Chapter XXXIV: The System of Dykes in the Tertiary Volcanic Series (2)

At least two broad types of microscopic structure may be recognized among the basic and intermediate dykes. (1) Holocrystalline, or with only a trifling proportion of interstitial matter. This type includes the dolerites and basalts, as well as rocks which German petrographers would class as diabases or diabase-porphyrites. The rocks are very generally characterized by ophitic structure, where the lath-shaped felspars penetrate the augite, and are therefore of an earlier consolidation. In such cases there is a general absence of any true interstitial matter. The rocks of this type are often rich in olivine, and appear to be on the whole considerably more basic than those of the second group. It is observable that they increase in numbers from the centre of Scotland westwards, and throughout the region of the basalt-plateaux they form the prevailing type. (2) In this type there is a marked proportion of interstitial substance, which is inserted in wedge-shaped portions among the crystallised constituents ("intersertal structure" of Rosenbusch). The ophitic structure appears to be absent, and olivine is either extremely rare or does not occur at all. The rocks of this group are obviously less basic than those of the other. They form the large dykes that rise so conspicuously through the South of Scotland and North of England, and their general characters are well described by Mr. Teall in the paper already cited. In some instances they enclose abundant porphyritic felspars of earlier consolidation, and then present most of the characters of andesites. Professor Rosenbusch has extended the name of "Tholeiites" to rocks of this group in the North of England.[171] The vitreous condition is found in both types, but is perhaps more frequent in the second. The glass of the basalts, however, even in thin slices, is characteristically opaque from its crowded inclusions; while that of the andesitic forms, though black in hand specimens, appears perfectly transparent and sometimes even colourless in thin slices.

[Footnote 171: _Mikroskopische Physiographie_, 3rd edit. 1071 _et seq._]

(3) _Chemical Characters._--The only one of these to which reference will be made here is the varying proportion of silica. While the dykes as a whole are either intermediate or basic, some of them contain so high a percentage of silica as to link them with the acid rocks. The average proportions of this ingredient range from less than 50 to nearly 60 per cent. The rocks with the lower percentage of acid are richer in the heavy bases, and have a specific gravity which sometimes rises above 3·0. They include the true dolerites and basalts. Those, on the other hand, with the higher ratio of silica, are poorer in the heavy bases, and have a specific gravity from 2·76 to 2·96. They comprise the tholeiites, andesites and other more coarsely crystalline rocks of the great eastern and south-eastern dykes.[172]

[Footnote 172: For analyses of dykes, see Sir I. L. Bell, _Proc. Roy. Soc._ xxiii. p. 546; Mr. J. S. Grant Wilson, _Proc. Roy. Phys. Soc. Edin._ v. p. 253; Mr. Teall, _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. p. 209; Professors Judd and Cole, _Quart. Jour. Geol. Soc._ xxxix. p. 444.]

Not only do the dykes differ considerably from each other in their relative proportions of silica, but even the same dyke may sometimes be found to present a similar diversity in different parts of its mass. It has long been a familiar fact that the glassy parts of such rocks are more acid than the surrounding crystalline portions. The original magma may be regarded as a natural glass or fused silicate, in which all the elements of the rock were dissolved, and which necessarily became more acid as the various basic minerals crystallised out of it.[173] In the Eskdale dyke the silica percentage of this glassy portion is 58·67, that of the little kernels of black glass dispersed through the rock as much as 65·49.[174] In the Dunoon dyke observed by Mr. Clough the siliceous finer-grained veins contain no less than 68·05 per cent of silica, while the mass of the dyke itself shows on analysis only 47·36 per cent.[175] Similar red strings have been noticed by the same careful observer in an east and west dyke near Lochgoilhead. From Mr. Teall's examination a large part of the felspar in these veins is probably orthoclase. It forms a much larger percentage of the entire rock than the felspar does in normal dolerites.

[Footnote 173: On this subject see a paper by Dr. A. Lagorio, "Über die Natur der Glasbasis sowie der Krystallisationsvorgänge im eruptiven Magma," Tschermak's _Mineralog. Mittheil._ viii. (1887), p. 421.]

[Footnote 174: Mr. J. S. Grant Wilson, _Proc. Roy. Soc. Phys. Edin._ v. (1880) p. 253.]

[Footnote 175: Unpublished analyses made by the late Professor Dittmar of Glasgow, and communicated to me by Mr. Clough.]

2. Trachyte Dykes.--In the Cowal District of Argyleshire, and in the south of Skye, Mr. Clough has encountered a limited number of dykes of trachyte. On a hasty inspection these are not always readily distinguished from the basalt-dykes with which they agree in general external aspect and in direction. Where their relation to these dykes, however, can be determined they are found to traverse them, and thus to be on the whole later, though one case has been observed where a trachytic dyke is in turn traversed by one of the basic series. Mr. Clough has supplied me with the following notes of his observations regarding the trachytic dykes. They are all characterized by the possession of spherulitic structures near their margins. These features, easily perceptible to the naked eye, afford the readiest means of distinguishing the dykes of this group. So abundant are the spherulites that they not infrequently impinge on each other in long parallel rows forming rod-like aggregates. Thus in a dyke near Craigendavie, at the head of Loch Striven, numerous planes about a quarter of an inch apart, and composed of such close-set rods, may be observed running parallel to the marginal wall for a distance of several inches from the edge. Most of these planes show on their surfaces that the rods are always parallel to each other, but may run in different directions in the different layers, being sometimes horizontal, sometimes vertical, or at any angle between. On examination, each rod is found to be made up of polygonal bodies, the angles of which are quite sharp, but with their sides often slightly curved, as if they had assumed their forms from the mutual pressure of original spherical bulbs. Further scrutiny shows that the polygonal bodies often exhibit an internal radiate structure.

In the central parts of the dyke the spherulitic arrangement is not traceable. About a foot from the margin it begins to be recognizable. At a distance of three or four inches the spherulites are about the size of peas, and gradually diminish towards the edge until they can no longer be seen.

Another characteristic of the trachyte dykes has been found by Mr. Clough to be a useful guide in discriminating them from the basalt-group. While the amygdales in the latter are generally rudely spherical, those in the trachytes are commonly elongated in the direction of the length of the dyke, and are frequently three quarters of an inch, sometimes even an inch and a half, in length, though less than a quarter of an inch in breadth.

A good example of these trachytic dykes, which occurs at Dunans, about the head of Glendaruel, has been examined microscopically and chemically. The central better crystallised portion was found by Mr. Teall to be composed mainly of small lath-shaped crystals of orthoclase, together with scales of brown biotite, a few prismatic crystals of pale somewhat altered pyroxene and scattered granules of magnetite. The chemical analysis of this rock by Mr. J. H. Player gave the following composition:--

Silica 56·4
Alumina 19·0
Ferric oxide 3·5
Ferrous oxide 4·8
Lime 2·6
Magnesia 1·5
Soda 4·5
Potash 5·0
Loss on ignition 2·6
----
99·9
====

4. HADE

In the majority of cases, especially among the great single dykes, the intrusive rock has assumed a position nearly or quite vertical. But occasionally, where one of these solitary examples crosses a deep valley, a slight hade is perceptible by the deviation of the line of the dyke from its normal course. Sedgwick long ago noticed that the Cleveland dyke has, in places, an inclination of at least 80° to its N.E. side.[176] In the coal-workings, also, a trifling deviation from the vertical is sometimes perceptible, especially where a dyke has found its way along a previously existing line of fault, as in several examples in Stirlingshire. But in those districts where the dykes are gregarious, departures from the vertical position are not infrequent, more particularly near the great basalt-plateaux. It was noticed by Necker, that even in such a dyke-filled region as Arran, almost all of the dykes are vertical, though sometimes deviating from that position to the extent of 20°.[177] Berger found that the angle of deviation among those of the north of Ireland ranges from 9° to 20°, with a mean of 13°.[178] The most oblique examples are probably those which occur in the basalt-plateaux of the Inner Hebrides, where the same dyke in some parts of its course runs horizontally between two beds, across which it also descends vertically (see Figs. 251, 252, 374). But with these minor exceptions, the verticality of the great system of dykes, pointing to the perpendicular fissure-walls between which the molten rock ascended, is one of the most notable features in their geological structure. In the Strath district of Skye Mr. Harker has noticed that while the earlier dykes have sometimes a hade of 45°, those younger than the granophyre are generally vertical or nearly so. In the Blath Bheinn group of hills, however, as already alluded to, he has observed that it is the youngest dykes which are inclined in a north-westerly direction, with a hade of as much as 40° from the horizon.

[Footnote 176: _Cambridge Phil. Trans._ ii. p. 28.]

[Footnote 177: _Trans. Roy. Soc. Edin._ xiv. p. 677.]

[Footnote 178: _Trans. Geol. Soc._ iii. p. 227.]

5. BREADTH

An obvious characteristic of most dykes is the apparent uniformity of their breadth. Many of them, as exposed along shore-sections, vary as little in dimensions as well-built walls of masonry do. Departures from such uniformity may often indeed be noted, whether a dyke is followed laterally or vertically. The largest amount of variation is, of course, to be found among the dykes of the gregarious type, the thinner examples of which may diminish to a width of only one inch or less, while their average breadth is much smaller than in the case of the great solitary dykes. In the district of Strathaird, in Skye, Macculloch estimated that the remarkably abundant dykes there developed vary from 5 to 20 feet in breadth, but with an average breadth of not more than 10 feet.[179] In the isle of Arran, according to Necker's careful measurements, most of the dykes range from 2 or 3 to 10 or 15 feet, but some diminish to a few inches, while others reach a width of 20, 30, or even 50 feet.[180] In the North of Ireland, Berger observed that the average breadth of thirty-eight dykes traversing primitive rocks (schist, granites, etc.) was 9 feet; and of twenty-four in Secondary rocks, 24 feet.[181]

[Footnote 179: _Trans. Geol. Soc._ iii. p. 80.]

[Footnote 180: _Trans. Roy. Soc. Edin._ xiv. p. 690 et seq.]

[Footnote 181: _Trans. Geol. Soc._ iii. p. 226. He believed that dykes in Secondary rocks reach a much greater thickness than in other formations. My own observations do not confirm this generalisation.]

But when we pass to the great solitary dykes, that run so far and so continuously across the country, we encounter much thicker masses of igneous rock. Most of the measurements of these dykes have been made at the surface, and the variations noted in their breadth occur along their horizontal extension. The Cleveland dyke, which is the longest in Britain, varies from 15 feet to more than 100 feet, with perhaps an average width of between 70 and 90 feet.[182] Some of the great dykes that cross Scotland are of larger dimensions. Most of them, however, like that of Cleveland, are liable to considerable variations in breadth when followed along their length. The dyke which runs from the eastern coast across the Cheviot Hills and Teviotdale to the head of the Ale Water, is in some places only 10 feet broad, but at its widest parts is probably about 100 feet. The Eskdale and Moffat dyke is in parts of its course 180 feet wide, but elsewhere it diminishes to not more than 40 feet. These variations are repeated at irregular intervals, so that the dyke alternately widens and contracts as its course is traced across the hills. Some of the dykes further to the north and west attain yet more gigantic proportions. That which crosses Cantyre opposite Ardlamont Point has been measured by Mr. J. B. Hill, of the Geological Survey, who finds it to be from 150 to 180 feet broad on the shore of Loch Fyne, and to swell out beyond the west side of Loch Tarbert to a breadth of 240 to 270 feet. A dyke near Strathmiglo, in Fife, is about 400 feet wide. The broadest dyke known to me is one which I traced near Beith, in Ayrshire, traversing the Carboniferous Limestone. Its maximum width is 640 feet.

[Footnote 182: At Cockfield, where it has long been quarried, it varies from 15 to 66 feet; at Armathwatie, in the vale of the Eden, it is about 54 feet (Mr. Teall, _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. p. 211).]

Unfortunately, it is much less easy to get evidence of the width of dykes at different levels in their vertical extension. Yet this is obviously an important point in the theoretical discussion of their origin. Two means are available of obtaining information on the subject--(_a_) from mining operations, and (_b_) from observations at precipices and between hill-crests and valley-bottoms.

(_a_) In the Central Scottish coal-field and in that of Ayrshire, some large dykes have been cut through at depths of two or three hundred feet beneath the surface. But there does not appear to be any well-ascertained variation between their width so far below ground and at the surface. In not a few cases, indeed, dykes are met with in the lower workings of the coal-pits which do not reach the surface or even the workings in the higher coals. Such upward terminations of dykes will be afterwards considered, and it will be shown that towards its upper limit a dyke may rapidly diminish in width.

(_b_) More definite information, and often from a wider vertical range, is to be gathered on coast-cliffs and in hilly districts, where the same dyke can be followed through a vertical range of many hundred feet. But so far as my own observations go, no general rule can be established that dykes sensibly vary in width as they are traced upward. Every one who has visited the basalt-precipices of Antrim or the Inner Hebrides, where dykes are so numerous, will remember how uniform is their breadth as they run like ribbons up the faces of the escarpments.[183] Now and then one of them may be observed to die out, but in such cases (which are far from common) the normal width is usually maintained up to within a few feet of the termination.

[Footnote 183: This point did not escape the attention of that excellent observer, Berger, in his examination of the dykes in the North of Ireland. We find him expressing himself thus:--"The depth to which the dykes descend is unknown; and after having observed the sections of a great many along the coast in cliffs from 50 to 400 feet in height, I have not been able to ascertain (except in one or two cases) that their sides converge or have a wedgeform tendency" (_Trans. Geol. Soc._ iii. p. 227).]

All over the southern half of Scotland, where the dykes run along the crests of the hills and also cross the valleys, a difference of level amounting to several hundred feet may often be obtained between adjacent parts of the same dyke. But the breadth of igneous rock is not perceptibly greater in the valleys than on the ridges. The depth of boulder clay and other superficial deposits on the valley bottoms, however, too frequently conceals the dykes at their lowest levels. Perhaps the best sections in the country for the study of this interesting part of dyke-structure are to be found among the higher hills of the Inner Hebrides, such as the quartzites of Jura and the granophyres and gabbros of Skye. On these bare rocky declivities, numerous dykes may be followed from almost the sea-level up to the rugged and splintered crests, a vertical distance of between 2000 and 3000 feet. The dykes are certainly not as a rule sensibly less in width on the hill-tops than in the glens. So far, therefore, as I have been able to gather the evidence, there does not appear to me to be, as a general rule, any appreciable variation in the width of dykes for at least 2000 or 3000 feet of their descent. The fissures which they filled must obviously have had nearly parallel walls for a long way down.

6. INTERRUPTIONS OF LATERAL CONTINUITY

In tracing the great solitary dykes across the country, the geologist is often surprised to meet with gaps, varying in extent from a few hundred feet to several miles, in which no trace whatever of the igneous rock can be detected at the surface. This disappearance is not always explicable by the depth of the cover of superficial accumulations; for it may be observed over ground where the naked rocks come almost everywhere to the surface, and where, therefore, if the conspicuous material of the dykes existed, it could not fail to be found. No dyke supplies better illustrations of this discontinuity than that of Cleveland. Traced north-westward across the Carboniferous tracts that lie between the mouth of the Tees and the Yale of the Eden, this dyke disappears sometimes for a distance of six or eight miles. In the mining ground round the head of the South Tyne the rocks are bare, so that the absence of the dyke among them can only be accounted for by its not reaching the surface. Yet there can be no doubt that the various separated exposures, which have the same distinctive lithological characters and occur on the same persistent line, are all portions of one dyke which is continuous at some depth below ground. We have thus an indication of the exceedingly irregular upward limit of the dykes, as will be more particularly discussed further on.

But there are also instances where the continuity is interrupted and then resumed on a different line. One of the best illustrations of this character is supplied by the large dyke which rises through the hills about a mile south of Linlithgow and runs westward across the coal-field. At Blackbraes it ends off in a point, and is not found again to the westward in any of the coal-workings. But little more than a quarter of a mile to the south a precisely similar dyke begins, and strikes westward parallel to the line of the first one. The two separated strips of igneous rock overlap each other for about three-quarters of a mile. But that they are merely interrupted portions of what is really a single dyke can hardly be questioned. A second example is furnished by another of the great dykes of the same district, which after running for about twelve miles in a nearly east and west direction suddenly stops at Chryston, and begins again in the same direction, but on a line about a third of a mile further north. Such examples serve to mark out irregularities in the great fissures up which the materials of the dykes rose.

7. LENGTH

In those districts where the small and crowded dykes of the gregarious type are developed, one cannot usually trace them for more than a short distance. The longest examples known to me are those which have been mapped with much patience and skill by Mr. Clough in Eastern Argyleshire. Some of them he has been able to track over hill and valley for four or five miles, though the great majority are much shorter. In Arran and in the Inner Hebrides, it is seldom possible to follow what we can be sure is the same dyke for more than a few hundred yards. This difficulty arises partly, no doubt, from the frequent spread of peat or other superficial accumulation which conceals the rocks, and partly also from the great number of dykes and the want of sufficiently distinct lithological characters for the identification of any particular one. But making every allowance for these obstacles, we are compelled, I think, to regard the gregarious dykes as essentially short as well as relatively irregular.

In striking contrast to these, come the great solitary dykes. In estimating their length, as I have already remarked, we must bear in mind the fact that they occasionally undergo interruptions of continuity owing to the local failure of the igneous material to rise to the level of what is now the surface of the ground. A narrow wall-like mass of andesite or dolerite, which sinks beneath the surface for a few hundred yards, or for several miles, and reappears on the same line with the same petrographical characters, while there may be no similar rock for miles to right and left, can only be one dyke prolonged underneath in the same great line of fissure. But even if we restrict our measurements of length to those dykes or parts of dykes where no serious interruption of continuity takes place, we cannot fail to be astonished at the persistence of these strips of igneous rock through the most diverse kinds of geological structure. A few illustrative examples of this feature may be selected. It will be observed that the longest and broadest dykes are found furthest from the basalt-plateaux, while the shortest and narrowest are most abundant near these plateaux.

Not far from what I have taken provisionally as the northern boundary of the dyke region, two dykes occur which have been mapped from the head of Loch Goil by Arrochar across Lochs Lomond and Katrine by Ben Ledi to Glen Artney, whence they strike into the Old Red Sandstone of Strathmore, and run on to the Tay near Perth--a total distance of about 60 miles. If the dyke which continues in the same line on the other side of the estuary of the Tay beyond Newburgh, is a prolongation of one of these, then its entire length exceeds 70 miles. A few miles further south, one of a group of dykes can be followed from the heart of Dumbartonshire by Callander across the Braes of Doune to Auchterarder--a distance of 47 miles, with an average breadth of more than 100 feet. In the district between the Forth and Clyde a number of long parallel dykes can be traced for many miles across hill and plain, and through the coal-fields. One of these is continuous for 25 miles from the heart of Linlithgowshire into Lanarkshire. Still longer is the dyke which runs from the Firth of Forth at Grangemouth westward to the Clyde, opposite Greenock--a distance of about 36 miles. Coming southward, we encounter a striking series of single dykes on the uplands between the counties of Lanark and Ayr, whence they strike into the Silurian hills of the southern counties. One of these runs across the crest of the Haughshaw Hills, and can be followed for some 30 miles. But if, as is probable, it is prolonged in one of the dykes that traverse the moorlands of the north of Ayrshire and south of Renfrewshire to the Clyde, its actual length must be at least twice that distance. The great Moffat and Eskdale dyke strikes for more than 50 miles across the South of Scotland and North of England. The Hawick and Cheviot dyke runs for 26 miles in Scotland and for 32 miles in Northumberland.

But the most remarkable instance of persistence is furnished by the Cleveland dyke. From where it is first seen near the coast-cliffs of Yorkshire the strip of igneous rock can be followed, with frequent interruptions, during which for sometimes several miles no trace of it appears at the surface, across the North of England as far as Dalston Hall south of Carlisle, beyond which the ground onwards to the Solway Firth is deeply covered with superficial deposits. The total distance through which this dyke can be recognized is thus about 110 miles. But it probably goes further still. On the opposite side of the Solway, a dyke which runs in the same line, rises through the Permian strata a little to the east of the mouth of the Nith. Some miles further to the north-west, near Moniaive, Mr. J. Horne, in the progress of the Geological Survey, traced a dark compact dyke with kernels of basalt-glass near its margin, running in the same north-westerly direction. Still further on in the same line, another similar rock is found high on the flanks of the lofty hill known as Windy Standard. And lastly, in the Ayrshire coal-field, a dyke still continuing the same trend, runs for several miles, and strikes out to sea near Prestwick. It cannot, of course, be proved that these detached Scottish protrusions belong to one great dyke, or that if such a continuous dyke exists, it is a prolongation of that from Cleveland. At the same time, I am on the whole inclined to connect the various outcrops together as those of one prolonged subterranean wall of igneous rock. The distance from the last visible portion of the Cleveland dyke near Carlisle to the dyke that runs out into the Firth of Clyde near Prestwick, is about 80 miles. If we consider this extension as a part of the great North of England dyke, then the total length of this remarkable geological feature will be about 190 miles.

8. PERSISTENCE OF MINERAL CHARACTERS

Not less remarkable than their length is the preservation of their normal petrographical characters by some dykes for long distances. In this respect the Cleveland dyke may again be cited as a typical example. The megascopic and microscopic structures of the rock of this dyke distinguish it among the other eruptive rocks of the North of England. And these peculiarities it maintains throughout its course.[184] Similar though less prominent uniformity may be traced among the long solitary dykes of the South of Scotland, the chief variations in these arising from the greater or less extent to which the original glassy magma has been retained. The same dyke will at one part of its course show abundant glassy matter even to the naked eye, while at a short distance the vitreous groundmass has been devitrified, and its former presence can only be detected with the aid of the microscope. Where a dyke has caught up and absorbed abundant foreign materials its composition naturally varies considerably from point to point. Mr. Harker has observed some good examples of this variation in Skye.

[Footnote 184: See the careful examination of this dyke by Mr. Teall, _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. p. 209.]