Chapter XXX: Part 30

Pulmonary symptoms which may furnish therapeutic indications are cough and expectoration, hæmoptysis, pain in the chest, and dyspnoea. Cough is of course necessary for the removal of the morbid products within the bronchial tubes and cavities. If the act of coughing be accompanied by expectoration, palliation is not required. But often there is what may be called a superfluous cough--that is, not accompanied by expectoration. This superfluous cough may be frequent, and occur in violent paroxysms which occasion fatigue and exhaustion. Frequently the cough prevents sleep. Palliative remedies are then indicated. It is desirable, if possible, to palliate cough with remedies which do not contain an opiate, owing to the impairment of appetite and digestion caused by the latter. Simple remedies, such as the balsam of tolu, the syrup of wild-cherry bark, Turlington's balsam, etc., may suffice. If not, other narcotics than opium should be tried--namely, hyoscyamus, lactucarium, and belladonna. Fothergill recommends hydrobromic acid and the spirits of chloroform. The addition, however, of some form of opiate is often required. The paregoric elixir is the simplest form, and therefore the best if it suffice. Of other forms, perhaps codeia is in general to be preferred. Patients should be enjoined not to prolong voluntarily ineffectual coughing efforts. The disposition to cough may in a considerable degree be controlled by the will until the morbid products are in a situation to be readily expectorated. The stimulant expectorants and those which act by causing nausea are not indicated in cases of phthisis, and are objectionable in so far as they impair appetite and digestion. Stimulating medicinal {437} inhalations are of doubtful propriety, but a superfluous cough is sometimes relieved by breathing some vapor, a little laudanum or paregoric elixir having been added to the water vaporized. The continuous breathing of an atmosphere charged with carbolic acid, either by diffusing it in an apartment or the use of a respirator, is advisable if there be fetor of the expectoration.

It has been seen that bronchial hemorrhage is not, as a rule, an unfavorable event in cases of phthisis. It does not follow from this fact that the loss of blood is desirable, and therefore that the hemorrhage should not be arrested. Moreover, the loss of blood in some instances involves immediate danger. A first attack of hæmoptysis occasions great alarm and anxiety. The prostration which appears is a moral effect rather than the exhaustion caused by the loss of blood. In repeated instances after attacks of hæmoptysis have several times recurred, I have known patients to keep about as usual during an attack, giving little or no heed to it.

The internal remedies which may be employed for the arrest of hemorrhage are: Ergot or ergotin, acetate of lead, tannic or gallic acid, and the astringent preparations of iron. Ergotin has been given with good effect by subcutaneous injection, from five to ten grains in water, with or without glycerin, being injected and repeated pro re nata. Opium in some form should be conjoined in order to allay nervous excitement. A teaspoonful of table-salt taken into the mouth and repeated after intervals of a few moments is a well-known remedy during the hemorrhage. The hemorrhage is sometimes so profuse and rapid that much blood is swallowed, and may be afterward vomited. Under these circumstances, and whenever the persistence of the hæmoptysis calls for more prompt measures, cold may be applied to the part of the chest which corresponds to the seat of the hemorrhage. This may be found by means of a localized subcrepitant râle. Another measure is the inhalation of a vaporized solution of the liquid persulphate of iron. Still another and more potential measure is the temporary ligation of one or more of the members of the body, the pressure being sufficient to interrupt the flow of blood in the veins and not in the arteries. This measure must be resorted to and continued only when the physician is present. The effect is sometimes almost magical. The measure is a substitute for venesection, which was formerly employed for the arrest of bronchial hemorrhage. Cavernous hemorrhage, occurring usually late in the disease, if profuse calls for prompt measures, and the topical employment of cold will be likely to be the most promptly effective.

Pain in the chest denotes either pleurisy or intercostal neuralgia. Mild counter-irritant applications by sinapisms or stimulating liniments, with anodynes graduated to the degree of pain, are indicated. Dyspnoea, if not caused by restrained movements of the chest from pain, or by pleuritic effusion, or by an intercurrent pneumonia, may denote either rapidity and extent of the tuberculous deposit or an accumulation of morbid products within the bronchial tubes: if the latter be the explanation, acts of expectoration are to be promoted. This is not easily done if the difficulty of expectoration proceed from great general debility. The ethereal stimulants, Hoffmann's anodyne, chloric ether, and the compound spirits of lavender are advisable under these circumstances as palliatives.

Pyrexia and increased frequency of the heart's action are symptoms indicative of an active tuberculous cachexia. How far these are purely symptomatic, and how far they may conduce to the progress of the disease, cannot be determined with our present knowledge. It may be assumed that they represent something more than is represented generally by the fever which is secondary to a local inflammation. That the febrile temperature is itself causative of changes in the tissues, as well as in the functions of the body, is probable; and the muscular power of the heart must be weakened by the {438} persistent frequency of its action. A rational object in therapeutics is either the removal or the neutralization of the morbid conditions on which the pyrexia and the increased frequency of the heart's action depend. The means of effecting this object are to be determined in the future, when more is known of the morbid conditions giving rise to pyrexia; meanwhile, there are certain medicines which, as experience shows, diminish the temperature, and febrile temperature can be reduced by external means which abstract heat from the body.

At the present time data are wanting for determining the importance of antipyretic treatment in cases of phthisis. Hyperpyrexia, however, may be considered as furnishing an indication for a trial of antipyretic medication, and the most reliable of the drugs employed for that purpose is quinia. It should be given for this object in full doses, as in other instances in which it is given for an antipyretic effect. These doses should not be continued long enough to disorder the stomach. Diurnal exacerbations of fever, especially if ushered in by a chill, may sometimes be arrested, or, if not arrested, materially modified, by full doses of quinia, although there may be no ground for the suspicion of malaria.

When the skin is hot and dry, with a high axillary temperature, sponging the body may be employed and continued until the pyrexia is diminished. I am not prepared to say whether the cold bath or the wet sheet is admissible or allowable. As having some antipyretic effect, and as diminishing the frequency of the heart's action, digitalis might be expected to prove a valuable remedy to fulfil the symptomatic indications under consideration. This drug was formerly much employed in cases of phthisis. The fact that it has in a great measure fallen into disuse may be taken as evidence that the theoretical recommendations are not sustained by clinical experience. The liability to disturbance of the stomach from its use is perhaps a sufficient reason for considering it inapplicable.

The profuse night-sweating which so often occurs in the course of phthisis claims treatment. Belladonna or atropia, the oxide or sulphate of zinc, gallic acid, the acetate of lead, and aromatic sulphuric acid are internal remedies for the palliation of this symptom. Sponging the surface before bedtime with diluted alcohol, diluted acetic acid, or with spirit in which alum is dissolved should be tried. Hot vinegar largely charged with capsicum has been found to be an efficient application. The covering at night should be as light as is consistent with comfort. Brunton has found strychnine and nux vomica, given at bedtime, useful. Another remedy, recommended by Murrell, is picrotoxin. This is given in the form of a solution (1 part to 240 parts water), the doses of from one to four minims daily, the last dose given late at night.[33] Agaricus, or the common toadstool, is recommended as an efficient remedy by Wolfenden of London and J. M. Young of Glasgow. From ten to twenty grains may be given in the form of an electuary with honey, or it may be given in the form of a tincture. In both these modes it is apt to cause nausea. This objection does not apply to the isolated medicinal principle, a crystallized substance which it is proposed to designate agaracine. Of this one-twelfth of a grain is a dose, which may be repeated if required. Young is of the opinion that it is not less effective than atropia as an antihydrotic remedy, and not open to the same degree of danger from an overdose as the latter. He has found it to act also as a soporific remedy, to relieve cough, and to diminish the temperature of the body.[34] A popular remedy is cold sage tea taken at bedtime.

[Footnote 33: Vide _Supplement to Ziemssen's Cyclopædia_, 1881, p. 325.]

[Footnote 34: _Glasgow Medical Journal_, March, 1882.]

Of complications and associated diseases, one of the most frequent is disease of the intestine. Of diarrhoea not thus connected the treatment is that {439} of indigestion. As incident to tuberculous ulcerations opium and astringents are indicated. Full doses of the carbonate of bismuth, with a salt of morphia, will often prove an efficient palliative. Peritonitis, acute and chronic, pleurisy with effusion, chronic laryngitis, pneumo-hydrothorax, and cerebral meningitis are to be treated according to indications which are considered in the articles treating of these affections, making of course proper allowances for their occurrence as secondary to the phthisical disease. Intermittent fever associated with phthisis should be arrested as promptly as possible. There is no foundation for the opinion which some have held that malaria retards the progress of tuberculous disease. Clinical facts show directly the reverse. If a perineal fistula occurs in a phthisical patient, the safest policy is not to interfere with it except so far as to make it as endurable as practicable. The idea that a fistula has a salutary effect by way of revulsion has been one of the reasons for making artificially an issue in the arm or elsewhere. This was formerly much in vogue, but it has mostly, and probably deservedly, fallen into disuse.

Medical opinion is sometimes asked concerning the propriety of marriage with a phthisical man or woman. As an abstract question there need be no hesitation as to the answer. If men went about deliberately selecting wives, or vice versâ--as, for example, horses are selected--there could be no doubt that phthisis should be considered a disqualification. Husbands and wives, however, are not mated in such a way. A marriage engagement has been entered into, and afterward one of the parties becomes phthisical. The friends of the non-phthisical party, not the parties themselves, come for advice, and the adviser is sometimes placed in an awkward situation. With respect to the effect of marriage on the tuberculous party, my analysis of 17 cases, 2 only being women, did not show that it was unfavorable. Were it unfavorable, considerations of sentiment and sense of duty generally outweigh all others. A more important point relates to offspring. A hereditary tendency is entailed in some, but not in all cases. The risk incurred in this point of view having been fairly stated, the responsibility of the medical adviser is ended.

After recovery from phthisis measures for the prevention of a relapse should receive due attention. The hygienic influences which were brought to bear on the disease, and which, as it is fair to conclude, had more or less agency in effecting the recovery, are as far as practicable to remain in operation. This important injunction applies alike to cases in which an arrest of the disease has taken place, so long as it ceases to be progressive. To prevent a renewal of its progress is an object having a similar importance as the prevention of a relapse after recovery.

In concluding the consideration of the treatment of pulmonary phthisis reference is to be made to a measure to which one of our countrymen has recently given much attention--namely, the injection of tuberculous cavities. More than thirty years ago the late Brainerd of Chicago related to me a case in which he made an opening through the chest-wall into a tuberculous cavity. He had the idea that cavities might in this way be treated by local applications with advantage. Of the result in that case it is only recollected that no bad consequences followed. Probably Brainerd did not prosecute further experimental observations, as I am not aware of any publication by him on the subject. In 1873, Mosler of Germany advocated making a free opening in tuberculous cavities with a view to drainage and topical treatment. He reported 3 cases in which a drainage-tube was introduced and kept in the cavity. The practicability of the operation and the absence of any evil result were shown by his cases. The operation had been advocated and performed prior to Mosler's publication, but without exciting consideration. To William Pepper belongs the credit of injecting medicated liquids by means {440} of a small syringe and hollow needles. Pepper has reported 12 cases in which cavities were thus injected. In these 12 cases two hundred and ten injections were made. In no instance did any harm result therefrom. The injected liquid in most of the cases was a very weak solution of iodine. In some instances a weak solution of carbolic acid was used. The objects are "the disinfection of the cavities, the relief of cough, the diminution of secretion, and the modification of the morbid action of the lining surface of the cavity, so as to favor cicatrization and contraction and the prevention of infection of the constitution." The results of the treatment in the cases reported by Pepper go to show that it may contribute to these objects. His observations have opened up a new and important department in the therapeutics of pulmonary phthisis.[35]

[Footnote 35: For reports of Pepper's cases and other details vide article in the _Transactions of the American Medical Association_, vol. xxxi., 1880; also article in the _American Journal of Medical Sciences_, October, 1874.]

Fibroid Phthisis, Chronic Interstitial Pneumonia, Cirrhosis of Lung.

The characteristic anatomical feature of this variety of phthisis is the predominant growth of the pulmonary connective tissue. If, as is generally held, this hyperplasia be due to a chronic inflammatory process, the name chronic interstitial pneumonia is not inappropriate. From an analogy to the structural affection of the liver characterized by an abnormal development of Glisson's capsule, the affection was called by Corrigan cirrhosis of the lung. The propriety of regarding it as a distinct form of pulmonary phthisis is based on points pertaining to the morbid anatomy and to the clinical history.

An abnormal interstitial growth enters more or less largely as an element into the morbid anatomy in cases of the ordinary form of phthisis. It is the chief element in typical cases of fibroid phthisis. The affected lung-structure is condensed and indurated, owing to obliteration of alveoli and bronchial tubes. The affection leads to notable diminution in volume. Resulting therefrom is a compensatory dilatation of bronchial tubes. Sacculated dilatations may reach the size of an English walnut or even a hen's egg. These are known as bronchiectasic cavities. The pleura is thickened and the opposed surfaces closely adherent to each other. With these distinctive changes are usually found small cheesy tuberculous deposits or true tuberculous cavities and miliary tubercles. The latter anatomical points show relationship to the ordinary form of phthisis. Exceptional cases are those in which the interstitial pneumonia is the result purely of the local action of inhaled irritating particles (vide PNEUMONOKONIOSIS). In these cases the tuberculous characteristics may be wanting. In cases of fibroid phthisis both lungs are often affected. But the affection is apt to be confined to, or much more extensive in, one lung, so that during life it either is, or appears to be, unilateral. Exceptionally, both lungs are extensively affected. It may originate in and be limited to a lower lobe. It is stated by Trojanowsky that when the affection is unilateral it oftener begins in the upper lobe, and when bilateral the lower lobes are first affected. A series of bronchiectasic dilatations may be so closely situated as to resemble an anfractuous cavity resulting from the discharge of liquefied tuberculous deposits.

It is customary to consider this affection as occurring consecutively to acute lobar and broncho-pneumonia, to chronic bronchitis, and to pleurisy. Taking into view, however, the slow, insidious development of the affection, the infrequency of its occurrence, and the frequency of the diseases just named, a more rational conclusion perhaps is that when these diseases are associated {441} with the phthisical affection they are secondary to it. The affection occurs oftener after than during the decade in which the ordinary form of phthisis is most apt to occur--that is, after thirty years of age.

The course of the affection as regards activity of progress is strikingly different from that of ordinary phthisis in a large proportion of cases. Commencing imperceptibly, after it has advanced to a certain extent it may remain apparently stationary, or it progresses very slowly during a long period. Its duration may extend over many years. In a case for a long time under my observation it existed probably for forty years. If the lesions be not extensive enough to interfere notably with the respiratory function, it may be tolerated indefinitely. The appetite, digestion, and nutrition may be well maintained. The muscular strength may not be much impaired. The circulation, temperature of the body, and other functions may be but little disturbed. A fatal termination, if not caused by some intercurrent disease, takes place after a very gradually progressive general debility and exhaustion.

As regards the different anatomical systems of the body other than the respiratory system, it is not important to add to the foregoing sketch details of symptomatology. The important symptoms referable to the respiratory system relate to cough, expectoration, and disturbance of respiration. The cough varies according to the quantity and character of the matter to be expectorated, the difficulty of its expulsion, and the susceptibility of the patient to the reflex influences on which cough depends. The matter expectorated is muco-purulent, and in many instances it is at times extremely fetid. This is due to the putrescency of morbid products detained within the bronchiectasic cavities and bronchial tubes, owing to difficulty in effecting their expulsion. The fetor may be suggestive of gangrene. The matter expectorated, however, if examined microscopically, will not be found to contain the débris of pulmonary structure. There may be sloughing of small portions of mucous membrane, but this is probably rare. The expectoration after certain intervals of putrid sputa in considerable or great abundance, the expectorated matter during the intervals having the characters of muco-pus without fetor, is almost pathognomonic of this variety of phthisis. The repeated occurrence of the putrid sputa, the clinical history, and the physical signs render it easy to exclude abscess of the lung. The detention of morbid products within bronchiectasic cavities, and the consequent putrescent decomposition, depend of course on the difficulty with which the contents of the cavity are expelled. This difficulty is greater if the cavities be in the lower than in the upper lobe. In a case which came under my observation the affection had been known by the attending physician to have existed for fifteen years. There was more or less habitual expectoration of ordinary muco-purulent matter, but after intervals of several days a considerable quantity of intolerably fetid matter was expelled. In this case the physical signs showed the affection to be limited to the lower lobe of the left lung. There was notable retraction of the lower and lateral portions of the chest on this side; solidification of lung was denoted by bronchial respiration and bronchophony over the posterior aspect; and the cavernous respiration was perceived over a circumscribed area in the latero-posterior aspect. This patient's general condition of health was fair; he had not a morbid aspect, and he was able to perform the duties of a clerkship in one of the municipal departments.

The respirations are more or less increased in frequency, the increase, other things being equal, being in proportion to the amount of damage of the pulmonary organs, or, in other words, the extent to which the respiratory function is compromised by the lesions. These may be sufficient to give rise to much suffering from dyspnoea. This was true of a case under my observation in which both lungs were extensively affected, while the muscular {442} strength and the functions generally of the body were not greatly impaired. The embarrassment of breathing is increased by an accumulation of muco-pus within the bronchial tubes, and notable relief follows expectoration of the accumulated products. Hæmoptysis occurs in some cases, but much less frequently than in the ordinary form of phthisis. The hemorrhage is sometimes profuse. It proceeds from erosion of the walls of vessels or the bursting of small aneurisms within bronchiectasic cavities.

Cyanosis is marked in some cases. This symptom is not always in proportion to the dyspnoea; that is, the cyanotic appearance of the prolabia and face may be present when the patient does not manifest suffering from a sense of the want of breath. The cyanosis is symptomatic of distension of the cavities of the right side of the heart, this being an effect of the obstruction of the pulmonary circulation. The obstruction may lead at length to dilatation of the right ventricle and auricle. Thence arises the general dropsy which may take place at an advanced period of the history of fibroid phthisis. A tricuspid regurgitant murmur may be perceived with or before the occurrence of dropsy; also visible pulsation of the cervical veins. A frequent physical sign under these circumstances is bulbous enlargement of the ends of the fingers and sometimes of the toes. The clubbed fingers, as they are called, are symptomatic of disturbance of the circulation. They are observed in some cases of disease of the heart, phthisis not existing.

The physical conditions giving rise to physical signs are as follows: Notable shrinkage of lung; solidification, which, if the lung be much diminished in volume, may be considerable or complete in degree and extensive; dilated tubes and bronchiectasic cavities varying in size, number, and relative situations; the presence of muco-pus in more or less abundance, the quantity variable at different times within the bronchial tubes and cavities. Vicarious emphysema is more frequent than in the ordinary form of phthisis.

In typical cases of extensive and advanced unilateral fibroid phthisis the affected side is much contracted. The appearance is like that presented in some cases after recovery from chronic pleurisy. The range of respiratory movements is much diminished, the two sides presenting a marked contrast in this regard. With this one-sided contraction of the chest there may be lateral curvature of the spine, the concavity looking toward the affected side. The supposition that the contraction is in reality a sequel of chronic pleurisy is at once disproved by finding the evidence of a degree of solidification notably greater than would be incident to the mere diminution of the volume of the lung. If the affection be limited to a lobe, either the upper or lower, there may be contraction more or less marked over the portion of the chest corresponding to the affected lobe. If the two lungs be much affected, the evidence of contraction is apparent to the eye on both sides. It is rarely if ever that the two lungs are equally affected.

The signs furnished by percussion and auscultation which represent solidification of lung, the presence of air in dilated tubes or bronchiectasic cavities and emphysematous lobules, are present either separately or in various degrees of combination. Solidification from induration without dilatation, sacculated or otherwise, of tubes, or if these be filled with morbid products and without vicarious emphysema of adjacent lobules, will give dulness on percussion more or less marked and over an area corresponding to the degree and the extent of the solidification. There may be flatness over the greater part or the whole of an entire lobe. Often, however, dulness is found in some situation, and either tympanitic or vesiculo-tympanitic resonance in other situations. Over bronchiectasic dilatations a tympanitic resonance may have the amphoric or the cracked-metal intonation. On auscultation the respiration over a space more or less extensive or within separate spaces of variable extent is either bronchial or broncho-vesicular. With these respiratory signs {443} representing solidification of lung are associated either bronchophony or increased vocal resonance, and the corresponding whispering signs--namely, whispering bronchophony and increased bronchial whisper. Over bronchiectasic cavities, may be heard the cavernous respiration and whisper. These signs of cavity may be combined with those of adjacent solidification of lung, giving rise to the several varieties of broncho-cavernous respiration. Coarse mucous or bubbling râles are of frequent occurrence, and the accumulation of muco-pus within the cavities may be represented by gurgling.

By means of the foregoing signs furnished by percussion and auscultation the character of the lesions, their situation, their extent, and the physical conditions as regards the presence of morbid products within the air-cavities, are determinable. These lesions are sometimes in striking contrast to the symptoms which represent the general conditions of the patient--the pulse, temperature, emaciation, etc. The symptoms and the physical signs may seem to conflict with each other, owing to the remarkable tolerance of the disease in some cases. To the physical changes which have been stated is to be added removal of the heart from its normal situation. If the seat of the affection be the left lung, its shrinkage may be such that the heart rises into the infra-clavicular region, and the space within which it is in contact with the chest-wall is larger than when the organ is in its normal situation. The latter circumstance is to be borne in mind with reference to the error of inferring therefrom enlargement of the heart. Not only is the area of notable dulness on percussion over the heart greater than in health, but the movements of the organ are remarkably apparent to the eye and touch. If the right lung be affected, the heart may be removed to the right of the sternum, the heart-sounds being heard here with their maximum of intensity. In this abnormal situation the presence of the heart may give rise to a notable dulness on percussion, and its impulses may be both seen and felt.

The differentiation of fibroid phthisis from the ordinary forms of the disease cannot be made with positiveness so long as the anatomical changes are small or moderate in degree and extent. The chief differential point is a greater degree of depression at the summit of the chest than would be likely to occur at an early period if the affection were of the ordinary form. If the affection begin at the base of the chest, it is more likely to be the fibroid variety. In typical cases, when the affection is unilateral and has led to notable shrinkage of the entire lung, taking the physical signs in connection with the evidence of tolerance afforded by the symptoms, it may be differentiated with confidence. Age is to be taken into account in the diagnosis; patients are rarely under forty. The expectoration from time to time of fetid mucus has considerable diagnostic significance.

With reference to the diagnosis, it is to be considered that between the ordinary form of phthisis and typical cases of fibroid phthisis there is every degree of gradation as regards the combination of the anatomical characters of both. There is no sharp line of demarcation between the two varieties. In these intermediate cases to determine by means of the symptoms and physical signs the relative proportion of each variety is not practicable, nor is this a matter of much practical importance. It may be added that the coexistence of chronic laryngitis and of tuberculous disease of the intestine is proof against fibroid phthisis. There is no possibility of the restoration of a lung affected with fibroid phthisis to its normal condition; but the prognosis as regards tolerance, arrest of progress or slowness of progress, and consequently duration of life, is much better than in the ordinary form of phthisis. On this account the diagnosis is of importance. The prognosis is better the nearer the approach to the affection in typical cases. Per contra, the prognosis is less favorable in proportion as the changes characteristic of the disease in its ordinary form are associated with those characterizing fibroid phthisis. If the affection be {444} confined to a lower lobe, it may not extend beyond this limit, and the persistence of solidification of the affected lobe may not be incompatible with good general health. Of these facts the following case is an illustration: Phoebe, aged five years, came under my observation in 1864. There was at that time notable dulness on percussion over the lower lobe of the left lung, with bronchial respiration and bronchophony. She had cough and expectoration, but had not been confined to the bed or house, and her general condition of health was then fair. The treatment consisted of tonic remedies and out-of-door life. I saw her repeatedly during the next two or three years, the physical signs remaining the same, and the general health fair. In 1869 she had chorea and was treated with Fowler's solution. I did not see her again until October, 1871; she had then, and had never been free from, some cough and expectoration, but her general health had been maintained. The signs of the solidification of the lower lobe of the left lung were then present, the upper lobe remaining unaffected. In November, 1874, I noted that I had again seen her and examined the chest. The dulness on percussion over the lower lobe of the left lung continued; there was at this time absence of respiratory sound over this lobe, but the vocal resonance was greater than on the opposite side. The left side was considerably contracted. She had still some cough and expectoration, and there was some deficiency of breath on active exercise. Her aspect was healthful, and she was well developed for her age (fifteen years). Menstruation was irregular. She consulted me for this irregularity, not regarding herself as ill in other respects. About six years afterward I met her in the street, and she accosted me. Her appearance was healthful.[36]

[Footnote 36: This patient remains in fair health at the present time, May, 1883, nearly twenty years after she first came under my observation.]

The treatment in cases of fibroid phthisis differs in no essential points from that in cases of the ordinary form of the disease. The slowness of progress and the long duration show less activity of the tuberculous cachexia. Nevertheless, the cachexia either exists or has existed, and the measures relating thereto which have been considered as belonging to the dietetic and regiminal treatment are alike applicable to both varieties of phthisis. The circumstances which render changes of climate admissible, if not advisable, are much oftener present in the fibroid variety, and there is greater probability of the disease being either arrested or retarded. Medicinal treatment is to be employed with reference to therapeutic indications alike in both varieties of the disease.

The treatment by inhalations to prevent putrefactive changes in the contents of bronchial tubes and in cavities is oftener indicated by fetid sputa in cases of fibroid phthisis. The continuous breathing of the atmosphere of a room containing an antiseptic vapor requires the patient to remain within doors. A more effective method is to make use of a respirator inhaler. A portable and convenient instrument, worn over the mouth like an ordinary respirator, has been devised by W. Roberts and improved upon by H. Curschmann. In this instrument the air which is breathed passes through layers of tow moistened with the antiseptic liquid. The disinfecting agents which have been found efficient are carbolic acid, creasote, oil of turpentine, a mixture of the tincture of iodine and the compound tincture of benzoin and thymol.[37]

[Footnote 37: Vide article by William Pepper in _Transactions of the American Medical Association_, vol. xxxi., 1880.]

Prevention of Phthisis.

The number of deaths throughout the globe which are caused by pulmonary phthisis vastly exceeds the number caused by any other disease. {445} The etiology of pulmonary phthisis embraces largely causes which can be removed. Hence the disease is to a great extent preventable. Are any comments on these simple statements needed in order that the prevention of phthisis may be regarded as among the most important of the subjects belonging to preventive medicine?

It has been assumed that phthisis involves a predisposition which is in most, and perhaps in all, cases innate. Putting aside all questions relating to an acquired tuberculous diathesis, it may be assumed that the development of the phthisical affection depends in many or perhaps in most cases, more or less, and probably often in a great measure, upon causes which promote the diathetic condition. Now, many of these causes are removable, and if removed phthisis is prevented, and the prevention of a disease which may properly be called a scourge of the human family will be diminished.

Of removable causes may be mentioned humidity of the soil in places of residence; living in small unventilated dwellings; confinement within doors; breathing in close workshops or factories, and in overcrowded rooms at night, an atmosphere deficient in oxygen and contaminated with pulmonary and cutaneous emanations; working underground in mines from which light as well as pure air is excluded; a deficiency of food sufficiently wholesome and varied; impairment of the cutaneous functions from uncleanliness; and want of a proper adaptation of clothing to the climate or season. These are obvious violations of the hygienic requirements for health. It is unnecessary to cite facts to show to what extent these violations prevail in different countries. They are causes which admit of removal, however difficult may be the task. Connected with their removal are other considerations than the prevention of phthisis. But confining the attention exclusively to the latter object, how incalculable would be the saving of life and health were these causes to be removed! Much has been done within the last half century toward diminishing the mortality from phthisis by advancement in pathological and therapeutical knowledge; how much more remains to be done by preventive measures!

The prophylaxis against phthisis must date from birth. An infant should not nurse a mother who is consumptive or whose milk is of poor quality. Care is to be observed in the selection of wet-nurses. All the various articles which are sold under the name of infants' food should be discarded. Many of these are fraudulent; that is, they are not what they purport to be. But admitting that, if properly prepared, they are safe substitutes for milk and the simple farinaceous foods, there can be no guarantee for their proper preparation; and the risk is too great to rely upon articles which cannot be readily tested and for the genuineness of which dependence must be placed on irresponsible dealers.[38] There is need of much caution respecting the purity of milk, especially in cities. Much harm is not infrequently done by over-care in children's diet--that is, by denying articles which they crave, and restricting them to those which they do not like. In this matter the instincts are not to be set aside, especially in early life, when perversions of appetite and taste have not been acquired. Not infrequently from undue caution the quantity of food is restricted, and children suffer from insufficient alimentation; this is more likely to occur in our country among the wealthy than among the poorer classes. Other prophylactic provisions pertaining to exercise, out-of-door life, clothing, etc. need not here be considered.

[Footnote 38: Vide "Address by A. Jacobi on Infant Diet," _Transactions of the New York State Medical Society_, 1882.]

In order to combat the various causes which have been named, knowledge of hygienic laws must be diffused among all classes. There is a lamentable lack of information and of interest as regards matters of hygiene among the more intelligent classes. But it is not sufficient to enlighten these: the {446} knowledge must be extended, as far as practicable, to those who, in this point of view, are lower in the scale. Many persons of wealth fall in this category. The causes which are purely personal can be reached only by information diffused by means of publications, lectures, and intercourse with medical men and others. Here is a rich field for missionary labors. To overcome certain of the causes, however, the intervention of legislative authority is necessary. With reference thereto health boards, properly constituted and invested with adequate powers, should be organized in States, counties, and cities. In this way it is practicable by the prevention of phthisis to lessen greatly the rate of mortality.

Protection against the communication of the disease requires to be specially noticed. Occupying the same bed with phthisical patients and sleeping in the same room, if the latter be not enjoined by the dictates of humanity, are objectionable. They are to be objected to on the score of unhygienic influences, physical and moral, irrespective of the doctrine of a tuberculous contagium, and of course still more in view of the probabilities in favor of this doctrine. Care should be taken to exclude from the table the meat of tuberculous animals. In addition to the purity of milk in other regards, it should be ascertained that the supply is not from cows affected with tuberculous disease. Obviously, this is especially of importance with reference to infants who are bottle-fed and in childhood, when generally milk forms a much larger proportion of the diet than in after years. The ventilation of apartments occupied by phthisical patients should be attended to with reference to the possibility of the disease being communicated by the inhalation of particles of tubercle; and it may not be a needless precaution to introduce a disinfectant into the vessels which receive the matter expectorated.

{447}

SYPHILITIC DISEASE OF THE LUNG.

BY EDWARD T. BRUEN, M.D.

DEFINITION.--Lesions of the lungs with a syphilitic impress include catarrhal inflammation of the bronchial mucous membranes, chronic inflammatory new formations, which affect especially the connective tissue, producing sclerosis or else gummatous growths.

HISTORY.--From the early part of the eighteenth century attempts have been made to create a word-portraiture representing the peculiar features of syphilitic pulmonary disease as a separate entity. It has been defined histologically and clinically from simple and from fibroid phthisis, or from cases of syphilis in which a damaged state of the general health has fostered the development of phthisis. But the question, Is there a peculiar microscopic and macroscopic anatomy, or a special symptomatology by the aid of which the cause, seat, and dissemination of pulmonary syphilis can be recognized? remains even now but partially removed from the field of debate and conjecture, although unquestionably the syphilitic poison bears intimate relation with various pulmonary processes.

ETIOLOGY.--Predisposing and Exciting Causes.--Syphilis of the lungs is a rare disease as compared with the forms of specific laryngitis, but even here Leman asserts that there is an early simple catarrh of the larynx indistinguishable from the specific catarrhs. Whistler, in recording his observations upon 88 cases of the lesions found in syphilis of the larynx, observes that catarrhal congestions in early laryngeal syphilis simulate the same lesions from ordinary causes. Schnitzler lays particular stress on the association of pulmonary syphilis with affections of the larynx and a specific bronchitis which may occur in the first two months after inoculation. Many other writers on this subject assert that laryngeal and bronchial catarrh attend the period of early skin eruptions, disappearing in consequence of an antisyphilitic treatment.

The rarity of pulmonary syphilis has been further attested by the observations of Greenfield, who states that out of 22 cases of visceral syphilis, only 1 occurred in the lung and 4 in the larynx and trachea: in these cases, while the dura mater and cerebral vessels were extensively diseased, no trace of skin affection could be found. Goodhart has collected from the post-mortem records in Guy's Hospital during twenty-two years 189 cases of visceral syphilis, but in only 38 of these chronic lung disease occurred. Phthisis associated with syphilis is usually a late secondary or tertiary process, which appears from two to five years after the infection; in rare cases ten--even twenty--years have been said to elapse before the supervention of pulmonary trouble. Cases of phthisis associated with syphilis have, however, been described as occurring within the first twelve months after infection. Further investigation may establish these cases of early pulmonary syphilis as attributable to violent systemic infection, or their etiology may be involved in the deterioration of the general health which sometimes occurs. Moreover, one {448} must remember that simple phthisis may more readily be developed in the scrofulous syphilitic, owing to the predisposition of such persons to catarrhal forms of inflammation. In the progress of syphilis there is also a tendency to catarrhal processes through anæmia and damaged general health, which may predispose certain cases to an ordinary type of phthisis. The origin of the new formation in both tubercular and syphilitic phthisis is similar--viz. the arterial, lymphatic, and the peribronchial sheaths, spreading thence to the interlobular connective tissues. It is therefore not surprising that it has been difficult to differentiate the tubercular from the specific forms of phthisis, and Goodhart asserts that there is no histological difference between syphilitic and tubercular phthisis, except that the former is more vascular.

We may assume that true pulmonary tuberculosis may be associated with syphilis, but preserves its own pathological characters; that, although we are ignorant of the exact differential histological changes, there is sufficient evidence to show that there is a distinct association between syphilis and pulmonary disease; and that syphilitic phthisis is commonly interstitial. Whether the relation be one of cause and effect, or whether the process is simply a modification of ordinary tubercular phthisis, it is impossible at present to determine. The final adjustment of the theories concerning the specific etiology of tubercular phthisis may throw further light upon the etiology of syphilitic phthisis. That gummata may be found in the lungs is a well-established fact, and by some authorities is not considered rare.

The discussion of the etiology has already indicated the relation of the predisposing and exciting causes to pulmonary processes in connection with syphilis. In certain cases of syphilis the antecedent of pulmonary changes is a laryngeal or bronchial catarrh. The relation which an active virus in the blood sustains to the process is still subject to debate. Hutchinson writes as follows: "If the infected blood were the cause of the local phenomena, it is almost certain that such phenomena will be symmetrical, because the blood is equally supplied to both sides; such is the case during the secondary stage. If, however, the symptoms result from tissue-conditions, and the blood is at the time of the outbreak free, then there is a considerable probability that local influences may take a large share in evoking them, and they will be asymmetrical--evoked by some local cause."

The existence of gummata, then, does not necessarily show that there is any active virus in the blood, because their formation is sometimes symmetrical, sometimes asymmetrical.

PATHOLOGY AND CLASSIFICATION.--The lesions of pulmonary syphilis may be divided into four classes: _(a)_ early phthisis, associated with principal interlobular proliferation; _(b)_ advanced syphilis, in which gummatous or allied formation exists; _(c)_ simple phthisis, developing in consequence of impaired general health induced by syphilis; _(d)_ inherited or congenital syphilis, occurring in infants.

_(a)_ The pathological process in the majority of cases in the adult is interstitial new formation, very often evoked by antecedent catarrhal inflammation. At first small spindle-shaped and round cells appear and develop into connective tissue, among the fibres of which blood-vessels are freely produced; the septa of the alveoli are thickened and the alveoli themselves compressed. In any morbid process in the lungs, such as tubercle, sarcoma, or cancer, the alveoli act as the inter-fascicular spaces of the connective tissue. In the same manner in syphilis the alveoli of the lungs are always in the later stages, and sometimes primarily, more or less filled with small cells, which, surrounded by the newly-formed connective-tissue fibrous framework, gives the appearance of some of the forms of simple phthisis. The smaller bronchi become narrowed, and perhaps occluded, by the pressure of the new growth which develops along their lumen. Occlusion of the bronchi may also be caused {449} by enlargement of the bronchial glands, which is one of the incidents of the syphilitic pulmonary process.

If we endeavor to nucleate the peculiar impress attributed to early syphilitic pulmonary processes, we find much that is vague. The vascularity and advanced grade of organization of the new growth are considered by Greenfield and Goodhart to be characteristic when compared with tubercular consumption, in which the original growth is bloodless and the tendency is to retrograde metamorphosis. Green and Virchow suggest that the origin of syphilitic diseases of the lungs is distinctive in this respect, that while in the ordinary forms of phthisis the fibroid is secondary or coequal in its development with changes in the alveoli and alveolar wall, in syphilis there are primarily interstitial changes. In chronic bronchitis the fibroid thickening proceeds from the bronchi. Wagner, however, maintains that implication of the alveolar wall is as common in syphilis as in ordinary phthisis.

In the general pathology of syphilis the change in the intima of the blood-vessels is characteristic: this has not yet been demonstrated in the lung, but merely the general thickening of the external coat of the vessels. When entire vesicular consolidation and breaking down occurs, the process is similar to ordinary phthisis, and indistinguishable from it.

_(b)_ In the gummatous stage the same formation of cellular and connective tissue is found as in the diffused form, with which gummata are often associated. Gummata may originate anywhere in the intervesicular tissue, usually near the visceral pleura. Sometimes they are formed near the roots of the lungs, intimately connected with the blood-vessels and bronchial sheaths. They may also be formed in the deeper layers of the costal pleura or upon the periosteum of the ribs. Owing to the peculiar anatomical formation of gummata, their subsequent history is one of combined caseous and fatty degeneration. These centres of softening may communicate with a bronchus, more or less rapid evacuation of the mass may occur, and a cavity be formed which often enlarges as the gummata break down. Contraction may ensue, leaving a small fibrous scar with cheesy cretaceous deposit, or the gummata may point externally, with or without the appearance of inflammation in the adjacent tissues, or they may remain stationary for an indefinite period. In some cases the pulmonary new formation may be a combined interstitial, gummatous, and catarrhal process; but, as a rule, the fibroid process of syphilis in the earlier stages is not accompanied by the filling of the alveoli with catarrhal cells. Gummata developed in or near the pleural sac may increase in size, and by compressing the lung simulate pleural effusions.

_(c)_ The morbid anatomy of cases in which simple phthisis develops in consequence of the vulnerability of the pulmonary tissues to the exciting causes of bronchial inflammation requires no special consideration.

_(d)_ Interstitial inflammation, gummata, and enlargement of the bronchial glands have been found in the syphilitic foetus and in very young children. It is also claimed that syphilitic disease of the lung may be one of the forms of tertiary disease which develop in children between the second dentition and maturity. Virchow and Lebert have described pulmonary gummata in children suffering from inherited syphilis. Depaul gives the cases of two children with pemphigus who had soft puriform nodules or collections scattered through the lungs. In the infant lung the highly cellular character and ready reversion to the embryonic type of structure would naturally lead to exuberant growth and rapid diffusion of the morbid process, which could not occur in the more fibrous, less cellular lung of the adult. Hence the slower growth in the latter establishes the more fibrous and limited extent of disease: in other respects the origin and distribution of the growth are identical in both cases. In the infant enlargement of the bronchial glands {450} and bronchitis leading to broncho-pneumonia, or an unusual proliferation of epithelium in the alveoli, is more frequent than in the adult.

MORBID ANATOMY.--In the earlier stages of pulmonary syphilis the macroscopic appearance of the lung is firmer at the seat of deposit than elsewhere. It is also heavier and has a smoother surface. The infiltrated parts are grayish-red or grayish-yellow, smooth, and homogeneous. Sometimes the appearance resembles pale-whitish patches invading districts of the lung. The hyperplastic material becomes converted into a tough, contracting, fibrous tissue, which radiates through the lung, drawing together the bronchial tubes and flattening them, possibly even to obliteration. The entire lung may be involved, but the changes most frequently proceed from the hilus of the organ into the interior, following the track of the bronchial radicles and the bronchial and pulmonary arteries. The lesions frequently develop near the visceral pleura, where there is more connective tissue. This accounts for the depressed puckered scars which are found on the pleural surface.

The macroscopic appearances in specific pulmonary disease differ, according to Goodhart, "both from a chronic pneumonia and from that solidification ensuing after contraction of the lung from old pleurisy, in that it is less evenly distributed, and generally less widely spread over the lobe, than they. It is nodular, rather diffused, and more symmetrical than unilateral. From miners' phthisis the appearance differs in the absence of the extreme dilatation of the bronchial tubes and more solidity from greater growth. The tissues involved are more tough and less granular than red or gray hepatization." It is possible to differentiate other forms of fibroid phthisis by noting, in addition to the above points, the presence of the syphilitic process in other viscera, and by comparing the clinical records with the post-mortem examination.

Syphilitic lesions may be found in any part of one or both lungs, but their localization at definite points in the lungs, leaving the balance free even when the lesion has proceeded to formation of cavities, may be characteristic. There is, however, a wide division of professional opinion upon the subject of the localization of the process in syphilitic pulmonary disease; some claiming the middle lobe, some a symmetrical lesion at the apices, others lesions at a definite point elsewhere than at the apices. If the pulmonary lesions are introduced by an attack of pleurisy, the process in the lungs is usually located at one or both bases. Some, however, locate the disease at the base, without mentioning an antecedent pleurisy.

Gummata are more frequently situated in the middle or lower lobes of one or both lungs, and are defined by a boundary layer of fibrous tissue. Fibroid development may ensure their adhesion to the visceral and costal pleura. They are gray or yellowish-gray, hard, well-defined nodules, of varying size and number, occurring as single large masses surrounded by normal or compressed lung. In the centre is found a diffluent material, not unlike the centre of a scirrhous nodule, similarly enclosed in a limiting fibrous investment from an inch to many inches thick. In the condition of the neighboring pulmonary substance a difference may be observed between gummatous and tuberculous nodules: the latter occur in more numerous masses, usually small, and the entire lung is more or less diseased; while in syphilis extended districts of non-affected lung occur in the neighborhood of gummata. Whenever gummatous lesions in the lungs exist a history of pustular eruptions, laryngitis, arterial lesions--in fine, some indication of general systemic syphilitic poisoning--can always be found. Fournier thinks there are five anatomical points of distinction between syphilitic gummata and tubercle: "1. Tubercle involves the upper part of both lungs; gummata one lung, and may be limited to a portion. 2. Gummata are few as a rule, solitary; tubercles sooner or later become confluent. 3. Gummata are larger than tubercles, never {451} miliary in form. 4. Gummata are always yellow or white, never transparent like miliary tubercle. 5. Until softening takes place gummata are of more equal consistence than tubercles, and if they soften do not break down, wholly owing to the capsule. Histologically, there is no difference in structure." Gummatous formations may be found on the pericardium and heart and in the thoracic and abdominal walls. Clinically, the most important pathological feature is that large districts of healthy lung are interposed between the affected districts; this is not so in ordinary phthisis.