Chapter IX: Section 1: That where time is not allowed, the Master Mechanic (4)

DEAR SIR AND BROTHER: Your favor of December 6 came to hand during
my absence from the city, which accounts for a delayed answer. I
cannot give you any information of the action of the Committee
appointed by the engineers in their Convention, other than what I
received from Grand Chief Arthur and one member of the Committee. I
have heard that it was the intention of the Committee to end the
strike; but I can say to you honestly and candidly, that so far as
a boycott is concerned it is simply nonsense to talk about it. Any
sane man who will carefully consider the present situation of the
C., B. & Q., and the condition of our organization, would see the
folly of our contemplating such a step. The day for boycott has
long gone by; there was a time when it could have been put into
effect, and something accomplished by it, had there been any
disposition on the part of a large number of men to maintain it,
but any man who was a witness of the situation at Chicago, during
the time of the boycott, would see the folly of talking about one
in this instance; and I must say to you very firmly and honestly,
that the Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen, as an organization,
will have nothing whatever to do with a boycott, no matter what Mr.
Cavener's statements may be. I am waiting for the report of this
Committee which has been appointed by the engineers. When their
report comes in, if they have no way of ending the strike, I will
find a way of getting the Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen out of
it, and I will go to work and endeavor to find employment for our
members who are not able to find it themselves. It is a very good
idea to go to work and preach federation and all these different
doctrines, and then, when the time comes to act upon them,
repudiate them. There is no man who appreciates the manly stand of
the C., B. & Q. firemen more than I, and there is no one in a
better position to see the condition of the organization than I am.
I am speaking for no effect other than to express my honest
opinion. The time has come when this strike must end and the men
must look for employment, and the quicker this is done the better
it will be for all concerned. There are those in our Order who are
not earning $40 per month and whose wages are far below the wages
paid on the Western roads. These men have paid their last dollar
and they are in want; their families must have clothes, they must
have fuel to keep them warm; and I can tell you as a friend and
brother that I do not propose to drive such men out of the
organization after having done what they could to maintain the
strike. As soon as the strike is off we will devote our time and
attention to finding employment for such men as desire to make
application to the Grand Officers.

Let the consequences be what they will, we have decided upon the
stand we shall take, and I shall take it as an official of the
Order. The engineers in their Convention were informed of my
opinion, as was Mr. Cavener, and it seems to me that when their
Committee was appointed, it would have been nothing more than
proper courtesy to have requested one of our members to act with
them. This they did not do. They say it was an oversight, but it
does not change my opinion as to their duty. I have learned through
a member of the Committee of what their action will be; and I
desire to say to you as a brother, with the best feelings towards
you and other members of your Lodge and all strikers, that the
advice we gave you in our last communication was for your best
interests as well as to the interests of every member in the
country. The men who preach boycott had better be engaged in
bringing about federation of the different organizations, so that
they may act in harmony one with another. Better be men and
acknowledge the strike lost, look for work and get themselves in a
position to fight again when we are called upon to do so.

I trust you will receive this communication in the spirit in which
it is written, as I desire to be honest with you and to give you
what I believe the best advice that I possibly can, and, mark my
words, the day will come when you will say that I was right. It may
be when I am officially dead, but I know what the final result will
be. I have the best of feeling for the engineers on the Burlington
system, they have done their duty and done it manfully; and had
they the support which they ought to have had, the result of the
strike would have been very different.

Trusting that the Brothers have decided to take the advice of one
who is their friend, and if they desire assistance in the way of
positions and situations that they will apply for them, and wishing
you all success, I remain,

Yours fraternally,
FRANK P. SARGENT, G. M.

"The particular charge made was that Grand Master Sargent had advised firemen to take the places of engineers. And upon this gratuitous falsehood every conceivable charge has been rung. It will be observed that there is not so much as an intimation of such a thing, nor can any amount of torture of Grand Master Sargent's language make it convey such an idea."

End of Project Gutenberg's The Great Strike on the 'Q', by John A. Hall