Chapter XXIX: The Carboniferous Volcanoes of England (1)

The North of England: Dykes, The Great Whin Sill--The Derbyshire
Toadstones--The Isle of Man--East Somerset--Devonshire

1. THE NORTH OF ENGLAND

The volcanic intercalations which diversify the Lower Carboniferous formations of Southern Scotland extend but a short way across the English Border, and although, over the moors and hills of the north of Cumberland and Northumberland, the Carboniferous sandstones, limestones and shales are well exposed, they present no continuation of either the plateau or puy-eruptions which play so prominent a part in the geology of Roxburghshire and Dumfriesshire. This deficiency is all the more noticeable seeing that the Carboniferous system is exposed down to its very base, in the deep dales of the North of England. Had any truly interstratified volcanic material existed in the system there, it could hardly fail to have been detected.

But while contemporaneous volcanic rocks are absent, the northern English counties contain many intrusive masses of dolerite, diabase, andesite or other eruptive rocks, which may be found traversing all the subdivisions of the Carboniferous system. These eruptive materials have taken two forms: in some cases they rise as Dykes, in others they appear as Sills.

Dykes.--With regard to the dykes, some are probably much later than the Carboniferous period, and consequently will be more appropriately considered in Chapters xxxiv. and xxxv. The great Cleveland dyke, for example, which runs across the Carboniferous, Permian, Triassic and Jurassic formations, is probably referable to the Older Tertiary volcanic period. One dyke known as the Hett Dyke, has been plausibly claimed as possibly of Carboniferous age. It runs in a W.S.W. direction from the Magnesian Limestone escarpment at Quarrington Hill, a few miles to the east of Durham, through the great Coal-field, across the Millstone Grit and Carboniferous Limestone, disappearing near Middleton in Teesdale. Its total length is thus about 23 miles. It varies in breadth from about 6 to about 15 feet, and appears to increase in dimensions as it goes westward.[1]

[Footnote 1: Sedgwick, _Trans. Geol. Soc._ 2nd series, iii. part 1 (1826-28), p. 63; _Trans. Cambridge Phil. Soc._ ii. (1822), p. 21. Sir J. Lowthian Bell, _Proc. Roy. Soc._ xxiii. (1875), p. 543.]

The age of this dyke cannot at present be satisfactorily fixed. It must be later than the Coal-measures through which it rises. Sedgwick long ago pointed out that though it reaches the escarpment of the Magnesian Limestone, it does not cut it; yet it is found in coal-mining to traverse the Coal-measures underlying the Limestone. He was accordingly inclined to believe it to be of older date than the Magnesian Limestone. At its western extremity it approaches close to the Great Whin Sill of Teesdale, though no absolute connection between the two has been established. Mr. Teall, however, has called attention to the similarity between the microscopic structure of the rock forming the Hett Dyke and that of the mass of the Whin Sill, and he is strongly inclined to regard them as belonging to the same period of intrusion.[2]

[Footnote 2: _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. (1884), p. 230.]

It is especially worthy of remark that in the course of its nearly rectilinear course across the Durham Coal-field, the Hett Dyke, where it crosses the Wear, is flanked on the north at a distance of a little more than two miles by a second parallel dyke of nearly identical composition. Between the two dykes, during mining operations, a sill about 20 feet thick has been met with, lying between two well-known coal-seams at a depth of about 60 fathoms from the surface, and extending over an area of at least 15 acres.[3] Microscopic examination of this sill by Mr. Teall proved that the rock presents the closest resemblance to that of the Hett Dyke.[4] In this case, it may be regarded as probable that the two dykes and the intermediate sill form one related series of intrusions, and the conjecture that the Hett Dyke may be connected with the Whin Sill thus receives corroboration. The age of the Whin Sill itself will be discussed a few pages further on.

[Footnote 3: Sir Lowthian Bell, _Proc. Roy. Soc._ xxiii. (1875), p. 544.]

[Footnote 4: _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. (1884), p. 230.]

Of the other dykes which may possibly be coeval with the Hett Dyke we may specially note those which follow the same W.S.W. trend, for that strike differs from the general W.N.W. direction of most of the dykes. Two conspicuous examples of the south-westerly trend may be seen, one near Morpeth, the other north of Bellingham. The former dyke, as regards microscopic structure, is more nearly related to the majority of the series in the North of England. But that north of Bellingham (High Green) presents affinities both in structure and composition with the Hett Dyke,[5] and may perhaps belong to the same period of intrusion.

[Footnote 5: Mr. Teall, _op. cit._ p. 244. _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xxxix. (1884), p. 656, and _Proc. Geol. Assoc._ (1886). See also Prof. Lebour, _Geology of Northumberland and Durham_, chap. xi.]

The Great Whin Sill.--The geologist who, after making himself acquainted with the abundant sills among the Carboniferous rocks in the centre of Scotland, finds his way into Northumberland, meets there with geological features that have become familiar to him further north. The sea-cliffs of Bamborough and Dunstanborough, the rocky islets of Farne, the long lines of brown crag and green slope that strike inland through the Kyloe Hills and wind across the cultivated lowlands and the moorlands beyond, remind him at every turn of the scenery in the basin of the Forth. But not until he has traced these ridges for many miles southwards and found their component rocks to form there an almost continuous sheet does he realize that nothing of the kind among the Scottish Carboniferous rocks can be compared for extent to this display in the North of England.[6]

[Footnote 6: The Whin Sill has been the subject of much discussion, and a good deal of geological literature has been devoted to its consideration. The writings of Trevelyan, Sedgwick, W. Hutton, Phillips and Tate are especially deserving of recognition. The intrusive character of the Sill, maintained by some of these writers, was finally established by the mapping of the Geological Survey, and was discussed and illustrated by Messrs. W. Topley and G. A. Lebour in a paper in the 33rd volume of the _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ (1877), in which references to the earlier observers will be found. See also Prof. Lebour's _Outlines of the Geology of Northumberland_, 2nd edit. (1886), p. 92. The petrography of the Whin Sill is fully treated by Mr. Teall in _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. (1884), p. 640, where a bibliography of the subject is also given.]

From the furthest skerries of the Farne Islands southwards to Burton Fell on the great Pennine escarpment, a distance in a straight line of about 80 miles, this intrusive sheet may be traced in the Carboniferous Limestone series (Map I.). There are intervals where its continuity cannot be actually followed at the surface, but that it really runs unbroken from one end to the other underground cannot be doubted by any one who has examined the region. This singular feature in the geology and scenery of the North of England is known locally as the Great Whin Sill.[7] From the rocky islets and castle-crowned crags of the coast-line it maintains its characteristic topography, structure and composition throughout its long course in the interior. So regularly parallel with the sedimentary strata does it appear to lie, that it was formerly regarded by many observers as a true lava-sheet, poured out upon the sea-floor over which the limestones and shales were laid down. But its really intrusive character has now been clearly demonstrated. Not a vestige of any tuff has been detected associated with it, nor does it ever present the usual characters of a true lava-stream.[8] Its internal structure and the wonderful uniformity in its character mark it out as a typical intrusive sheet.

[Footnote 7: "Whin" is a common term in Scotland and the North of England for any hard kind of stone, especially such as can be used for making and mending roads. "Sill" denotes a flat course or bed of stone, and was evidently applied to this intrusive sheet from its persistent flat-bedded position and its prominence among the other gently inclined strata among which it lies. It is from this example in the North of England that the word "sill" has passed into geological literature.]

[Footnote 8: On the coast at Bamborough and the Harkess Rocks the usual petrographical characters of the Whin Sill are exchanged for those of fine-grained amygdaloidal diabases arranged in distinct sheets, which in their upper parts are highly vesicular and show ropy surfaces--peculiarities suggestive of true lava-streams. But according to Professor Lebour the rocks are intrusive into limestone and shale (_Geology of Northumberland and Durham_, p. 98). Mr. Teall has expressed the suspicion that these rocks must have consolidated under conditions somewhat different from those which characterized the normal Whin Sill (_Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. p. 643). They seem to be the only parts of the sill which present features that might possibly indicate superficial outflow.]

Among the manifestations of the subterranean intrusion of igneous rocks in the British Isles the Great Whin Sill, next after the Dalradian sills of Scotland, is the most extensive. Its striking continuity for so great a distance, and the absence around it of any other trace of igneous action, save a few dykes, place it in marked contrast to the ordinary type of Carboniferous sills. The occasional gaps on its line of outcrop in the northern part of its course do not really affect our impression of the persistence of the sheet. They not improbably indicate merely that in its protrusion it had a wavy irregular limit, which in the progress of denudation has occasionally been not yet reached. For mile after mile the sill has been mapped by the Geological Survey in lines of crag across the moorlands, and as a conspicuous band among the limestones and shales that form the steep front of the Pennine escarpment, where it has long been known in the fine sections exposed among the gullies by which that noble rock-face has been furrowed.

1. Silurian strata; 2. Carboniferous Limestone series; 3. The Great Whin Sill, which gradually rises to higher stratigraphical position as it goes westward; 4. Millstone Grit.]

Along its main outcrop, the sill dips gently eastwards below the portion of the Carboniferous Limestone series which overlies it. But so slight are the inclinations, so gentle the undulations of the rocks in this part of the country, that far to the east of that outcrop the sill has been laid bare by the streams which in the larger dales have cut their way through the overlying cake of Carboniferous strata down to the Silurian platform on which they rest (Fig. 176). Among these inland revelations of the eastward continuation of the sill under Carboniferous Limestone strata, the most striking and best known are those which have been made by the River Tees, and of which the famous waterfalls of the High Force and Cauldron Snout are the most picturesque features. The distance of the remotest of these denuded outcrops or "inliers" from the main escarpment is not less than 20 miles.

It is not possible to form an accurate estimate of the total underground area of the Whin Sill. In the southern half of the district, south of the line of the Roman Wall, where, the inclination of the strata being generally low, the same stratigraphical horizons are exposed by denudation far to the east of the main outcrops of the rocks, we know that the sill must have a subterranean extent of more than 400 square miles. Yet this is probably only a small part of the total area over which the molten material was injected. In the northern part of the district, the Carboniferous Limestone series is not exposed over so broad a stretch of country, and denudation has not there revealed the eastward extension of the sill. But there is no reason to suppose the sheet to be less continuous and massive there. We must remember also that the present escarpment has been produced by denudation, and that the intrusive sheet must have once extended westwards beyond its present limits at the surface. If, therefore, we were to state broadly that the Great Whin Sill has been intruded into the Carboniferous Limestone series over an area of 1000 square miles we should probably be still below the truth.

The rock composing this vast intrusive sheet is a dolerite or diabase, which maintains throughout its wide extent a remarkable uniformity of petrographical characters. In this and other respects it illustrates the typical features of sills. Thus it is coarsest in texture where it is thickest, and somewhat finer in grain towards its upper and lower surfaces than in the centre. Among the coarser varieties the component crystals of augite are not infrequently an inch in length and occur in irregular patches.[9] Occasional amygdaloidal portions are observable, but these are not more marked than those to be found in the "whin-dykes" of the same region.[10] The amygdaloidal and vesicular fine-grained rocks of the Bamborough district may possibly be quite distinct from the main body of the Whin Sill.

[Footnote 9: Sedgwick, _Cambridge Phil. Trans._ ii. p. 166. Mr. Teall, _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xl. p. 643.]

[Footnote 10: Messrs. Topley and Lebour, _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xxxiii. p. 418.]

Under the microscope the rock is seen to consist essentially of the usual minerals--plagioclase, augite and titaniferous magnetic iron-ore. An ophitic intergrowth of the augite and felspar is observable, likewise a certain quantity of micropegmatite which plays the part of groundmass between the interstices of the lath-shaped felspars. Full details of the characteristics of the component minerals and their arrangement are given by Mr. Teall in the paper already cited.

The main body of the sill is a sheet which sometimes diminishes to less than 20 feet in thickness and sometimes expands to 150 feet, but averages from 80 to 100 feet. It occasionally divides, as near Great Bavington, where it appears at the surface in two distinct beds separated by an intervening group of limestones and shales. Occasionally, as at Elf's Hill Quarry, it gives out branches which send strings into the adjacent limestone.[11]

[Footnote 11: Messrs. Topley and Lebour, _op. cit._ p. 413.]

Although in most natural sections it seems to lie quite parallel with the strata above and below, yet a number of examples of its actual intrusion have been observed. When traced across the country, it is found not to remain on a definite horizon, but to pass transgressively across considerable thicknesses of strata. Its variations in this respect are well shown in the accompanying table of comparative sections constructed by Messrs. Topley and Lebour.[12] It will be seen that while at Harlow Hill the sill is found overlying the Great Limestone of Alston Moor, at Rugley, five miles off it lies about 1000 feet lower down, far below the position of the Tyne-bottom Limestone. Still farther north, however, the sill west of Holy Island is said to lie 800 feet above the Great Limestone and to come among the higher beds of the Carboniferous Limestone series.[13]

[Footnote 12: _Op. cit._ plate xviii.]

[Footnote 13: _Op. cit._ p. 414.]

The Whin Sill appears generally to thicken in an easterly or north-easterly direction. There are further indications that it was intruded from east to west. Thus, at Shepherd's Gap, on the Great Roman Wall, the dolerite, coming evidently from an easterly quarter, has broken up and thrust itself beneath a bed of limestone. Again, when the sill bifurcates the branches unite towards the east or north-east.[14] The sill can be proved to thin away to the west from Teesdale to the Pennine escarpment, and in Weardale the "Little Whin Sill" diminishes from 20 feet, till in three miles it disappears.[15]

[Footnote 14: _Op. cit._ p. 415.]

[Footnote 15: _Op. cit._ p. 419.]

Fig. 177.--Sections of the Carboniferous Limestone series of Northumberland showing the variations in the position of the Whin Sill. By Messrs. Topley and Lebour.]

The strata in contact with the Whin Sill, both above and below, have been more or less altered. Sandstones have been least affected; shales have suffered most, passing into a kind of porcellanite, with development of garnet and other minerals.[16] Limestone often shows only slight traces of change, though here and there it has become crystalline.

[Footnote 16: Mr. Teall, _op. cit._ xxxix. (1884), p. 642, and authors cited by him.]

No trace of any boss or neck has been detected in the whole region which might be supposed to mark a funnel of ascent for the material of the Whin Sill. The Hett Dyke and the High Green Dyke, already noticed, may, however, have been possibly connected with the injection of this great intrusive sheet. No other visible mass of igneous rock in the region has been even plausibly conjectured to indicate a point or line of emission for the sill.

It is certainly singular that in so wide a territory, where the whole succession of strata has been so admirably laid bare by denudation in thousands of natural sections, and where, moreover, much additional information has been obtained from lead-mining as to the nature of the rocks below ground, not a single vestige of tuff, agglomerate or interstratified lava has been up to the present time recorded, unless the Harkess rocks already alluded to can be so regarded.

Judging, however, from the analogy of the other districts of igneous rocks in Britain, we can hardly resist the conclusion that the Great Whin Sill is essentially a manifestation of volcanic action, that it was connected with the uprise of basic lava in volcanic orifices, and that the subterranean energy may quite probably have succeeded in reaching the surface and ejecting there both lavas and tuffs.

It appears to be certain that any vents which existed cannot have lain to the west of the present escarpment of the sill, for no trace of them can be found there piercing the Carboniferous or older formations. They must have lain somewhere to the east in the area now overspread with Millstone Grit and Coal-measures, or still farther east in the tract now concealed under the North Sea. The evidence of the sill itself, as we have seen, corroborates this view of the probable situation of the centre of disturbance.

The question of the geological age of the sill is one of considerable difficulty, to which no confident answer can be given.[17] The injection of the diabase must obviously be considerably later than the highest strata through which it has risen; that is, it must be younger than some of the higher members of the Carboniferous Limestone series. But here our positive evidence fails.

[Footnote 17: See Messrs. Topley and Lebour, _op. cit._ p. 418.]

The Sill is traversed by the same faults which disrupt the surrounding Carboniferous rocks. It is therefore of older date than these dislocations. Its striking general parallelism with the shales and limestones probably proves that it was intruded before the rocks were much disturbed from their original horizontal position. But the manner in which the intrusive rock has been thrust into and has involved the shales and limestones seems to indicate that these strata had already become consolidated and lay under the pressure of a great thickness of superincumbent Carboniferous strata.

In the absence of all certainty on the subject it seems most natural to place the Whin Sill provisionally among the Carboniferous volcanic series with which petrographically and structurally it has so much in common. In Scotland the puy-eruptions continued till the time of the Coal-measures. If, before the close of the Carboniferous period, volcanic vents were opened somewhere to the east of the coal-fields of Northumberland and Durham, they might be accompanied with basic sills injected into the Carboniferous Limestone series, which was then lying still approximately horizontal under a thickness of from 3500 to 5000 feet of Carboniferous sedimentary deposits. These still undiscovered volcanoes seem to have been endowed with even more energy than those of Central and Southern Scotland, at least nowhere else among the Carboniferous records of Britain is there such a colossal manifestation of subterranean intrusion as the Great Whin Sill.

2. THE DERBYSHIRE TOADSTONES

In the absence of any certain evidence that the Whin Sill belongs to the Carboniferous period, we must advance southward into the very heart of England before any clear vestiges can be found of contemporaneous volcanic eruptions among the members of the Carboniferous system. After quitting the lavas and tuffs of Roxburghshire and their brief continuations across the English border, we do not again meet with any truly bedded volcanic rocks in that system until we reach the middle of Derbyshire. In this picturesque district, famous for its lead-mines and its mineral waters, a feebly developed but interesting group of intercalated lavas, locally called "toadstones," has long been known. There is thus a space of some 150 miles across which, though the formations are there so fully developed and so abundantly trenched by valleys from the top to the bottom of the system, no volcanic vents nor any trace of Carboniferous volcanic ejections has yet been found. On the other hand, after the district of the "toadstones" is passed, the Carboniferous rocks are again destitute of any volcanic intercalations across the centre and south-west of England and over Wales, until after a space of about 150 miles they reappear in Somerset.

The volcanic group of Derbyshire thus stands out entirely isolated. Lying in the Carboniferous Limestone, where that formation is typically developed, it presents an admirable example of a thoroughly marine phase of volcanic action (Map I.).

One of the most prominent features in the geology of the centre of England is the broad anticlinal fold which brings up the lower portion of the Carboniferous system to form the long ridge of the Pennine chain that runs from Yorkshire to the Midland plain, and separates the eastern from the western coal-fields. This fold widens southwards until not only the Millstone Grit and Yoredale rocks, but the underlying Mountain Limestone is laid bare. A broad limestone district is thus exposed in the very heart of the country, ranging as a green fertile undulating tableland, deeply cut by winding valleys, which expose admirable sections of the strata, but nowhere reach the base of the system. The total visible depth of the limestone series is computed to be about 1500 feet; the Yoredale shales and limestones may be 500 feet more; so that the calcareous formations in which the volcanic phenomena are exhibited reach a thickness of at least 2000 feet.

It is not yet definitely known through what vertical extent of this thickness of sedimentary material the volcanic platforms extend, but where most fully developed they perhaps range through 1000 feet, lying chiefly in the Carboniferous Limestone, but apparently in at least one locality extending up into the lower division of the Yoredale group. The area within which they can be studied corresponds nearly with that in which the limestone forms the surface of the country, or a district measuring about 20 miles from north to south, with an extreme breadth of 10 miles in an east and west direction.

A special historical interest belongs to the Derbyshire "toadstones."[18] They furnished Whitehurst with material for his speculations, and were believed by him to be as truly igneous rocks as the lava which flows from Hecla, Vesuvius or Etna. But he thought that they had been introduced among the strata and "did not overflow the surface of the earth, according to the usual operations of volcanoes."[19]

[Footnote 18: This word has by some writers been supposed to be corrupted from _tod-stein_, dead-stone, in allusion to the dying out of the lead veins there; by others the name has been thought to be derived from the peculiar green speckled aspect of much of the rock, resembling the back of a toad.]

[Footnote 19: _An Enquiry into the Original State and Formation of the Earth_, 1778, Appendix, pp. 149, _et seq._]

His views were published as far back as 1778, three years after Hutton read the first outline of his theory of the earth and made known his observations regarding the igneous origin of whinstones.[20] The first detailed account of the Derbyshire eruptive rocks was that given by Fairey,[21] which has served as the basis of all subsequent descriptions. Conybeare, in particular, prepared a succinct narrative from Fairey's more diffuse statements, and thus placed clearly before geologists the nature and distribution of these volcanic intercalations.[22] Subsequently the district was mapped by De la Beche and the officers of the Geological Survey, and the areas occupied by the several outcrops of igneous rock could then be readily seen.[23]

[Footnote 20: _Trans. Roy. Soc. Edin._ i. p. 275, _et seq._ Hutton specially mentions the toadstone of Derbyshire as one of the rocks produced by fusion, p. 277.]

[Footnote 21: _General View of the Agriculture and Minerals of Derbyshire_ (1811).]

[Footnote 22: _Outlines of the Geology of England and Wales_ (1822), p. 448.]

[Footnote 23: See Sheets 71 N.W., 72 N.E., 81 N.E. and S.E. and 82 S.W. of the Geological Survey of England and Wales.]

Though the "toadstones" were believed to form definite platforms among the limestone strata, and thus to be capable of being used as reliable horizons in the mineral fields of Derbyshire, they appear to have been generally regarded as intrusive sheets like the Whin Sill of the north. Thus De la Beche in his _Manual of Geology_, giving a summary of what was known at the time regarding intercalated igneous rocks, remarks with regard to the Derbyshire toadstones that they may from all analogy be considered to have been injected among the limestones which would be easily separated by the force of the intruded igneous material.[24] But the same observer, after his experience among the ancient volcanic rocks of Devonshire, came fully to recognize the proofs of contemporaneous outflow among the Derbyshire toadstones. In his subsequently published _Geological Observer_, he described the toadstones as submarine lavas that had been poured out over the floor of the sea in which the Carboniferous Limestone was deposited, and had been afterwards covered up under fresh deposits of limestone.[25] It is remarkable, however, that he specially comments on the absence, as he believed, of any contemporaneously ejected ashes and lapilli, such as occur in Devonshire. That true tuffs or volcanic ashes are associated with the toadstones was noticed by Jukes in 1861,[26] and afterwards by the Geological Survey.[27] Since that time geologists have generally recognized these Derbyshire igneous rocks as truly contemporaneous intercalations. But very little has recently been written on the structure of the district, our information regarding it being still based mainly on the early observations of Fairey and the mapping of the Geological Survey.

[Footnote 24: _Manual_, 3rd edit. 1833, p. 462.]

[Footnote 25: _Geological Observer_ (1851), pp. 642-645.]

[Footnote 26: _Student's Manual of Geology_, 2nd edit. (1863), p. 523. For a general _résumé_ of the proofs of contemporaneity furnished by the toadstones, see "The Geology of North Derbyshire," by Messrs. A. H. Green and A. Strahan (_Memoirs of the Geological Survey_, 2nd edit. (1887), p. 123).]

[Footnote 27: In the first edition of the _Memoir on the Geology of North Derbyshire_, published in 1859, the authors of which were Messrs. A. H. Green, C. le Neve Foster and J. R. Dakyns.]

The subject, however, has now been resumed by Mr. H. Arnold Bemrose, who in 1894, after a prolonged study of the petrography of the rocks, communicated the results of his researches to the Geological Society.[28] In his excellent paper, to which I shall immediately make fuller reference, he mentions the localities at which lava-form and fragmental rocks may be observed, but does not enter on the discussion of the geological structure of the region or of the history of the volcanic eruptions. Before the announcement of his paper, hearing that I proposed to make for the first time a rapid traverse of the toadstone district, for the purpose of acquainting myself with the rocks on the ground, he kindly offered to conduct me over it. My chief object, besides that of seeing the general nature of the volcanic phenomena of the region, was to examine more particularly the areas of the volcanic fragmental rocks, with the view of discovering whether among them some remains might not be found of the actual vents of discharge. In this search I was entirely successful. Aided by Mr. Bemrose's intimate knowledge of the ground, I was enabled to visit in rapid succession those tracts which seemed most likely to furnish the required evidence, and in a few days was fortunate enough to obtain proofs of six or seven distinct vents, ranging from the extreme northern to the furthest southern boundary of the volcanic district. Mr. Bemrose has undertaken to continue the investigation, and will, I trust, work out the detailed stratigraphy of the Carboniferous Limestone so as eventually to furnish an exhaustive narrative of the whole volcanic history of Derbyshire. Meanwhile no adequate account of the area can be given. But I will here state all the essential facts which up to the present time have been ascertained.

[Footnote 28: _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ vol. l. (1894), p. 603.]

1. THE ROCKS ERUPTED.--Mr. Allport has described the microscopic character of some of the toadstones,[29] and further details have been supplied by Mr. Teall.[30] The fullest account of the subject, however, is that given by Mr. Bemrose in the paper above referred to. This observer distinguishes the lava-form from the fragmental rocks, and gives the minute characters of each series. He does not, however, separate true interstratified lavas from injected sills, nor the bedded tuffs from the coarse agglomerates which fill up the vents. These distinctions are obviously required in order that the true nature and sequence of the materials in the volcanic eruptions may be traced, and that the phenomena exhibited in Derbyshire may be brought into comparison with those found in other Carboniferous districts. But to establish them satisfactorily the whole region must be carefully re-examined and even to some extent re-mapped.

[Footnote 29: _Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc._ xxx. (1874), p. 529.]

[Footnote 30: _British Petrography_, p. 209.]

The lavas (including, in the meantime, sheets which there can be little doubt are sills) show three main types of minute structure and composition, which are discriminated by Mr. Bemrose as--(_a_) Olivine-dolerites; these, the most abundant of the series, consist of augite in grains, olivine in idiomorphic crystals, plagioclase giving lath-shaped and tabular sections, and magnetite or ilmenite in rods and grains; (_b_) Ophitic olivine-dolerites, consisting of augite in ophitic plates forming the groundmass, in which are imbedded idiomorphic olivine, plagioclase (often giving large lath-shaped sections and magnetite or ilmenite); (_c_) Olivine-basalts; these rocks are distinguished by containing crystals of augite and olivine in a groundmass of small felspar-laths, granular augite and magnetite or ilmenite, with very little interstitial matter. They have been noticed only in two of the outcrops of toadstone.

The fragmental rocks have been shown by Mr. Bemrose to cover a much more extensive space than had been previously supposed. He has found them to be distinguished by an abundance of lapilli varying from minute fragments up to pieces about the size of a pea, and composed of a material that differs in structure from the dolerites and basalts with which the tuffs are associated. These lapilli consist largely of a glassy base more or less altered, which is generally finely vesicular and encloses abundant skeleton crystals and crystallites. The tuffs thus very closely resemble some of the Carboniferous basic tuffs of Fife, already referred to (vol. i. p. 422), and like these they include abundant blocks of dolerite and basalt.

2. GEOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF THE TOADSTONE DISTRICT.--As the volcanic rocks of Derbyshire lie among the Carboniferous Limestones of a broad anticlinal dome, they are only exposed where these limestones have been sufficiently denuded, and as the base of the limestones is nowhere laid bare, the lowest parts of the volcanic series may be concealed. Over the tract where the toadstones can be examined they appear as bands regularly intercalated with the limestones, but varying in thickness in the course of their outcrops. As they are prone to decay, they usually form smooth grassy slopes between the limestone scarps, though isolated blocks of the dull brown igneous rocks may often be seen protruding from the surface. Now and then a harder bed of toadstone caps a hill, and thus forms a prominent feature in the landscape, but as a rule these igneous bands play no distinguishing part in the scenery, and are indeed less conspicuous than the white escarpments of limestone which overlie them.

It was the opinion of the older geologists that three distinct platforms of toadstone extend without break throughout the district, and subdivide the limestones into four portions. But this opinion does not seem to have been based on good evidence either of sequence or of continuity. Various facts were brought forward by the officers of the Geological Survey to show that the supposed persistence of the three platforms of toadstone did not really exist, but that these sheets of igneous material are found at different spots on very different horizons, and are of limited horizontal range.[31] So far as my own limited observations go, they entirely corroborate this view. There can be little doubt, I think, that the identity of certain outcrops of toadstone has been assumed, and the assumption has been carried throughout the district. The truth is that the number of successive platforms on which igneous materials appear will never be satisfactorily determined until the stratigraphy of the Derbyshire Carboniferous Limestone is worked out in detail. When the successive members of this great calcareous formation have been identified by lithological and palæontological characters over the district, it will be easy to allocate each outcrop of toadstone to its true geological horizon. When this labour has been completed, it will probably be found that instead of three, there have been many discharges of volcanic material during the deposition of the limestone series; that these have proceeded from numerous small vents, and that they are all of comparatively restricted horizontal extent. Such a detailed examination will also determine how far the toadstones include veritable sills, and on what horizons these intrusive sheets have been injected.

[Footnote 31: _Geol. Surv. Mem. on North Derbyshire_, by Messrs. Green and Strahan (1887), p. 104.]

In the meantime, we know that the lowest visible bands of toadstone are underlain by several hundred feet of limestone, thus proving that the earliest known volcanic explosions took place over the floor of the Carboniferous Limestone sea, after at least 700 or 800 feet of calcareous sediment had accumulated there. The latest traces of volcanic activity are found in a part of the Yoredale group of shales and limestones which form the uppermost member of the Carboniferous Limestone of this region. But it is not quite clear whether the vesicular diabase found there is interstratified or intrusive. Certainly no contemporaneous tuffs have yet been found among the Yoredale rocks, nor in any higher subdivision of the Carboniferous system, though coarse agglomerates marking the position of vents do traverse the Yoredale group at Kniveton.

It may be remarked that in the district over which the toadstones can be seen, two areas are recognizable, in each of which the exposures of the igneous rocks are numerous, while between them lies an intervening tract wherein there is hardly any visible outcrop of these rocks. The northern and much the more extensive area stretches from Castleton to Sheldon, while the southern spreads from Winster to Kniveton. This distribution not improbably points to the original position of the vents, and indicates a northern more numerous group of volcanic orifices, and a southern tract where the vents were fewer, or at least spread their discharges over a more limited space.

3. THE VENTS.--It had always appeared to me singular that, in ground so deeply trenched by valleys as the toadstone district of Derbyshire, no trace had been recognized of any bosses or necks from which these volcanic sheets might have been erupted. It is true that in mining operations masses of toadstone had been penetrated to a considerable depth without their bottom being reached, and the suggestion had been made that in such cases a shaft may actually have been sunk on one of the vents through which the toadstone came up.[32] One instance in particular was cited where, at Black Hillock, on Tideswell Moor, close to Peak Forest Village, a mass of toadstone was not cut through, though pierced to a depth of 100 fathoms. In that neighbourhood, however, several of the sheets of eruptive material are probably sills, and the shaft at Black Hillock may have been sunk upon the pipe or vein that supplied one or more of these intrusive sheets.

[Footnote 32: _Geol. Surv. Mem. on North Derbyshire_, p. 134.]

It was therefore with no little interest that I detected a series of vents at four separate localities, viz. Castleton, Grange Mill, Hopton, and Kniveton Wood. I have no doubt that a more extended search will bring others to light. Those observed by me are all filled with coarse agglomerate, the blocks in which are mostly composed of different lavas, sometimes with the addition of blocks of limestone, while the matrix consists mainly of lapilli of basic devitrified glass.

The most typical examples form a group of two, possibly three, vents which rise into two isolated, smooth, grassy dome-shaped hills at Grange Mill, five miles west from Matlock Bath.[33] In external form and colour, these eminences present a contrast to the scarped slopes of limestone around them. They at once recall the contours of many of the volcanic necks in Central Scotland. On examination it is found that the material composing them is a dull green agglomerate, the matrix of which is a compact substance weathering spheroidally, and full of small lapilli of minutely vesicular diabase. The larger stones consist, for the most part, of various vesicular dolerites or diabases, together with some pieces of limestone and occasionally large blocks of the latter rock, altered into a saccharoid condition. Two dykes of dolerite or basalt traverse the margin of the larger vent.

[Footnote 33: This is Mr. Bemrose's outcrop, No. 46, _op. cit._ p. 633.]

The steep sides of these agglomerate domes rise from the low ground around them to a height of 100 to 180 feet, their summits being a little more than 900 feet above the sea. The smaller neck is nearly circular, and measures about 1000 feet in diameter. The larger mass is less regular in shape, and is prolonged into such a bulge on the south-east as to suggest that its prolongation in that direction may really mark the position of a third and much smaller vent contiguous to it. The longer diameter of the larger mass is 2300 and the shorter 1300 feet.

On the south and west sides, the surrounding limestone can be traced up to within a few feet of the edge of the agglomerate, and its strata are there found to be much jumbled and broken, while their texture is rather more crystalline than usual, though not saccharoid. The two necks are separated by a narrow valley in which no rock is visible. Their opposite declivities meet at the bottom of this hollow, and are so definitely marked off that, even in the absence of proof that they are disjoined by intervening limestone, there can be little hesitation in regarding each hill as marking a distinct vent. A wider valley extends along the eastern base of the necks, and slopes upward on its east side until it is crowned by a long escarpment of limestone, which reaches a height of 1000 feet above the sea, or about 100 feet above the valley from which it rises. Unfortunately, the bottom and slopes of this depression are thickly covered with soil, but at one or two places debris of fine tuff may be observed, and at the northern and southern ends of the hollow well-bedded green and reddish tuff appears, dipping gently below the limestone escarpment. This band of volcanic detritus evidently underlies the limestone, and forms most of the gentle slope on the east side of the valley. It may be from 70 to 100 feet thick. That it was discharged from one or both of the necks seems tolerably clear. Its material resembles that forming the matrix of the agglomerate. The general arrangement of the rocks at this interesting locality is represented in Fig. 179, which is reduced from my survey on the scale of six inches to a mile. A section across the smaller vent would show the structure represented in Fig. 180.

1. Limestone; 2. Stratified tuff intercalated among the limestones; 3. Agglomerate.]

This group of vents lies in the southern of the two tracts of the volcanic district. In the northern tract a mass of agglomerate pierces the base of the limestone escarpment about a quarter of a mile west from the entrance to the Peak Cavern at Castleton.[34] It is rudely semicircular in area, stretching down the slope until its northern extension is lost under the lower ground. The agglomerate is not well exposed, but it can be seen to be a green, granular crumbling rock, made up in great part of minutely vesicular lapilli, enclosing blocks of various diabases two feet long or more. From the abrupt way in which this agglomerate rises through the limestone, there can be little doubt that it marks the position of one of the volcanic vents of the time. As it stands on the extreme northern verge of the limestone area, the ground further north being covered with the Yoredale rocks and Millstone Grit, it is the most northerly of the whole volcanic district.

[Footnote 34: This is outcrop No. 1 of Mr. Bemrose's paper, p. 625.]

Along the southern margin of the limestone country a group of agglomerate masses probably marks another chain of vents. These are specially interesting, inasmuch as they abut on the Yoredale series, and may thus be looked upon as among the latest of the volcanic chimneys. One of them is seen at Hopton,[35] where along the side of the road a good section is exposed of coarse tumultuous agglomerate, having a dull green matrix, composed of green, brown, and black, minutely cellular, basic, devitrified, glassy lapilli, showing under the microscope abundant microlites and crystals or calcareous pseudomorphs of olivine, augite, and felspar, and much magnetite dust. Through this matrix are distributed blocks of slaggy basalt and dolerite. An interesting feature of this mass is the occurrence in it of some veins, two or three inches broad, of a compact black porphyritic basalt. I did not trace the relations of this agglomerate to the stratified rocks around it. But its internal structure and composition mark it out as a true neck. It extends, according to the Geological Survey map, for about half a mile along the edge of the limestone, and is represented as being separated by two faults from the Yoredale series immediately to the south. So long as the belief is entertained that the toadstones are contemporaneous outflows of lava lying on certain definite horizons, far below the summit of the limestones, the position of the Hopton agglomerate is only explicable on the assumption of some dislocation by which the Yoredale shales have been brought down against it. But when we realize that the rock is an unstratified agglomerate, probably marking the place of a volcanic vent, and therefore rising transgressively through the surrounding strata, the necessity for a fault is removed, or if a fault is inserted its existence should be justified on other evidence than the relations of the igneous rock to the surrounding strata.

[Footnote 35: _Geol. Surv. Mem. North Derbyshire_, p. 24. This is outcrop No. 53 of Mr. Bemrose's paper, p. 635.]

Four miles to the south-west of Hopton, on the slope of the hill at Kniveton Wood, another remarkable mass of agglomerate forms a rounded ridge between the two forks of a small stream.[36] Its granular matrix, like that of the other necks, consists of lapilli of minutely vesicular basic glassy lava or pumice, and encloses large and small rounded blocks of finely cellular basalt and pieces of limestone. The rock is unstratified, and in all respects resembles that of ordinary Carboniferous necks in Scotland. Its relations to the Yoredale rocks are laid bare in the channels of the streamlets. There the shales and thin limestones may be seen much broken and plicated, their curved and fractured ends striking directly at the agglomerate. They may be traced to within a yard of the agglomerate. On the Geological Survey map the igneous rock is represented as bounded by two parallel faults. But I hardly think that this explanation suffices to account for the relations of the rocks and their remarkable boundary-line, which seems to me to be undoubtedly the wall of a volcanic vent. To the east of the streams, another mass of agglomerate may mark another neck, while to the north, a third detached area of the same kind of rock, rising among the limestones, may be regarded as likewise a distinct mass. At this locality, therefore, there are two, possibly three, vents. One of these, from the way in which it cuts across the Yoredale shales and limestones, is to be assigned to a time later than the older part of the Yoredale series, and thus, like the Hopton mass, it indicates that in the south of the volcanic area eruptions did not cease with the close of the deposition of the thick limestones, but were prolonged even into the time of the Yoredale rocks.

[Footnote 36: Outcrop No. 56, p. 638 of Mr. Bemrose's paper.]

A further proof of the late age of these southern patches of volcanic material is shown by two bands of vesicular toadstone in the Yoredale series, a little south from the village of Kniveton. These rocks are traced on the Survey Map, and are shown in a diagram in the Memoir, where their position is sought to be explained by a system of parallel faulting.[37] I was able to trace the actual contact of the western band with the strata underneath it, and satisfied myself that there is no fault at the junction. The igneous material is regularly bedded with the Yoredale shales and limestones. Either, therefore, these bands are intercalated lava-streams or intrusive sills. If mere vesicular structure were enough to distinguish true outflowing lavas, then there could be no doubt about these Kniveton rocks. But this structure is found in so many Carboniferous sills, particularly in those thin sheets which have been injected into coals and black shales, that its presence is far from decisive. The vesicles in the Kniveton rocks are small and pea-like, tolerably uniform in size and shape, and crowded together. They are thus not at all like the irregular cavities in the ordinary cellular and scoriaceous lavas of the toadstone series.

[Footnote 37: _Op. cit._ p. 87.]

Whether or not the question of their true relations be ever satisfactorily settled, these Kniveton bands are certainly younger than the lower portion of the Yoredale group. Their evidence thus agrees with that of the southern agglomerates in showing that the volcanic activity of this region was continued even after the thick calcareous masses of the Carboniferous Limestone series had ceased to be deposited.

Besides the six necks to which I have referred, a rock in Ember Lane, above Bonsall, probably belongs to another vent.[38] It is particularly interesting from the great preponderance of limestone fragments in it. The volcanic explosions at this locality broke up the already solidified limestones on the floor of the Carboniferous Limestone sea, and strewed them around, mingled with volcanic blocks and dust of the prevailing type.

[Footnote 38: This is outcrop No. 39 of Mr. Bemrose's paper, p. 632.]

When the district has been more carefully searched, other centres of eruption will no doubt be discovered. It may then be possible to depict the distribution of the active vents, and to connect with them the outflow of the bedded lavas. So far as I have been able to ascertain, there are no necks of dolerite or basalt, though, as I have shown, dykes or veins of molten rock are occasionally to be found in the agglomerates of the necks.

4. THE LAVAS AND TUFFS.--I have referred to the opinion of De la Beche that the toadstones of Derbyshire were poured out as lava-streams without any accompanying fragmentary discharges, and to the correction of this opinion by the subsequent observations of Jukes and of the Geological Survey. But though the existence of interbedded tuffs has long been known, it was not until Mr. Bemrose's more careful scrutiny that the relative importance of the tuffs among the lavas was first indicated. He has shown that a number of the bands mapped as "toadstone" are tuffs, and he has discovered other bands of tuff which have not yet been placed on any published map.

In examining the outcrops of the various toadstones of Derbyshire we learn that some of them are lavas without tuffs, probably including a number of bands, which are really sills; that others are formed of both lavas and tuffs, and that a third type shows only bedded tuff. Each of these developments will deserve separate description. But before entering into details, we may take note of the varying thicknesses of the different toadstones which have been determined by observation at the surface or by measurement underneath in mining operations. In some cases a distinct band of toadstone, separated by many feet or yards of limestone from the next band, and therefore serving to mark a separate volcanic discharge, may not exceed a yard or two in total thickness, and from that minimum may swell out to 100 feet. The majority of the bands probably range between 50 and 100 feet in thickness. In one exceptional case at Snitterton, a mass of "blackstone" is said to have been proved to be 240 feet thick, but this rock may not improbably have been a sill.[39] The true contemporaneous intercalations seem to be generally less than 100 feet in thickness.

[Footnote 39: A difference is made by the mining community between "toadstone" and what is called "blackstone." The former name appears to be restricted to the amygdaloidal green and generally more or less decayed lavas; the latter, so far as I can learn, is applied to the dark, more solid and crystalline rocks. If this distinction be well founded the one name may perhaps serve to mark the open cellular lavas, the other the more compact, dark, and heavy intrusive sheets.]

(_a_) Lavas without Tuffs.--Examples occur of sheets of toadstone which consist entirely of contemporaneously ejected diabase, basalt or dolerite. This rock is then dull green or brown in colour, more or less earthy in texture, and irregularly amygdaloidal. The vesicles are extremely varied in size, form and distribution, sometimes expanding until the rock becomes a slaggy mass. A central more solid portion between a scoriaceous bottom and top may sometimes be observed, as at the Great Rocks Quarry, Peak Forest Limeworks (Fig. 181). In this, as in other examples, a remarkably hummocky and uneven surface of limestone lies below the igneous band, the calcareous rock presenting knobs and ridges, separated by cauldron-shaped cavities and clefts, some of which are several yards deep. These inequalities are filled in and covered over with a soft yellow and brown clay, varying up to three or four feet thickness, and passing upwards into the more solid toadstone. There can hardly be any doubt that this singularly uneven limestone surface is due to the solvent action of water lying between the limestone and the somewhat impervious toadstone above, and that the clay represents partly the insoluble residue of the calcareous rock, but chiefly the result of the action of the infiltrating water on the bottom of the igneous band.[40]

[Footnote 40: _Geological Survey Memoir on North Derbyshire_, p. 20 and footnote.]

Fig. 181.--Section of vesicular and amygdaloidal diabase resting on
Carboniferous limestone, Peak Forest Limeworks, Great Rocks Quarry.

1. Limestone with a surface dissolved into cauldron-like
hollows; 2. Rotten yellow and brown clay resulting from
decomposition of toadstone and white clay from the solution of the
limestone--sometimes three or four feet thick; 3. Toadstone, a
diabase with highly slaggy base.
]

1. Toadstone; 2. Limestone; _f_, Fault.]

Junctions of the upper surfaces of the lava-sheets with the overlying limestone show that the igneous material sometimes assumed hummocky forms, which the calcareous deposits gradually overspread and covered.[41] A good example of this kind may be observed by the roadside at the foot of Raven's Tor, Millersdale. As shown in the subjoined figure, the limestone has here been worn into a cave, the floor of which is formed by the toadstone. The latter rock, of the usual dull green, slaggy and amygdaloidal character, is covered immediately by the limestone, but I did not observe any fragments of the toadstone, nor any trace of ashy materials in the overlying calcareous strata. This section shows that after the outflow of the lava, the sedimentation of the limestone was quietly resumed, and the igneous interruption was entirely buried.

[Footnote 41: Compare De la Beche, _Geological Observer_, pp. 559, 560, and _North Derbyshire Memoir_, p. 123.]