Chapter XXV: Summing Up

With some show of reason Swift affirmed that all sublunary happiness consists in being _well deceived_.

We are perfectly aware that this book does not support Swift’s ethics of happiness, for while agreeing that the English satirist’s theory may hold good on a great many occasions, we claim an exception for collectors as a class. In the world of art, art lovers and collectors, to be well deceived means to be living in a fool’s paradise, a most costly dwelling which promises no eternal joy. On the contrary, the happiness derived from being well deceived in this case is generally not only of very short duration but inflicts smarting wounds to pride and pocket.

In the world at large there seems to exist a certain benevolence towards deluded ones, which makes it at times possible for the well deceived to be the only one of his entourage unaware that he has been duped. In the world of collectors such a thing is almost an impossibility for, to quote a well-known French art lover: “After pictures by Michelangelo and specimens of Medici ware, the rarest thing to find with collectors is kindliness.”

The same art lover assures us that in this peculiar world not only is kindliness (_bienveillance_) rare, but the opposite sentiment has been developed almost to the point of genius. Collectors, especially first-rate collectors who have finally emerged into fame through the complex resultant of a good eye, shrewdness and extreme skill in fencing with strong competitors, have a regular talent for flavouring bitter pills for deceived friends and comrades with troublesome innuendoes and smarting disclosures, for, as the above-quoted connoisseur declares, they have a way of praising with “praise that exasperates and with homicidal compliments,” and there is a type of collector who knows his repertory by heart, a man who is a “_toreador raffiné--il massacre artistement_.”

What the neophyte can do to avoid being “artistically” massacred, as the French connoisseur puts it semi-euphemistically, is difficult to say. Books and special treatises may explain the nature of the deceit, point out the dangers awaiting him and show how traps are laid and how they work, but to pretend to become a truly safe buyer on the security of knowledge gathered from books and manuals would be like attempting the ascent of some dangerous peak on the strength of wisdom drawn from works on Alpine climbing.

The rudiments of the art do not concern so much the knowledge of how to buy as of how not to buy, how to resist, namely, the first impulse, which in an inexperienced art lover proves to be one of the worst dangers. The slow, prudent method must be learnt of not listening to first impulses till the first impulses are supported by something better than the innate conceit of a beginner. We know, of course, that there may be occasions when even a beginner may have cause to regret not having listened to a first impulse, but such a thing is further from the general rule than the beginner claims, and in any case it pays in the long run to let a good chance slip rather than risk becoming the possessor of some expensive would-be _chef-d’œuvre_.

In addition, during the early stages in particular, a certain amount of scepticism must temper a too ready belief in what the dealer has to say or show, in support of his assertion. There will come a time when experience will help the collector to detect more easily than at first alluring, suggestive information, etc.

Naturally it is not all dealers who are on the watch to take advantage of the beginner. On the contrary, there are more honest dealers in the antique market than one would think, but the trouble is that the dishonest ones seem to be to the fore, to be ever there ready to confront the inexperienced novice, and their noisy deceits become far more known than good, honest dealing, causing perplexity in some collectors so that it may be they disbelieve the man who is telling the truth and give credence to the liar, who being a perfect master in the art of misrepresentation, seems to be honesty itself.

Here, too, the determination to be rather sceptical as to documents, letters, pedigrees and mercantile evidence may lead the beginner to miss some good opportunity, but the case is rare and such losses are as a rule amply covered in the summing up of the total cost of apprenticeship, through not having paid for experience the extravagant price usually demanded. In due time the art lover’s ability to discern between dealing and dealing will be sharpened, and he will be able to defend himself better.

This merely concerns dealing and experience in distinguishing the genuine from the fake. But even supposing perfection has been attained in this part, the fact does not necessarily imply qualification as a connoisseur, collector, expert or even simple lover of art. A collection may be composed of genuine articles and yet be a poor one, utterly devoid of artistic merit or even commercial value of importance. To have paid a high price is no guarantee of merit. There are, as a matter of fact, perfectly genuine paintings for which extravagant fancy prices have been paid, but which in the eyes of a true connoisseur are not worth the nail they hang on.

It is almost impossible to conceive that experience in distinguishing the genuine from the false should be acquired without the attainment of some artistic progress prompting discrimination between poor art and mediocre, and mediocre art and fine art, yet this artistic side is the most difficult to develop to that perfection and semi-intuition of the beautiful, so necessary to the real and first-rate connoisseur.

By what method this artistic side may be perfected in the collector is still more difficult to tell, for in this direction experience only counts to a certain extent. In fact as regards this artistic education of the connoisseur we are inclined to repeat with Taine, in his _Philosophie de l’Art_: “Precepts? Well, two might be given: first to be born with genius--that is your parents’ affair, not mine; second to work a good deal to bring it out, and that is not my business either.”

Here too, then, actual methods are out of the question. They are, perforce, of such a general character as to be no more use than telling a blind man to keep in the middle of the road because there are ditches on either side. It is, further, not uncommon for contrary systems to lead to equally happy results according to the person employing them. One antiquary when undecided as to the genuineness of a painting used to have a photograph of it taken, for, he said, he could easily detect the traits of forgery on seeing the work in black and white with all colours eliminated, or, to put it in his own words: The faked side sweats out. Another connoisseur held exactly the contrary theory, declaring that he could tell nothing from photos but needed the colours to help to detect the genuineness or fraud of the painting. Perhaps the former had an artistic temperament based chiefly upon the charm of form while the latter was what in art is termed a colourist.

In addition, at times another misleading cause may be added which comes under the form of intervening suggestion and may put even a highly gifted artistic temperament off the scent.

Perhaps an example will best illustrate this peculiar interference, which is not only of a circumstantial order, as we have seen in another part of this book, but may be the result of an unconscious _parti pris_.

Some years ago when Mr. Stanford White imported works of art and antiques for his millionaire patrons, a Mr. X., who owned a fine mansion on Fifth Avenue, very much admired an early fifteenth century single andiron that was among the imported goods. He wished, however, to have a pair. The suggestion that a modern copy should be made from the only remaining original at first disgusted him, for everyone knows how easily American collectors buy imitations for originals and how disgusted they are if the dealer honestly says that a certain work is an imitation. On being assured that the imitation should be perfect, the new piece was finally ordered and the antiquary arranged for an artistically exact copy of the ancient andiron to be made in Italy. However, possibly because not wishing to be suspected of concocting “modern antiques,” or for some other reason, the Italian firm sent a perfect copy of the original in a brand new condition, suggesting that a certain Italian artist living in New York should give it the proper patina as he was fully initiated in the cryptic art of making new objects look as old as might be desired. The art critic chosen to come and judge of the final result of the work was, as the artist knew, rather distrustful of Italians and their tricks, as he put it.

The Italian artist did the work as well as it could be done, and knowing that it was going to be judged side by side with the original, the hardest test that can be inflicted upon an imitation, he managed to cheat the art critic by being excessively frank and honest, taking advantage of his prejudice against Italians and a probable momentary mental attitude. The two pieces were shown in the artist’s atelier, the imitation being placed by the artist in the full light and the original in the most benevolent corner, far from the window in a half-shade. The first thought that passed through the art critic’s brain as he entered the studio was that the “tricky Italian” had put the imitation where the light was less strong and the shade more benevolently helpful.

“Very good,” he remarked, “but of course even when not in the full light an imitation is always an imitation.”

“But that is the original,” replied the artist, for to make his positive assertion the more definite the critic had been pointing to the wrong piece.

A stony silence followed.

The story ends here and we do not know whether the critic ever forgave the artist his honest trick. Knowing that the art critic was a real connoisseur, a good exception to the class, we are quite sure that his judgment was perverted by the preconceived notion that the Italian had placed the imitation in the shade and thus had hardly let his artistic temperament and knowledge of art come into play in forming an opinion, or rather the opinion was already formed, and too quickly expressed, by a semi-subconscious process of reasoning that had nothing in common with art judgment.

So many are the special cases, and so little the assistance generally given to new-comers, that the safest method in conclusion is to have no actual method, to watch and study one’s own temperament, value the first results objectively, to be ready to learn as much as possible from experience under whatever form it comes and finally, like in so many cases of human life and possibilities, to work out one’s own salvation.

In this way, even if not called to the Olympus of the elect, the art lover will certainly reduce his bad bargains to a minimum--bad bargains in the way of buying the wrong things as far as the genuineness of the article is concerned as well as with regard to its artistic worth. With this he must rest satisfied for, as we gladly repeat once more with the Nestor of French connoisseurs: “Beware of the collector who never makes a mistake; the strongest is he who makes the fewest mistakes.”

* * * * *

As we have seen, the genus _curieux_ (curio-hunter) comprises a most complex and multiform assembly of types. From the distant ages of Roman dominion down to our times, collectomania has produced characters graduated in originality from the grotesque to the tragic, the false to the genuine, the sordid or wicked like Mark Antony and Verres to noble representatives like Julius Cæsar, Augustus and Agrippa.

Curiously enough the noble type of collector and the usefulness of his mission have generally escaped the observation of writers of all ages. They seem to have been quicker to see the grotesque side of collectomania than its utility. Martial, Juvenal, Pliny, Seneca and others are not dissimilar in their remarks from--say, Molière and La Bruyère.

So strong is the inclination to place the types in a grotesque setting, to make them the target of witty sallies, that they very often mistake oddities for signs of idiocy, idiosyncrasies and peculiarities for craziness, and, carrying their analysis no further, they let loose the vein of their satire on people whose passion for collecting has been of extreme use to the intellectual world, greatly assisting progress and the civilization of humanity.

“Just like a donkey beholding a lyre,” gibes an old Greek epigram in allusion to collectors who, while buying eagerly, give so little time, or none at all, to the enjoyment of the artistic merits of their acquisitions. Addressing one of his contemporaries who had a passion for collecting manuscripts and volumes but no inclination to read them, Lucian remarks: “Why so many literary works? Do you collect them in order to lie on the learned thoughts of others, or to paste the parchment of the volumes to your skin? With it all you will not become a jot more learned; a monkey is always a monkey, even though covered with gilded garments.”

To follow up the special case of book-collecting to which Lucian’s remark casually leads us, the same sentiment as that of the Greek writer was entertained centuries later by Petrarch and Robert Estienne. The former was a poet and bibliophile, the latter a famous printer, author of the _Thesauros linguæ latinæ_. The two did not spare satires on the mere collector of books.

A like attitude is taken towards Mazarin by a mediocre poet of La Fronde, who reproaches the Cardinal with collecting books without reading them; the same reproach that contemporary writers make to Magliabechi, a passionate collector of rare editions who never went further in a book than the title-page. Yet, to confine ourselves to these alone, to Mazarin is due one of the finest libraries of Paris which still bears his name, and by his careful, patient work, Magliabechi was the founder of the Magliabechiana, now the National Library of Florence, a marvel and model of historical character to other more modern institutions of the kind. These two persistent and passionate book collectors have certainly contributed more to science and its progress than many of those scholars who made fun of their hobby.

It must be taken into consideration that collecting, after all, is a passion, at times a deep and firmly rooted one, and that passion, like love, in its most exalted expression does not represent normality, but while on the one hand presenting qualities of an intuitive character, can be coupled with oddities and idiosyncrasies, frequently the inevitable heritage of originality.

Hannibal who stored his money in the hollow of the bronze statues of his collection, Sulla who put to death citizens to seize their rare pieces of art, and Julius Cæsar who travelled with his cherished objects of virtu, are known to us as collectors mostly through their peculiarities, the amusing anecdotal side of a passion, certain to be exploited by a writer, be he chronicler or historian.

Yet, to go back to the unjustified and indiscriminating spirit of satirists, both of ancient and more recent times, which tends to consider the collector a maniac or fool, many a Greek and Roman _chef-d’œuvre_ of art has nevertheless been spared to our admiration by the patient persistence and art-loving care of collectors.

It would, indeed, be interesting to follow the passage of some of the most noted specimens of past art. If one could trace the true history of each one of these objects in all its details, it would perhaps give us the history of the collecting passion together with tangible proof of its merits and utility.

It would, indeed, not only be interesting but also instructive to know the vicissitudes of some of the works of art that have come down to us. The few hints existing as to the lineage of owners of some of the most famous pieces of Greek and Roman art, certainly promise interest even though marred at times by the fact that much of the information rests upon the vague authority of tradition, or is strongly doubted by modern criticism.

“We owe, it is more than possible, the Venus of the Hermitage to Cæsar; the well-known ‘Whetter’ has almost certainly been saved to our admiration by Lucullus, just as Cicero may be thanked for the ‘Demosthenes’ and the collecting passion of Sallust has handed down to us the ‘Faun,’ the ‘Hermaphrodite’ and the ‘Vase’ of the Villa Borghese.”

These remarks of a well-known French collector who mainly notes works contained in the Louvre Museum might be extended to many other collections, especially those of Rome, where several of the works of art have old historical records of undisputed character.

From the Renaissance down to our own days the pedigrees of celebrated works of art are not only surer, but present at times a less interrupted line of descent. With such it is not uncommon to find a rare object pass from one collector to another, receiving the same care and consideration as though passing from father to son as a cherished heirloom--and it is, in fact, passing from one to another member of the same family, the family bound by an identical burning passion, that of collecting.

As to the essence of this passion, so often confounded with mania--a mistake calling forth the following comment from a French collector: “... _confondre la ‘manie’ avec la curiosité, c’est prendre l’hysterie pour l’amour, ‘la Belle Helenè’ pour l’Iliade_”--we should like to quote Gersaint, one of the few men who as art dealer and collector in one, what might be styled private dealer in modern phrase, impersonated the passion, as we have said, in its highest expression among the many collectors of the eighteenth century. It must be understood, of course, that Gersaint, one of these maniacs in, say, La Bruyère’s opinion, was a representative of those passionate collectors who subordinate every other passion of mankind to the one they have made the sole aim of their lives. “... A _curieux_,” says this unilateral lover but not hobbyist collector, “has the advantage of not falling an easy prey to the many passions so familiar to the human family: the _curiosité_ fills all the empty spaces of his leisure moments. Entertained by his cherished possessions, he has time only for working at the advance of his _curiosité_, and his cabinet becomes the centre of all his pleasures, and the seat of all his passions.”

The outsider and half-way-insider will agree that this is a trifle too much; but, after all, the great collectors who have left to the museums of their countries fortunes that would have been lost but for their intense passion--treasures of art left by the ignorant to the doom of decay--have all felt, more or less, the burning passion described by Gersaint, in the passage quoted which goes on to assert that a true paradise awaits the perfect collector, who is never bored, and never the prey of spleen.

Without discussing the promises held out by Gersaint, as the perfect collector is, to our knowledge, rare, let us state that our book does not hope to urge any reader on to the perfection that ushers into Gersaint’s bliss, but if the brief glimpse we have given of Collectomania with its pleasures and dangers should convince some really passionate lover of art that collecting has a nobler aim than that of mere pleasure, if we should discourage a Tongilius or Paullus, or if this work should scare some modern Clarinus and do away with a noisy, useless up-to-date Trimalchus, we shall feel that the purpose of the book has been justified to some extent.

INDEX.

Adamo da Brescia, counterfeiter of coins, 67

_Adventures of a Bric-à-brac Hunter_,
144

Agar’s, Mme., collection of dolls, 291

Agesilas, 21

Aglæphon, 25

Agrippa as an art lover, 31

Alberti, 86

Alcohol as a solvent, 227

Alexander the Great, 37

Alluye, castle of, 92

Altar piece, Rothschild’s faked, 262

_Amateur marchand_, the, 117

Amber varnish, 228

Ambras collection, the, 87

American collector, the, 141

Andirons, story of the, 305

Andrea da Foiano, 79

Andrea del Sarto, 99

Andreoli, Maestro Giorgio, 250

Anne of Austria, 123

Anonimo Morelliano, the, 98

Antiquary, old and modern, the, 143, 153

Antique, passion for the, 71

Antiques, the collection of, in Italy, 82

Apelles, 20

Apollo and Marsyas, 94

Apollo, Sulla’s statue of, 36

Apollo, temple of, at Delphi, 23, 61

Apollo, the golden, 18

Aponius Saturninus, prætor, 29

Archæological suggestion, 160

Aretino, Pietro, 117

Aristotle, 18

Aristotle, bas-relief of, 91

Armour, faked, 269

Arms, the imitation of, 267

Art collecting, spread of, in Europe, 110

Art critic, the, 160

Art, influence of Greek and Roman, 83

Art in Rome, 20

Art museums in Rome, 61

Art sales, 128

Artist and erudite, 140

Artistic war booty, 21

Artists as connoisseurs, 288

Artists at Rome, status of, 20

Aspetti, Tiziano, 98

Athens, 18

_Atria auctionaria_, 28, 212

_Atrium_, the, 48

Atticus, 40

Auction room, atmosphere of the, 214

Augustus and Vedius Pollio, 52

Autographs, forged, 200, 298

Baldinucci, 225

Barberini, Cardinal, 118

Barbizet Brothers, 252

_Barguette_, la, 110

Barocco, the, 113

Bas-reliefs, bronze, 91, 235

Basant, 131

Basilini, 147

Bastianini, 182, 188

Belli, Valerio, 98, 100

Bellini, 100

Beniviene, Girolamo, Bastianini’s bust of, 183

Biblical subjects, 102

Bibliomaniacs, Roman, 50

_Biographie Universelle_ of M. Weiss, 115

Bisticci, V. da, 92

“Black Band,” the, 171, 180, 219

Boethus, 30

Boiss, Mme., 209

Bolides, faking, 300

Bonafedi, Signor, 185

Bonnaffé, Edmond, 108, 112, 149, 193

Bookbindings, 296

Book collectors, Roman, 49

Books, 294

Bracciolini, Poggio, 75

Brass articles, patina for, 265

Bric-à-brac, 130

Bric-à-brac shops in Rome, 29

Brienne, 119

Briesco, Andrea, 87, 88

Bronze and other metals, to give tone and colour to, 264

Bronzes, 30, 89, 238

Brunelleschi, 75, 83

Brunellesco, 71

Brunswick Museum, the, 91

Brutus as a collector, 40

Brutus of Michelangelo, 103

Buffon, 131

Bullant, Jean, 92

Cafaggiolo, 249

Calamis, 46, 59

“Calcedonio,” Niccoli’s, 73

Calchar, 100

Caligula, 29

Caligula as an auctioneer, 212

Callot’s bad etching, 127

Camelio, Vittore, 91

Cameos, counterfeit, 58

Candelabras, 30

Canvas for restoring paintings, 229

Capodimonte factory, the, 256

_Cappuccino_, 282

Cardinal di San Giorgio, 82, 89

Carncades, 41

Carracci, “The Deluge” by, 120

Castellani sale, the, 213

Castiglione, 103

Catalogues, first printed, 116

Cathegus, 25

Catherine de Medici, 110

Cavenaghi, 167

Cavino, 91

Cellini, 103

Ceroplastics, 244

Cesnola collection, 248

Charles the Bald, Bible and Psalter of, 66

Charles VI, catalogue of, 68

Chasles, M., 199

Cheese as a vehicle for colour, 230

Chemistry’s aid to faking, 263

Chilperic, a collector, 65

Christian and pagan subjects, 96

Christianity and art, 63

_Chronique Scandaleuse_, 130

Chrysogon, 25

Chrysoloras, Emanuele, 72

Claywork fakes, 235

Cicero and Art, 19;
imitation and fraud, 24;
pubilc auctions, 28;
a collector of doubtful taste, 40, 41;
Chrysogon, 45;
_citrus_ tables, 54;
public sales, 211

Cinquecento art, 102; velvet, 289

Cinquecento collectors, 102

Ciriaco d’Ancona, 71

_Citrus_ or _thuja_, 54;
qualities, 55

_Citrus_ tables, craze for, 25, 54

Clarinus, 32

Classification, 138

“Cleaning,” 216

Client and art market, 31

Clodion’s clay groups, 208, 238

Clodius, 31

Clotaire, a collector, 65

Clovis, a collector, 65

_Craquelage_, on pottery, 255

Cressy, influence of the battle of, 110

_Crieur_, the, 28

Crozat, 129

Coaches, Commodus’ collection of, 212

Codrus, the needy collector, 32

Coin counterfeiting, 67, 92

Cola di Rienzi, 69

Collection, a form of banking, 64

Collector, the: the home of the, 18;
and satirists, 32;
types of, 34;
rapacious, 37, 38;
ultra-modern, 141

Collectors and collections, 135

Collector’s touch, the, 146

Colouring marble, 242

Commerce and art collecting, 130

Commodus’ effects, sale of, 212

Concini, 123

Condivi, 90

Connoisseurship and erudition, 138

Conquerors as collectors of art treasures, 22

Constantine, 18, 63

Constantinople and Oriental arms, 267

Copyists in Rome, 59; Greek, 59

Corinthian bronze, 30, 51, 239

Cornelius Nepos’ statuette of Hercules, 37

Corplet, Alfred, 252

Correggio, the Marsyas and the Antiope by, 119

Correr Museum, 91

Corvinus, Mathias, 96

Cosimo I, 104

Costantini, Prof., 178

Costumes and dress, 290

Coulanges, 124

Counterfeit coining, 67

Counterfeiting, imitation, and forgery in Rome, 58

Courajod, Louis, 84, 92

Courtier, the, in Rome, 28; modern, 164

Couvreur, 147

_Curieux_, meaning of, 136

Custom House officials, 179

Cut glass, 260

Dagobert, 65

Damascening, 270

Damophilus, 21, 43

David, statuette by Michelangelo, 108

Davillier collection, the, 90, 95, 108, 140

Dazzi, the Italian dealer, 179

d’Aunale, Duc, 110

de Bassiano, 91

d’Este, Isabella, 80

de Genlis, Mme., 136

de la Porte, Armand-Charles, 120

de Limeville, Sieur, 127

de Sévigné, Mme., 125

d’Oiron, faience, 109

Dealers, traders and shopkeepers, 154

Death masks, 92

Deceptive surroundings, 210

Della Robbia, imitations of, 250

Delorme, Philibert, 92

Delphi, 17

Demasippus, 25

Demmin, 251, 273

Derutha, 249

Devers, Joseph, 250

di Banco, Antonio, 84

_di mattonella_, 156

Didius Julianus, 212

Dolls and toys, 290

Donatello, 71, 83, 84, 86

Donatello’s _puttino_, 197

Dondi, 71

Dreyfus, G., 91

Drouot, Hotel, 214

Duchie, Jacques, collection of, 69

Dyes for marble, 243

Eclectic and specialist, 138, 140

Ecouen, castle of, 92

_Electrum_, Helen’s cup of, 18

Enamels, faked, 259, 260

England, rise of the passion for collecting in, 110

English furniture, 283

Ennius, 22

_Epitrapezios_, the, 36

_Ereinteur_, the, 217

Eros, the tearful collector, 33

Estienne, H., 109, 112

Estienne, R., dictionary of, 136

Etchings, margins for, 232

Etruscan pottery, 248

Eudel, Paul, 180, 199, 203, 238, 273, 278, 295

Evander Aulanius, 60

_Évangéliaire_, a rare, 66

Evelyn, John, 115

Ex-voto objects, 290

_Exhedra_, 49

Expert, the, 162

Fabius Maximus, 19

“Fabius Pictor,” 20

Faked atmosphere, the, 207

Faked reputation, the, 220

Faker, the, 194

Faker, the jovial, 202

Fakers, the aristocracy of, 88

“Faking the _milieu_,” 209

Faking in Rome, 27, 57

“Faustina antica,” Mantegna’s, 81

Filarete, 86

Firminius, 31

Florence, National Museum, 91

Flute player, the, 88

Fontainebleau, school of, 112

Forgeries, 153

Forni, 230

Fortunatus, 65

Fortuny, Mariano, 268

Forzetta, Oliver, 69

France and art collecting, 107

France, art in, 112

France, seventeenth-century art in, 114

Frankfurt, fair of, 109

Frederick II, Duke of Mantua, 66, 99

Freppa, 182

Friuli, Marquis of, 66

_Fronde_, the, 119

Fulvius Nobilior, 21

Furniture, faking, 167, 279

Gaillon, castle of, 87

Gegania and Clesippus, 29

Gellianus the auctioneer, 213

German-made arms, 267

Gersaint, 131, 148, 309

Ghiacceti, Luigi, 110

Ghiberti, Lorenzo, 85, 94, 100

Gilded bronze, 241

Gilles Corrozet, 111

Ginori’s china works, 256

Ginsburg, Dr., 205

Giovanni Tornabuoni, 80

Girardon, 40

Giuliano da Sangallo, 80

Giustiniani, 248

Gladius Rogieri, the, 273

Glass, faked, 259

Glazes for pottery, 255

Glyptography, 79

Go-between, the, 164

Godescal, monk, 66

Gold products, spurious, 277

Gorgas, 21, 43

Gouffier, Claude, 109

Græco-Roman pottery, 247

_Græeculi delirantes_, 20

Gratianus, 31

Greek copyists, 59

Greeks, the, as art collectors, 17

Green-bronze lacquer for metal, 263

Green or brown-green patina, 265

Green patina, 266

Grolier, 107

Gubbio, 249

Guillebert de Metz, 69

Gymnasium of the Areopagus, 17

Hall, Major H. Bing, 144

Hannibal, 37

Hercules and Antæus, 88

Hercules of Lysippus, 19

“Hercules Musagetes,” 22

Hercules, statuette of, 36

Heius of Messina, 49

Henry II faience, 252

Hispano-Moresque pottery, 249

Holland, collections in, 128

Horace, 25;
the _crieur_, 28, 32;
book collecting, 50;
patina, 51

Huber, Dr. L., 131

Imbert, 141

Imitation and fraud in Rome, 24

Imitations, contemporaneous, 232

Imitations by noted factories, 256

Imitator, the, 170

Imitators and copyists, 59

Impasto painting, 230

_Imperator Caldusius_, 92

Impruneta clay, 187

Inlaid work on furniture, 282

Inscriptions, 93

Iron work, 266

Isotta Atti, 86

Italian artists, versatility of, 86

Italy, collections in, in the fifteenth century, 70

Italy, exportation laws, 179

Italian faience, imitations of, 250

_Itinerarium Galliæ_, by Just Zinzerling, 115

Ivory work, 244

Jabach, the dealer, 115, 123

Jests, 160

Jewellery, old, 278

Juba, King of Numidia, 212

Julius Cæsar, 21, 31;
a specialist, 42

Julius, Prætor, 60

Jupiter, colossal statue of, in the Louvre, 39

Jupiter, head of, 79

Jupiter Olympicus, temple of, 21

Jupiter, temple of, in Elis, 23

Justinian, digest of, 63

Juvenal, Codrus, 33;
Tongilius, 34;
Licinius, 34;
precious goblets, 52

Krieg, 248

La Bruyère, 124, 140

La Rochefoucauld, 195

Lamberti, Nicolo di Piero, 84

_Laocoön_, the, 104

Laws against exportation, 172

Lebroc, 209

Lequesne, M., 184

_Les Collections des Medicis_, 74

Lescot, 126

Libraries at Athens, 18

Licinius the nervous collector, 34

_Liste anonyme des curieux_, 115

Livy, 61

Lorenzo, il Magnifico, 75, 77, 78

Louis XI and the miraculous ring, 78

Louis XIII as a collector, 122

Louis XIV as a collector, 39, 123

Louvre, the, 40, 41, 92, 96, 120, 122, 187

Lovesque, 141

Lucian, on Roman tourist guides, 62, 307

Lucretius, candelabra, 30

Lucullus, 60

Lustre work, 250

Lyndon, Minerva’s temple at, 18

Lysippus, statue of Hercules, by, 36

Machiavelli, 102

Magliabechi, 307

Maillet, M. A., 201

Malachite, kind of patina, 265

Malatesta’s temple of love, 86

Manheim, connoisseur, 54, 261

Mantegna and Isabella d’Este, 81

_Maquilleur_, the, 216

Marcellus, 19

Marcus Agrippa, 43

Marcus Aurelius as an auctioneer, 212

Marcus Aurelius, statuette of, 97

Marguerite of Antioch, 39

Mark Antony as a collector, 22, 31;
rapacity, 38, 39;
Corinthian bronze, 51

Marks of noted pottery factories, 258

Marks on steel, 274

Marostica, 67

Marsigli, Luigi, 72

Martial, 26;
the _septæ_, 31;
Milonius, 32;
Clarinus and Paullus, 32;
Eros and Mamurra, 33;
statuette of Hercules, 36, 213

Marzi, Ezio, Prof., 191

Mazarin as a collector, 115, 117, 120

Mecherino, 106

_Médailles insolentes_, 128

Medals, forgers and imitators of antique, 100

Medals, patina for old, 265

Medici collection, fate of the, 74

Medicis, the, 72;
Piero, 75;
Cosimo, 75, 104;
Giulio, 77;
Ottaviano, 99;
Alexander, 101;
Lorenzino, 101

Mediæval collections, 64

Mégisserie, the, 111

Meissen china, booming, 151

Meleager, statuette of, 89

Melpomene, colossal, in the Louvre, 41

_Memoires de Brienne_, 127

_Mettere il bavaglino_, 157

Mexican idols, 246

Michelangelo, 89, 102, 103, 111

Michelangelo’s David, 108

Michelozzo, 75

Milanesi, 100

Milizia, 226

Millin, 136

Milonius, 32

Miniature work, 232

Miniatures in Rome, 30

Mino, 91

Minor collections, 299

Moabite pottery, forged, 205

Modena Museum, 91

Moderno, 97

Molière’s works, 294

Montaigne, 108

Moreau, artist in iron, 266

Morelli, 147

Mosaic, a Roman, 46

Muffled glaze, 251

Mummius, L., 19

Munich Museum, the, 185

Murrhines, 52

Murrhines, prices paid for, 25

Museum of Arezzo, 92

Museum of French monuments, 92

Museum of Munich, 92

Museums and forgeries, 153

Musical instruments, 284

Mustard pot, find of a, 161

Myron, 39

Mys, bronzes of, 30

Napoleon as an art collector, 132

Natali’s imitations, 182, 185, 190

National Museum, Florence, 91

Nero, 18, 46

Newton and Pascal, 201

Niccoli, Niccolo, 71, 92

Nicomedes, King, 37

Nieuwerkerque, 182

Nolives, 182

Nonius, 38

Numismatists, 92

Octavianus, a collector of Corinthian bronze, 51

_Oeci_, 49

Orlandini, Prof., 192

Orleans, Duke of, 129

Oriental pottery, 247, 249

Oriental weapons, 267

Over-restoration, 234

Paduan School, 91, 196

Pagan art, the worship of, 85

Painting, imitations in, 99

Painting, transformed, 168

Paintings, restoring, 225

Palazzo, Riccardi, the, 75

Palissy, 251

Palladium, Niccoli’s, 97

Paolo Veronese, 102

Paris, art sales in, 128

Parvenu collector, the, 82

Pascal and Newton, 201

Pasiteles, 21

Pastels and water colours, 232

Patinæ, 51;
bronze, 238;
marble, 241

Paul Potter, 232

Paullus, 32

Pausias, 42

Perenzolo, 69

Peristyle, the, 48

Perronet de Granvelle, 39

Pertinax, public auction by, 212

Peruvian pottery, 246, 248

“Peter Funk,” 222

Petrarch, 71

Petronius’ collection of Murrhines, 54

Petronius and art, 20, 26

Phœdrus, on faking, 59

Phidias, 20

Philippe-Egalité, 129

Photographing pseudo-masterpieces, 169

Pietà, Zampini’s, 185

Pinacotheca of the Acropolis, the, 49, 71

Piot, 140

_Plaquettes_, 88, 91, 93

Plato, portrait of, 91

Plautus (“Menœchme”), 28

Pliny, 18;
Gegania and Clesippus, 29;
candelabra, 30;
Nonius, 38;
the “Young Philippian,” 40;
Polygnotus and Pausias, 42;
Scaurus, 46;
Corinthian bronze, 51;
patina, 51;
Murrhines, 52;
_citrus_ tables, 54;
as a connoisseur in bronze, 57;
counterfeit Sardonyx, 58;
Evander Aulanius, 60;
Pliny, the younger, on faking, 59

Plutarch, “Sulla’s private travelling god,” 36

Police of Louis XIV, 128

Polish of faked furniture, the, 280

Politiano, 79

Pollaiodo, Antonio, 88

Polycletus, 24;
bronzes, 30;
cameo, 73

Polygnotus, 42

Pompey, a generous collector, 41

Pontchartrain, 128

Pope Leo X, portrait of, 99

Pope Sixtus IV and the Medicis, 80

Pottery, faked, 247, 253, 254

Pourquet, M., 295

Poustales collection, the, 89

_Præco_, the, 28, 213

Prado of Madrid, the, 87, 92

Praxiteles, 46

Precious stones, imitation of, 58

Prices and values, 147

Prints and drawings, faking old, 231

“Prioristi,” Florentine, 209

Private collections at Rome, beginning of, 22

Procopius, 62

Promenade of Pompey, 42

Propertius and Cynthia, 42

Protective laws, 105, 172

Psychology of collectors, the, 203

Ptolemy’s cup, 66

Public auctions in Rome, 28

Public sales, 211

Quattrocento imitations, 87;
velvets, 289

Quintilian, 24

Racine’s works, 294

Radegond, St., 65

Raester, Olga, 285

Rameses, the forged, 203

Renaissance fakers of art, 68

Restorers and fakers, 59, 165

Restorers’ workshops in Rome, 60

Restoring paintings, 226

Retouching, 225

Reville’s _Promptuarium_, 92

Revolution, ceramics of the French, 252

Revolution, French, influence of the, 132

Rhodes’ pottery, 248

Riccio, bronzes of, 87, 101

Richelieu as a collector, 115

_Ricordi_ of Lorenzo Medici, 78

Ridolfi, Prof., 178

Rienzi, 71

Rinuccini, 78

Rochefort, Henri, 162, 214

Rolland, Mme., 150

Roman busts, imitations of, 90

Roman house, the, 48, 49

Roman, the, not a lover of art, 18

Romano, Giulio, 111

Rome: the home of the collectors, 18;
development of art, 21;
beginnings of private collection, 22;
fictitious art and fraud, 24;
freakish prices, 25;
_septæ_, 28;
public auctions, 28;
an emporium of art, 44;
Roman house, 48;
faking and copying, 59;
artistic life, 60

Rosary, Mazarin’s valuable, 119

Rossini, 286

Rothschilds, the, 152, 235, 260, 269

Rovertet, 107

Rugs, Oriental, 293

_Sacrarium_, the, 49

St. Martin de Tours, monk of, 66

Saitaphernes, tiara of, 277

Sales of art collections, 128

Sales and auctions, 208

_Salle Lebrun_, the, 132

Salting collection, the, 191

Sanson, Charles, the executioner, a collector, 116

Sansovino, Jacopo, 89

Sardonyx, counterfeited, 58

Satire, on collecting, 125

_Satyricon_, the, 47

Sauval, 110

Savonarola, 83

_Sbullettare_, 186n.

Scaling of terra-cotta, 186

Scarampi, Cardinal, 73, 74

Scaurus, 45;
his atrium, 49

Scientific and artistic pursuits, 137

Scopas, 46

Seneca and art, 20;
collectors, 32;
bibliomaniacs, 50;
veneered furniture, 55

_Septæ_, the, 28, 29

Servilia, 47

Servilius, 46

Sèvres, museum at, 248

Shaw, Bernard, 142

Shaw, Quincy, 31, 141

Shields, story of the three, 271

Siena imitators, 191

_Sigillaria_, the, 31

Signatures and monograms, 193, 208, 231

Signorili, _Descriptio urbia Romæ_ of, 69

Silver, artistic, during the French Revolution, 275

Silver, colour and tone of, 276

Silver marks, 276

Silver work, 274

Silver, wrought, rage for, in Rome, 25

Sisinande, 56

Sixteenth-century art, 101

Slang, art dealers’, 159

Sleeping Cupid, the, 89

Smuggler, the, 171

Sogliani, 111

Solvents used in restoring pictures, 227

Specialist, the, 138

Spoon, Jacob, 127

_Sposalizio_, Correggio’s, 118

Squarcione, Francesco, 71

Staedel Museum, the, 96

Stamp-collecting, 299

Stanley, H. M., 142

Statues, 35, 36, 37

_Stemmata_, 49

Strongylion, bronze by, 40

Strozzi, Filippo, 101

_Stucco duro_ imitations, 237

Suetonius, 29;
Cæsar, 43, 212

Suggestion, influence of, 177

Sulla, 22, 31, 36

Supino, Prof., 178

Symbolic art, 63

_Tabulæ auctionariæ_, 213

Tanagras, faked, 235

Tane’s _Philosophie de l’Art_, 304

Tapestries, 49, 291

Tardieu and Sanson, 116

“Tazza Famese,” the, 80

Tedesco, Piero di Giovanni, 84

Tempera, use of, in restoring, 228

Temples as museums of art treasures, 18

Textile material, antique and modern, 288

Theophrastus, 18

Thibaudau, _Trésor de la Curiosité_, 128

Tiberius, II, 65

Timonacus, 43

Tintoretto, 102

Titian, 102, 120

Tongilius, the important collector, 34

Tortoise-shell as veneer, 55

Touchard, 248

Tourists in ancient Rome, 61

Trade and art, 150

_Traité des plus belles bibliothèques_, 115

Transferring bookbindings, 297

Trevoux, 136

Trimalcho, 26

_Triclinia_, 49

Trouillebert, 170

Tuscany, protective laws in, 106

Uffizi Gallery, the, 90

_Ulysses Belgico-Gallico_, Golnitz’s, 115

Urban VIII and the Coliseum, 105

Vaillant, 114

Valentino, Duke, 90

Valerius Maximus, 20

Varnish, imitating old and cracked, 229

Vasari, 86, 88, 89, 99, 225

Vedius Pollio and Augustus, 52

Vellano, bronzes of, 87, 88

Vellano, Vasari’s life of, 100

Velleius Paterculus, 19

Velvets, quattrocento and cinquecento, 289

Veneering in Rome, 55

Venetian works, effect of cleaning on, 217

Venus Anadyomene of Apelles, 60

Verres, the greedy collector, 22, 30, 31, 37

Verrocchio, Andrea del, 88-92

“Verrocchio and Co.,” 190

Vicentino, Valerio, 143

Victoria and Albert Museum, 96, 185, 188

Vindex, the real connoisseur, 35, 37

Virgil, 101

Vitruvius, 20;
private palaces, 45

Volpi, Elia, Prof., 178

Voltaire, 130

_Voyage pour l’Instruction_, Verdier’s, 115

_Voyage de Lister_, 115

_Voyage de Montaigne_, 108

Vrain-Lucas, 199

Vulteius Medas, 28

“Wall breakers” at Athens, 18

Walters, H., 141

Warton, 110

Weapons, faked, 267

Wax work, 244

“Way for Asses, The,” 161

White, Stanford, 141, 304

Winckelmann, 36, 53, 58

Wood carving, colouring, 243

Worm-holes in furniture, imitation, 281

“Young Philippian,” the, 40

Zampini, Ferrante, 182, 185, 198

Zenodonis, a copyist, 59

Printed in Great Britain at
_The Mayflower Press, Plymouth_. William Brendon & Son, Ltd.

1921

Transcriber’s Notes

Punctuation, hyphenation, and spelling were made consistent when a predominant preference was found in this book; otherwise they were not changed.

Simple typographical errors were corrected; occasional unbalanced quotation marks retained.

Ambiguous hyphens at the ends of lines were retained.

The spelling and accent marks in non-English text were not checked for accuracy.

Index not checked for proper alphabetization or correct page references.

Page 26: Missing opening quotation marks added before “Think of it!” and before “Well, it belonged to”.

Page 110: “Duke d’Aumule” is listed on page 313 of the Index as “d’Aunale, Duc”. The common spelling today is “d’Aumale”.

End of Project Gutenberg's The Gentle Art of Faking, by Riccardo Nobili