible for him ever to have shared the hazard, of similar undertakings. To whom, as possessing this requisite in an eminent degree, could he apply but to George Cruikshank? The application was readily heard and at once acceded to; this is their first voyage in company, but it may not be the last." Each of the two volumes contains eight illustrations, and it may justly be said of these little vignettes that they are among the artist's most successful efforts with the needle. Although highly popular from the beginning, the "Sketches" were now received with even greater fervour, and several editions were speedily called for. As the late Mr. G. A. Sala contended, the coadjutorship of so experienced a draughtsman as George Cruikshank, who knew London and London life "better than the majority of Sunday-school children know their Catechism," was of real importance to the young reporter of the _Morning Chronicle_, with whose baptismal name (be it remembered) his readers and admirers were as yet unacquainted.

During the following year (1837) Macrone published a Second Series of the "Sketches" in one volume, uniform in size and character with its predecessors, and containing ten etchings by Cruikshank; for the second edition of this extra volume two additional illustrations were done, viz., "The Last Cab-Driver" and "May-day in the Evening."[1] It was at this time that Dickens repurchased from Macrone the entire copyright of the "Sketches," and arranged with Chapman & Hall for a complete edition, to be issued in shilling monthly parts, octavo size, the first number appearing in November of that year. The completed work contained all the Cruikshank plates (except that entitled "The Free and Easy," which, for some unexplained reason, was cancelled) and the following new subjects: "The Parish Engine," "The Broker's Man," "Our Next-door Neighbours," "Early Coaches," "Public Dinners," "The Gin-Shop," "Making a Night of It," "The Boarding-House," "The Tuggses at Ramsgate," "The Steam Excursion," "Mrs. Joseph Porter," and "Mr. Watkins Tottle."

Footnote 1: A set of the twenty-eight etchings, proofs
before letters (First and Second Series), realised £30 at
Sotheby's in 1889. Lithographic _replicas_ of the plates in
the Second Series were published in Calcutta in 1837.

Cruikshank also produced a design for the pink wrapper enclosing each of the twenty monthly parts; this was engraved on wood by John Jackson, the original drawing (adapted from one the artist had previously made for Macrone) being now in the possession of Mr. William Wright, of Paris. The subject of the frontispiece is the same as that of the title-page in the Second Series. The alteration in the size of the illustrations for this cheap edition necessitated larger plates, so that the artist was compelled to re-etch his designs. These reproductions, although on an extended scale, were executed with even a greater degree of finish, and contain more "colour" than those in the first issue; but the general treatment of the smaller etchings is more pleasing by reason of the superior freedom of line therein displayed. As might be anticipated, a comparison of the two sets of illustrations discloses certain slight variations, which are especially noticeable in the following plates: "Greenwich Fair;" musicians and male dancer added on left. "Election for Beadle;" three more children belonging to Mr. Bung's family on right, and two more of Mr. Spruggins's family on left, thus making up the full complement in each case. "The First of May" (originally entitled "May-day in the Evening"); the drummer on the left, in the first edition, looks straight before him, while in the octavo edition he turns his face towards the girl with the parasol. "London Recreations;" in the larger design the small child on the right is stooping to reach a ball, which is not shown in the earlier plate.

PLATE III

"JEMIMA EVANS"

_Facsimile_ of Unused Designs for "Sketches by Boz" by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

Additional interest is imparted to some of the etchings in "Sketches by Boz" owing to the introduction by the artist of portraits of Charles Dickens and himself, there being no less than five delineations of the face and figure of the youthful "Boz" as he then appeared. In the title-page of the Second Series (as well as in the reproduction of it in the octavo edition), the identity of the two individuals waving flags in the car of the balloon has been pointed out by Cruikshank, who wrote on the original pencil-sketch, "The parties going up in the balloon are intended for the author and the artist,"--which may be considered a necessary explanation, as the likenesses are not very apparent.

In the plates entitled "Early Coaches," "A Pickpocket in Custody," and "Making a Night of It," Cruikshank has similarly attempted to portray his own lineaments and those of Dickens; he was more successful, however, in the illustration to "Public Dinners," where the presentments of himself and the novelist, as stewards carrying official wands, are more life-like. There exist, by the way, several seriously-attempted portraits of Dickens by Cruikshank, concerning the earliest of which it is related that author and artist were members of a club of literary men known during its brief existence as "The Hook and Eye Club," and that at one of their nightly meetings Dickens was seated in an arm-chair conversing, when Cruikshank exclaimed, "Sit still, Charley, while I take your portrait!" This impromptu sketch, now the property of Colonel Hamilton, has been etched by F. W. Pailthorpe, and a similar drawing is included in the Cruikshank Collection at South Kensington. Among other contemporary portrait-studies (executed in pencil and slightly tinted in colour) is one bearing the following inscription in the artist's autograph: "Charles Dickens, Author of Sketches by Boz, the Pickwick Papers, &c., &c., &c.,"--an admission that seems to dispose of Cruikshank's subsequent claim to the authorship of "Pickwick."

PLATE IV

"THE FOUR MISS WILLISES"

_Facsimile_ of an Unused Design for "Sketches by Boz" by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

It has been remarked that Cruikshank was so accurate in the rendering of details that future antiquaries will rely upon his plates as authoritative in matters of architecture, costume, &c. For example, in the etching of "The Last Cab-Driver," he has depicted an obsolete form of cabriolet, the driver being seated over the right wheel; and in that of "The Parish Engine" we may discover what kind of public fire-extinguisher was then in use--a very primitive implement in comparison with the modern "steamer." In the latter plate, by the way, we behold the typical beadle of the period, who afterwards figured as Bumble in "Oliver Twist." _Apropos_ of this etching, Mr. Frederick Wedmore points out (in _Temple Bar_, April 1878) that it is "an excellent example of Cruikshank's eye for picturesque line and texture in some of the commonest objects that met him in his walks: the brickwork of the house, for instance, prettily indicated, the woodwork of the outside shutters, and the window, on which various lights are pleasantly broken. I know no artist," he continues, "so alive as Cruikshank to the pretty sedateness of Georgian architecture. Then, too, there is the girl with basket on arm, a figure not quite ungraceful in line and gesture. She might have been much better if Cruikshank had ever made himself that accurate draughtsman of the figure which he hardly essayed to be, and she and all her fellows--it is only fair to remember--might have been better, again, had the artist who designed her done his finest work in a happier period of English dress." Mr. Wedmore alludes to another etching in "Sketches by Boz" as being "perhaps the best of all in Cruikshank as proof of that sensitive eye for what is picturesque and characteristic in every-day London. It is called 'The Streets, Morning,' the design somewhat empty of 'subject,' only a comfortable sweep who does not go up the chimney, and a wretched boy who does, are standing at a stall taking coffee, which a woman, with pattens striking on pavement and head tied up close in a handkerchief, serves to the scanty comers in the early morning light. A lamp-post rises behind her; the closed shutters of the baker are opposite; the public-house of the Rising Sun has not yet opened its doors; at some house-corner further off a solitary figure lounges homeless; beyond, pleasant light morning shadows cross the cool grey of the untrodden street; a church tower and spire rise in the delicate distance, where the turn of the road hides the further habitations of the sleeping town."

It may be hypercritical to resent, on the score of inaccuracy, an occasional oversight on the part of Cruikshank; but it is nevertheless interesting to note that in the plate entitled "Election for Beadle," Cruikshank has omitted from the inscription on Spruggins's placard a reference to "the twins," the introduction of which caused that candidate to become temporarily a favourite with the electors; in "Horatio Sparkins," the "dropsical" figure of seven (see label on right) is followed by a little "1/2d." instead of the diminutive "3/4d." mentioned in the text; in "The Pawnbroker's Shop" it will be observed that the words "Money Lent" on the glass door should appear reversed, so as to be read from the outside; while in the etching illustrating "Private Theatres," the artist has forgotten to include the "two dirty men with the corked countenances," who are specially referred to in the "Sketch."

The first cheap edition of "Sketches by Boz," issued by Chapman & Hall in 1850, contained a new frontispiece, drawn on wood by Cruikshank, representing Mr. Gabriel Parsons being released from the kitchen chimney,--an incident in "Passage in the Life of Mr. Watkins Tottle."

George Cruikshank not unfrequently essayed several "trial" designs before he succeeded in realising to his satisfaction the subject he aimed at portraying. Some of these are extremely slight pencil notes--"first ideas," hastily made as soon as conceived--while others were subjected to greater elaboration, and differing but slightly, perhaps, from the etchings; on certain drawings are marginal memoranda--such as studies of heads, expressions, and attitudes--which are valuable as showing how the finished pictures were evolved. The majority of the designs are executed in pencil, while a few are drawn with pen-and-ink; occasionally one may meet with a sketch in which the effect is broadly washed in with sepia or indian-ink, and, more rarely still, with a drawing charmingly and delicately wrought in water-colours. Besides original sketches, the collection at the South Kensington Museum contains a series of working tracings, by means of which the artist transferred his subjects to the plates. There are no less than three different suggestions for the frontispiece of the first cheap edition of "Sketches by Boz," together with various renderings of the design for the wrapper of the first complete edition, in which the word "Boz" in the title constitutes a conspicuous feature, being formed of the three letters superimposed, while disposed about them are several of the prominent characters. Probably the most interesting in this collection is a sheet of slight sketches signed by the artist, although they are merely tentative jottings for his etchings. One of these pencillings (an unused subject) represents a man proposing a toast at a dinner-table, doubtless intended as an illustration for "Public Dinners"; and here, too, are marginal studies of heads--including one of a Bill Sikes type--together with a significant note (apparently of a later date) in the autograph of Cruikshank, which reads thus: "Some of these suggestions to Chas. Dickens, and which he wrote to in the second part of 'Sketches by Boz'!"

PLATE V

"THOUGHTS ABOUT PEOPLE"

_Facsimile_ of an Unused Design for "Sketches by Boz" by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

A large number of studies for "Sketches by Boz" may also be seen in the Print Room of the British Museum, many of which are very slight. In some instances we find the same subject rendered in different ways, and it is worthy of note that a few of these designs were never etched; among the most remarkable of the unused sketches is a rough drawing for the wrapper of the monthly parts (octavo edition), with ostensible portraits of author and artist introduced. This collection includes "first ideas" for "Thoughts about People," "Hackney Coaches," "The Broker's Man," &c., and a careful examination shows that the sketches for the plates illustrating "Seven Dials" and "The Pickpocket in Custody" are entitled by the artist "Fight of the Amazons" and "The Hospital Patient" respectively. In one of the trial sketches for "The Last Cabman," the horse is represented as having fallen to the ground, the passenger being violently ejected from the vehicle.

* * * * *

[Sidenote: =Oliver Twist, 1837-39.=]

On August 22, 1836, Charles Dickens entered into an agreement with Richard Bentley to edit a new monthly magazine called _Bentley's Miscellany_, and to furnish that periodical with a serial tale. George Cruikshank's services as illustrator were also retained, and his design for the wrapper inspired Maginn to indite, for "The Bentley Ballads," the "Song of the Cover," whence this characteristic verse is quoted:--

"Bentley, Boz, and Cruikshank stand
Like expectant reelers;
'Music!' 'Play up!' pipe in hand
Beside the _fluted_ pillars

"Boz and Cruikshank want to dance,--
None for frolic riper;
But Bentley makes the first advance,
Because he pays the piper."

The first number of the _Miscellany_ was issued in January 1837, and in February appeared the initial chapter of the editor's story, entitled "Oliver Twist, or, the Parish Boy's Progress," which was continued in succeeding numbers until its completion in March 1839, with etchings by Cruikshank.

The dramatic character of this stirring romance of low London life afforded the artist unusual scope for the display of his talent; indeed, his powerful pencil was far more suited to the theme than that of any of his contemporaries. The principal scenes in the novel proved most attractive to him, and he fairly revelled in delineating the tragic episodes associated with the career of Fagin and Sikes. These twenty-four etchings are on the same scale as those in the first collected edition of the "Sketches," but they are broader and more effective in treatment. In October 1838,--that is, about five months before completion in the _Miscellany_,--the entire story was issued by Chapman & Hall in three volumes post octavo, and there can be no doubt that its remarkable success was brought about in no small measure by Cruikshank's inimitable pictures. Nearly eight years later (in January 1846) a cheaper edition, containing all the illustrations, was commenced in ten monthly parts, demy octavo, and subsequently published in one volume by Bradbury & Evans. On the cover for the monthly numbers Cruikshank has portrayed eleven of the leading incidents in the story, some of the subjects being entirely new, while others are practically a repetition of the etched designs. The plates in this edition, having suffered from previous wear-and-tear, were subjected to a general touching-up, as a comparison with the earlier issue clearly indicates, such reparation (carried out by an engraver named Findlay, much to Cruikshank's annoyance) being especially noticeable in cases where "tones" have been added to wall-backgrounds and other parts of the designs. Apart from actual proof impressions, the "Oliver Twist" etchings are naturally to be found in their best state in _Bentley's Miscellany_, where they are seen in their pristine beauty. In some of the plates it will be observed that Cruikshank has introduced "roulette" (or dotted) work with excellent effect, although, of course, this disqualifies them as examples of pure etching. The first cheap edition of "Oliver Twist," issued in 1850 by Chapman & Hall, contains a frontispiece only by George Cruikshank, representing Mr. Bumble and Oliver in Mrs. Mann's parlour, as described in the second chapter.

PLATE VI

"THE PARISH ENGINE"

_Facsimile_ of the Original Drawing for the First Octavo Edition of "Sketches by Boz" by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

It has been said that Cruikshank could not draw a pretty woman. At any rate, he neglected his opportunity in "Oliver Twist," for he fails in so depicting Rose Maylie, while his portrayal of Nancy is particularly ugly and repelling, whereas she certainly possessed physical charms not unfrequently found in women of her class. Although the artist has imparted too venerable an appearance to the Artful Dodger, he has seized in a wonderful manner the characteristics of criminal types in his rendering of Fagin and Bill Sikes. In many of Cruikshank's etchings the accessories are very _àpropos_, and sometimes not without a touch of quiet humour. For example, in the plate representing Oliver recovering from the fever, there is seen over the chimney-piece a picture of the Good Samaritan, in allusion to Mr. Brownlow's benevolent intentions with respect to the invalid orphan; while in that depicting Mr. Bumble and Mrs. Corney taking tea, may be noticed the significant figure of Paul Pry on the mantelshelf. Some of the designs are marked by slight incongruities, which, however, do not detract from their interest. In the etching "Oliver Plucks up a Spirit," it will be observed that the small round table which the persecuted lad overthrows during his desperate attack upon Noah Claypole could not possibly assume, by such accidental means, the inverted position as here shown. In the plate entitled "The Evidence Destroyed," the lantern (according to the text) should have been lowered into the dark well, but doubtless the error was intentional on the part of the artist, in order to secure effect; in "Mr. Fagin and his Pupil Recovering Nancy," the girl is represented as being exceedingly robust, whereas she was really "so reduced with watching and privation as hardly to be recognised as the same Nancy." Again, in the illustration depicting Sikes attempting to destroy his dog, we see in the distance the dome of St. Paul's, while, as a matter of fact, the desperate ruffian had not reached a point so near the metropolis when he thought of drowning the faithful animal.[2] In "The Last Chance," where the robber contemplates dropping from the roof of Fagin's house to escape his pursuers, the rope (described in the letterpress as being thirty-four feet long) is barely half that length, and could never have extended to the ground; while the dog, who lay concealed until his master had tumbled off the parapet, must have been distinctly visible to all observers if he stood so prominently on the ridge-tiles as here indicated. The latter etching is one of the most fascinating of the series, for here Cruikshank has realised every feature of the dramatic scene,--the harassed expression on the evil face of the hunted criminal, the squalid tenements half shrouded by approaching darkness, the excitement of the people crowding the windows of the opposite houses; indeed, the tragic and repulsive element in the picture constitutes a remarkable effort on the part of the artist.

Footnote 2: In a large water-colour _replica_ of this
subject, signed "George Cruikshank, Octr. 14th, 1873, in my
82nd year," the artist stated that the landscape represented
the old Pentonville fields, north of London.

PLATE VII

STUDIES FOR

SCENES AND CHARACTERS IN "SKETCHES BY BOZ"

_Facsimile_ of the Original Sketches by GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

In the centre of the sheet the Artist has written: "Some of these suggestions to Chas. Dickens, and which he wrote to in the second part of 'Sketches by Boz.'"

In considering the story as a whole, it is difficult to say how much of the powerful impression we are conscious of may be due to the illustrator. In his famous eulogy on Cruikshank, Thackeray remarked: "We are not at all disposed to undervalue the works and genius of Mr. Dickens, and we are sure that he would admit as readily as any man the wonderful assistance that he has derived from the artist who has given us portraits of his ideal personages, and made them familiar to all the world. Once seen, these figures remain impressed on the memory, which otherwise would have had no hold upon them, and the Jew and Bumble, and the heroes and heroines of the Boz Sketches, become personal acquaintances with each of us. O that Hogarth could have illustrated Fielding in the same way! and fixed down on paper those grand figures of Parson Adams, and Squire Allworthy, and the great Jonathan Wild." Again, with more especial reference to the "Oliver Twist" designs, the kindly "Michael Angelo Titmarsh" wrote: "The sausage scene at Fagin's; Nancy seizing the boy; that capital piece of humour, Mr. Bumble's courtship, which is even better in Cruikshank's version than in Boz's exquisite account of the interview; Sykes's[3] farewell to his dog; and the Jew--the dreadful Jew--that Cruikshank drew! What a fine touching picture of melancholy desolation is that of Sykes and the dog! The poor cur is not too well drawn, the landscape is stiff and formal; but in this case the faults, if faults they be, of execution rather add to than diminish the effect of the picture; it has a strange, wild, dreary, broken-hearted look; we fancy we see the landscape as it must have appeared to Sykes, when ghastly and with bloodshot eyes he looked at it. As for the Jew in the dungeon, let us say nothing of it--what can we say to describe it?"

Footnote 3: The name of Sikes is frequently thus mis-spelt.
It is odd that Dickens himself first wrote it "Sykes," as may
be seen in the original manuscript of the story.

The complete set of twenty-four working tracings of the original designs for "Oliver Twist," some of which exhibit variations from the finished etchings, realised £140 at Sotheby's in March 1892. Water-colour _replicas_ of all the subjects were prepared by Cruikshank in 1866 for Mr. F. W. Cosens, which the artist supplemented by thirteen smaller drawings and a humorous title-page, the entire series being reproduced in colour for an _edition de luxe_ of "Oliver Twist," published by Chapman & Hall in 1894. The Cruikshank Collections in the British and South Kensington Museums include many of the artist's sketches and "first ideas" for the "Oliver Twist" plates, as well as a number of the matured designs. Here are several trial sketches for the monthly wrapper of the first octavo edition, executed in pencil with slight washes of sepia added; the original drawings for "Rose Maylie and Oliver" (known to collectors as the "Fireside" plate, to which reference will presently be made), and for "Mr. Bumble Degraded in the Eyes of the Paupers" (with marginal sketches), the title of which is appended in Dickens's autograph, where, instead of "the eyes," the word "presence" was originally written. Here, also, we find the first sketch of Noah Claypole enjoying an oyster-supper, with the following query written by the artist: "Dr. Dickens, 'Title' wanted--will any of these do? Yours, G. Ck." The proposed titles are then given, thus: "Mr. Claypole Astonishing Mr. Bumble and 'the Natives';" "Mr. Claypole Indulging;" "Mr. Claypole as he Appeared when his Master was Out,"--the latter being adopted. On the back of a pen-and-ink drawing of "Oliver's Reception by Fagin and the Boys," Cruikshank suggested a different title, viz., "Oliver Introduced to the Old Gentleman by Jack Dawkins." A beautiful little water-colour drawing of the subject, entitled "Oliver Introduced to the Respectable Old Gentleman," is in the Print Room of the British Museum, where we may also discover a portrait of Oliver himself--a profile study of the head as seen in the drawing now referred to. On the back of a sketch of Mr. Brownlow at the bookstall (for the plate entitled "Oliver Amazed at the Dodger's Mode of 'Going to Work'") is the rough draft of an unsigned note in the autograph of Cruikshank, evidently addressed to Dickens:--

"_Thursday Eg., June 15, '37._

"MY DEAR SIR,--Can you let me have a subject for the second
Plate? The first is in progress. By the way, would you like
to see the Drawing? I can spare it for an hour or two if you
will send for it."

PLATE VIII

"MR. BUMBLE DEGRADED IN THE EYES OF THE PAUPERS"

_Facsimile_ of the Original Sketch for "Oliver Twist" by GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

The Inscription above the Sketch is in the Autograph of Dickens.

I am enabled to reproduce in _facsimile_ a very interesting sheet of sketches for prominent characters in "Oliver Twist," containing no less than five studies of Fagin, including the "first idea" for the famous etching of the Jew in the condemned cell. Still more noteworthy are four studies of Bill Sikes in the condemned cell, evidently made early in the progress of the book, thus seeming to indicate that the artist conjectured this would be the fate of the burglar instead of the Jew; or is it possible that the existence of these studies may be considered as a corroboration of his assertion (in a letter to the _Times_, presently to be quoted) that he, and not Dickens, must be credited with the idea of putting either Sikes or Fagin in the cell?

Concerning Cruikshank's powerful conception of Fagin in the condemned cell ("the immortal Fagin of 'Oliver Twist,'" as Thackeray styled him), it is related by Mr. George Hodder (in "Memories of my Time") that when the great George brought forth this picture, where the Jew is seen biting his finger-nails and suffering the tortures of remorse and chagrin, Horace Mayhew took an opportunity of asking him by what mental process he had conceived such an extraordinary notion; and his answer was, that he had been labouring at the subject for several days, but had not succeeded in getting the effect he desired. At length, beginning to think the task was almost hopeless, he was sitting up in bed one morning, with his hand covering his chin and the tips of his fingers between his lips, the whole attitude expressive of disappointment and despair, when he saw his face in a cheval-glass which stood on the floor opposite to him. "That's it!" he involuntarily exclaimed; "that's just the expression I want!" and by this accidental process the picture was formed in his mind. Many years afterwards Cruikshank declared this statement to be absurd, and when interrogated by Mr. Austin Dobson, who met the artist at Mr. Frederick Locker's house in 1877, he said he had never been perplexed about the matter, but attributed the story to the fact that, not being satisfied whether the knuckles should be raised or depressed, he had made studies of his own hand in a glass, and illustrated his account by putting his hand to his mouth, looking, with his hooked nose, wonderfully like the character he was speaking of. Respecting another illustration in the story, where "The Jew and Morris Bolter begin to Understand each Other," Professor Ruskin observes that it is "the intensest rendering of vulgarity, absolute and utter," with which he is acquainted.

The latter portion of "Oliver Twist" was written in anticipation of the magazine, in order that the complete story might be promptly launched in volume form. The illustrations for the final chapters had consequently to be produced simultaneously and with all possible speed, so that the artist had no time to submit his designs to Dickens. One of these plates, viz., "Rose Maylie and Oliver," depicted a scene in the new home of the Rev. Harry Maylie; he, his wife, and mother, are seated by the fire, while Oliver stands by Rose Maylie's side. When Dickens first saw this etching he so strongly disapproved of it that the plate was forthwith cancelled and another design substituted; but, the book being then on the eve of publication, it was impossible to prevent a small number of impressions of this illustration being circulated, and copies of the work containing the scarce "Fireside" plate are therefore eagerly sought after by collectors. Dickens, in expressing to Cruikshank his disapprobation of this etching, undoubtedly realised the delicacy of the situation, in the possibility of injuring the susceptibilities of the artist, as the following carefully-worded intimation testifies:--

"I returned suddenly to town yesterday afternoon, to look at the latter pages of 'Oliver Twist' before it was delivered to the booksellers, when I saw the majority of the plates in the last volume for the first time.

"With reference to the last one--Rose Maylie and Oliver--without entering into the question of great haste, or any other cause, which may have led to its being what it is, I am quite sure there can be little difference of opinion between us with respect to the result. May I ask you whether you will object to designing this plate afresh, and doing so _at once_, in order that as few impressions as possible of the present one may go forth?

"I feel confident you know me too well to feel hurt by this enquiry, and, with equal confidence in you, I have lost no time in preferring it."

PLATE IX

"MR. CLAYPOLE AS HE APPEARED WHEN HIS MASTER WAS OUT"

_Facsimile_ of the Original Sketch for "Oliver Twist" by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

The Inscriptions are in the Autograph of the Artist.

It seems, however, that Cruikshank did not immediately proceed to carry out the author's wish, but endeavoured to improve the plate by retouching and adding further tints by means of stippling, &c. In the South Kensington Collection there is an early proof of the etching in which the shadow tints are washed in with a brush, and the fact that these alterations were subsequently carried out is established by the existence of a unique impression of the plate in its second state. This proof was probably submitted to Dickens and again rejected, for no impressions having the stippled additions are known to have been published. The substituted design, bearing the same title as the suppressed one, does not much excel it in point of interest, as the artist himself readily admitted; it represents Rose Maylie and Oliver standing in front of the tablet put up in the church to the memory of Oliver's mother, this etching appearing in _Bentley's Miscellany_ and in all but the earliest copies of the book. The substituted plate (like many others in the volume) was afterwards considerably "touched up," for it will be noticed that in the earlier impressions Rose's dress is light in tone, while subsequently it was changed to black.

A very circumstantial story relative to Cruikshank's connection with "Oliver Twist" was published in a Transatlantic journal called _The Round Table_, and reprinted immediately after Dickens's death in a biography of the novelist by Dr. Shelton Mackenzie, who avers that he had been informed that Dickens intended to locate Oliver in Kent, and to introduce hop-picking and other picturesque features of the county he knew so well: that the author changed his purpose, and brought the boy to London: and further, that for such important alterations in the plot Cruikshank was responsible. But the more remarkable portion of this narrative is Dr. Mackenzie's account of his visit to Cruikshank in 1847, at the artist's house in Myddleton Terrace, Pentonville, concerning which he writes:--

"I had to wait while he was finishing an etching, for which a printer's boy was waiting. To while away the time, I gladly complied with his suggestion that I should look over a portfolio crowded with etchings, proofs, and drawings, which lay upon the sofa. Among these, carelessly tied together in a wrap of brown paper, was a series of some twenty-five to thirty drawings, very carefully finished, through most of which were carried the now well-known portraits of Fagin, Bill Sikes and his dog, Nancy, the Artful Dodger, and Master Charles Bates--all well known to the readers of 'Oliver Twist'--and many others who were not introduced. There was no mistake about it, and when Cruikshank turned round, his work finished, I said as much. He told me that it had long been in his mind to show the life of a London thief by a series of drawings, engraved by himself, in which, without a single line of letterpress, the story would be strikingly and clearly told. 'Dickens,' he continued, 'dropped in here one day just as you have done, and, while waiting until I could speak with him, took up that identical portfolio and ferreted out that bundle of drawings. When he came to that one which represents Fagin in the condemned cell, he silently studied it for half-an-hour, and told me that he was tempted to change the whole plot of his story; not to carry Oliver Twist through adventures in the country, but to take him up into the thieves' den in London, show what their life was, and bring Oliver safely through it without sin or shame. I consented to let him write up to as many of the designs as he thought would suit his purpose; and that was the way in which Fagin, Sikes, and Nancy were created. My drawings suggested them, rather than his strong individuality suggested my drawings."

PLATE X

"OLIVER AMAZED AT THE DODGER'S MODE OF 'GOING TO WORK'"

_Facsimile_ of the First Sketch for the Etching by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

Forster naturally characterises this story as a deliberate untruth, related with "a minute conscientiousness and particularity of detail that might have raised the reputation of Sir Benjamin Backbite himself," and points out that the artist's version, as here narrated, is completely refuted by Dickens's letter to Cruikshank, which unquestionably proves that the closing illustrations had not even been seen by the novelist until the book was ready for publication. Cruikshank, on reading in the _Times_ a criticism of Forster's biography, in which this charge against Dickens was commented upon, at once indited the following letter to that journal, where it appeared on December 30, 1871:--

"_To the Editor of 'The Times._'

"SIR,--As my name is mentioned in the second notice of Mr.
John Forster's 'Life of Charles Dickens,' in your paper of
the 26th inst., in connection with a statement made by an
American gentleman (Dr. Shelton Mackenzie) respecting the
origin of 'Oliver Twist,' I shall be obliged if you will
allow me to give some explanation upon this subject. For
some time past I have been preparing a work for publication,
in which I intend to give an account of the origin of
'Oliver Twist,' and I now not only deeply regret the sudden
and unexpected decease of Mr. Charles Dickens, but regret
also that my proposed work was not published during his
life-time. I should not now have brought this matter
forward, but as Dr. Mackenzie states that he got the
information from me, and as Mr. Forster declares his
statement to be a falsehood, to which, in fact, he would
apply a word of three letters, I feel called upon, not only
to defend the Doctor, but myself also from such a gross
imputation. Dr. Mackenzie has confused some circumstances
with respect to Mr. Dickens looking over some drawings and
sketches in my studio, but there is no doubt whatever that I
did tell this gentleman that I was the originator of the
story of 'Oliver Twist,' as I have told very many others who
may have spoken to me on the subject, and which facts I now
beg permission to repeat in the columns of the _Times_, for
the information of Mr. Forster and the public generally.

"When _Bentley's Miscellany_ was first started, it was
arranged that Charles Dickens should write a serial in it,
and which was to be illustrated by me; and in a conversation
with him as to what the subject should be for the first
serial, I suggested to Mr. Dickens that he should write the
life of a London boy, and strongly advised him to do this,
assuring him that I would furnish him with the subject and
supply him with all the characters, which my large
experience of London life would enable me to do.

"My idea was to raise a boy from a most humble position up
to a high and respectable one--in fact, to illustrate one of
those cases of common occurrence, where men of humble
origin, by natural ability, industry, honest and honourable
conduct, raise themselves to first-class positions in
Society. And as I wished particularly to bring the habits
and manners of the thieves of London before the public (and
this for a most important purpose, which I shall explain one
of these days), I suggested that the poor boy should fall
among thieves, but that his honesty and natural good
disposition should enable him to pass through this ordeal
without contamination; and after I had fully described the
full-grown thieves (the Bill Sykeses) and their female
companions, also the young thieves (the Artful Dodgers) and
the receivers of stolen goods, Mr. Dickens agreed to act on
my suggestion, and the work was commenced, but we differed
as to what sort of boy the hero should be. Mr. Dickens
wanted rather a queer kind of chap, and, although this was
contrary to my original idea, I complied with his request,
feeling that it would not be right to dictate too much to
the writer of the story, and then appeared 'Oliver Asking
for More;' but it so happened just about this time that an
inquiry was being made in the parish of St. James's,
Westminster, as to the cause of the death of some of the
workhouse children who had been 'farmed out,' and in which
inquiry my late friend Joseph Pettigrew (surgeon to the
Dukes of Kent and Sussex) came forward on the part of the
poor children, and by his interference was mainly the cause
of saving the lives of many of these poor little creatures.
I called the attention of Mr. Dickens to this inquiry, and
said that if he took up this matter, his doing so might
help to save many a poor child from injury and death; and I
earnestly begged of him to let me make Oliver a nice pretty
little boy, and if we so represented him, the public--and
particularly the ladies--would be sure to take a greater
interest in him, and the work would then be a certain
success. Mr. Dickens agreed to that request, and I need not
add here that my prophecy was fulfilled: and if any one will
take the trouble to look at my representations of 'Oliver,'
they will see that the appearance of the boy is altered
after the two first illustrations, and, by a reference to
the records of St. James's parish, and to the date of the
publication of the _Miscellany_, they will see that both
dates tally, and therefore support my statement.

PLATE XI

STUDIES FOR

BILL SIKES, NANCY, AND THE ARTFUL DODGER

_Facsimile_ of Original Sketches by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK

_Lent by Messrs. Robson & Co._

"I had, a long time previously to this, directed Mr.
Dickens's attention to Field Lane, Holborn Hill, wherein
resided many thieves and receivers of stolen goods, and it
was suggested that one of these receivers, a Jew, should be
introduced into the story; and upon one occasion Mr. Dickens
and Mr. Harrison Ainsworth called upon me at my house in
Myddleton Terrace, Pentonville, and in course of
conversation I then and there described and performed the
character of one of these Jew receivers, whom I had long had
my eye upon; and this was the origin of 'Fagin.'

"Some time after this, Mr. Ainsworth said to me one day, 'I
was so much struck with your description of that Jew to Mr.
Dickens, that I think you and I could do something
together,' which notion of Mr. Ainsworth's, as most people
are aware, was afterwards carried out in various works. Long
before 'Oliver Twist' was ever thought of, I had, by
permission of the city authorities, made a sketch of one of
the condemned cells in Newgate prison; and as I had a great
object in letting the public see what sort of places these
cells were, and how they were furnished, and also to show a
wretched condemned criminal therein, I thought it desirable
to introduce such a subject into this work; but I had the
greatest difficulty to get Mr. Dickens to allow me to carry
out my wishes in this respect; but I said I must have
either what is called a Christian or what is called a Jew in
a condemned cell, and therefore it must be 'Bill Sikes' or
'Fagin;' at length he allowed me to exhibit the latter.

"Without going further into particulars, I think it will be
allowed from what I have stated that I am the originator of
'Oliver Twist,' and that all the principal characters are
mine; but I was much disappointed by Mr. Dickens not fully
carrying out my first suggestion.

"I must here mention that nearly all the designs were made
from conversation and mutual suggestion upon each subject,
and that I never saw any manuscript of Mr. Dickens until the
work was nearly finished, and the letter of Mr. Dickens
which Mr. Forster mentions only refers to the last
etching--done in great haste--no proper time being allowed,
and of a subject without any interest; in fact, there was
not anything in the latter part of the manuscript that would
suggest an illustration; but to oblige Mr. Dickens I did my
best to produce another etching, working hard day and night,
but when done, what is it? Why, merely a lady and a boy
standing inside of a church looking at a stone wall!

"Mr. Dickens named all the characters in this work himself,
but before he had commenced writing the story he told me
that he had heard an omnibus conductor mention some one as
Oliver Twist, which name, he said, he would give the boy, as
he thought it would answer his purpose. I wanted the boy to
have a very different name, such as Frank Foundling or Frank
Steadfast; but I think the word Twist proves to a certain
extent that the boy he was going to employ for his purpose
was a very different sort of boy from the one introduced and
recommended to him by, Sir, your obedient servant,

"GEORGE CRUIKSHANK.

"HAMPSTEAD ROAD, _December 29, 1871_."

PLATE XII

STUDIES FOR

BILL SIKES IN THE CONDEMNED CELL

_Facsimile_ of Original Sketches by

GEORGE CRUIKSHANK