Chapter V

The Second Public Session--Swearing a Creed never before known in a General Council--Really an Oath including Feudal Obedience.

The same tone of disappointment in which the _Civiltá_ had said that as the discussion of the Draft was not concluded, no Decree would be promulged in the second session, pervaded the additional remark that the world would describe as a vain ceremony the recital of the creed with which it had been resolved to fill up the day. Writers of different shades, as if by concert, did describe it as a religious ceremony,--a mere ceremony, an empty ceremony, a vain ceremony, and a tedious ceremony.

So far from taking this session as a vain show, we take it for one of the most distinctive footmarks left in the deposits of history by the mammoth which we call the Papacy. Without contrivance of man--in contravention, indeed, of arrangements made with patient forethought--the Vatican Council was compelled, under guise of reciting a creed, to exhibit its bishops as if barons swearing allegiance to a prince in peril of losing his estates. The creed recited was one never before seen or heard of in any General Council. An apparent accident set the faith of the early Church, and the modern composite oath and creed, before the eye of history in a contrast sharper than any artist could have devised.

A cause similar to that which led to this day being employed in setting face to face the old creed and the new, had at Trent led to the act that formed the reverse of the medal. At Trent, on the day fixed for the third session, no Decree was ready for promulgation, just as none was ready at the Vatican on that fixed for the second.

Consequently, at Trent, after much reluctance, the Fathers, rather than let the day appointed pass without a session, consented to fill up the time in doing what many of them felt would expose them to ridicule--in reciting the creed. Thus did they create an example which the Curia now followed. Two unforeseen accidents, linked together only by the association of precedent, led to the placing of the Catholic creed as it existed up to the Council of Trent, and the Romish creed as framed after Trent, side by side in a framework so impressive as to ensure the exhibition of the two in contrast to all ages.

At Trent the Fathers said that they would set forth as the firm and sole foundation, against which the gates of hell should not prevail, the creed used by the Roman Church, which was the _principium_, wherein "all who confessed Christ" of necessity concurred,--an expression which seems as if it was the last breath of catholicity on the lips of the Papal society. Another slight reminiscence of catholicity appears when it is said that the creed is given in the exact words in which it is read "in all churches,"--a terminology proper to apostolic pens, or to the lips of our glorified Lord, speaking to His servant John, when the word "churches" was the Christian vernacular, and "church" as a collective was rarely used, and only in the very largest sense possible.

Led by a way which they knew not, the Fathers at Trent set up a memorial of the faith of the Christian Churches as they found it in the creed. Led also by a way which they knew not, the Fathers at the Vatican set up an everlasting remembrance of what their predecessors at Trent had done with the faith.

The Cardinals arrived on the morning of the Epiphany, dressed in red; but they changed to the white proper to the day. Patriarchs, primates, archbishops, bishops, abbots and generals of orders, were all in white, except the Orientals, who had never surrendered to the primacy of Rome on the sacred subject of vestments. The Pope entered the hall, as he had done at the first session, between Antonelli and Mertel.

After Mass, Dominicis-Tosti and Philip Ralli, the two Promoters of the Council; reverently drew nigh to the throne, and addressing the Pontiff, said:--

Inasmuch as, by ancient appointment of the Fathers, the sacred
Councils of the Church have been wont to set the Confession of the
Faith in the forefront of all their doings, as a buckler against
every heresy, we, therefore, the Promoters of this Vatican Council,
do humbly pray that profession of the Catholic faith in the form
prescribed by thy predecessor of sacred memory, Pius IV, be made
this day, in public session by all the Fathers of this Vatican
Council.

The Pontiff replied, "We enjoin and command accordingly."

Then arose the sovereign from his throne, took off the sacred mitre, and, with loud and clear voice, recited for the first time in the history of man, as the belief of a General Council, the creed of Pius IV. Near the end of it, he came to the clause which swears obedience to the Roman Pontiff. This he omitted. The conclusion swears to maintain the faith just recited, and, as much as in the confessor lies, to enforce it "on all those committed to him." The Pope simply said to enforce it "upon all," and then he closed according to the regular form,--"I, Pius, promise, vow, and swear, so help me God, and these God's Holy Gospels."

Bishop Fessler, Secretary of the Council, and Bishop Valenziani, now came to the throne. The Pontiff handed to them the creed of Pius IV, just as he had handed his own Decrees at the first session. Valenziani, ascending the pulpit, recited it, in his own name and in that of all the Fathers. When he came to the portentous obedience clause, omitted by him who owes no account to man, tribunal, or nation, the bishop, read, "To the Roman Pontiff, successor of the blessed Peter, prince of the Apostles, and Vicar of Jesus Christ, I promise and swear true obedience,"--as if it was an installation in a feudal order. No wonder that Canon Pelletier, writing in Frond (vol. vii. p. 170), should say that this act of homage, "in the circumstances of which all are aware, had an immense importance." Valenziani then concluded the form as the Pope had done, only, instead of enforcing obedience "upon all," it was "on all committed to him."

Patrizi, the Senior Cardinal present,[266] now rose, came to the throne, knelt, laid his hand on the volume of the Gospels, and lifting up his voice, said, "I, Constantine, Bishop of Porto and Rufina, promise, vow, and swear according to the form now read, so help me God, and these God's Holy Gospels"; and he kissed the book.

Then Cardinals and Patriarchs, one by one, after them Primates, Archbishops, Bishops, Abbots, and Generals of Orders, in regular gradation of rank, first two and two, and, later, four and four,[267] came successively to the throne, and during the space of two hours, knelt down, laid the hand on the book, repeated the above words, each inserting his own name, kissed the book, and so swore allegiance to the King of the Vatican, under the form of a profession of the simple and loving faith of Christ. The two creeds, recited at Trent and in St. Peter's, are below, in parallel columns--the one representing what the Council of Trent found, and the other representing what it left. Future epochs will have to mark subsequent innovations. We put _the clause forming the basis of the new dogmas in_ italics. The other italics are those given in Dr. Challoner's recension[268]:--

THE CATHOLIC CREED BEFORE THE ROMISH CREED AFTER THE THE REFORMATION REFORMATION

"I, N., with a firm faith, "I, N., with a firm faith, believe and profess all and believe and profess all and every one of the things which every one of the things which are contained in that creed are contained in that creed which the holy Roman Church which the holy Roman Church maketh use of; namely-- maketh use of; namely--

"I believe in one God, the "I believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth, and of all heaven and earth, and of all things visible and invisible: things visible and invisible: and in one Lord Jesus Christ, and in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, the only-begotten Son of God, _born of the Father before all ages_: _born of the Father before all God of God; Light of light; ages_: God of God; Light of light; true God of true God; begotten, true God of true God; begotten, not made; consubstantial not made; consubstantial to to the Father, by whom the Father, by whom all things all things were made; who, were made; who, for us men, for us men, and for our salvation, and for our salvation, came down came down from heaven, from heaven, and was incarnate and was incarnate by the Holy by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Ghost of the Virgin Mary, and Mary, and was made man. was made man. Was crucified Was crucified also for us under also for us under Pontius Pilate; Pontius Pilate; He suffered He suffered and was buried, and was buried, and the third and the third day He rose again, day He rose again, according according to the Scriptures; to the Scriptures; He ascended He ascended into heaven, sits into heaven, sits at the right at the right hand of the Father, hand of the Father, and is to and is to come again with glory come again with glory to judge to judge the living and the dead; the living and the dead; of of whose kingdom there shall whose kingdom there shall be be no end. And in the Holy no end. And in the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Life-giver, Ghost, the Lord and Life-giver, who proceeds from the Father who proceeds from the Father and the Son, who together with and the Son, who together with the Father and the Son is the Father and the Son is adored and glorified, who spoke adored and glorified, who spoke by the Prophets; and (I believe) by the Prophets; and (I believe) one holy catholic and one holy catholic and apostolic apostolic Church, I confess one Church, I confess one baptism baptism for the remission of for the remission of sins, and sins, and I look for the resurrection I look for the resurrection of of the dead, and the life of the dead, and the life of the the world to come. Amen." world to come. Amen.

"_I most steadfastly admit and
embrace apostolical and
ecclesiastical traditions, and all
other observances and
constitutions of the same Church._

"I also admit the holy
_Scriptures_, according to that
sense which our holy Mother, the
Church, has held, and does hold,
to whom it belongs to _judge_ of
the true sense and interpretation
of the Scriptures; neither
will I ever take and interpret
them otherwise than according
to the unanimous consent of the
Fathers.

"I also profess that there are
truly and properly _seven
sacraments_ of the new law,
instituted by Jesus Christ our
Lord, and necessary for the
salvation of mankind, though not
all for every one; to wit,
_baptism_, _confirmation,
eucharist, penance_, _extreme
unction, orders_, and
_matrimony_; and that they confer
grace; and that of these,
_baptism confirmation_, and
_orders_ cannot be reiterated
without sacrilege.

"I also receive and admit the
received and approved _ceremonies_
of the _Catholic Church_,
used in the solemn administration
of all the aforesaid sacraments.

"I embrace and receive all
and every one of the things
which have been defined and
declared in the holy Council of
_Trent_, concerning _original sin_
and _justification_.

"I profess, likewise, that in
the Mass there is offered to God
a true, proper, and propitiatory
sacrifice for the living and the
dead. And that in the most
holy sacrament of the _eucharist_
there is truly, really, and
substantially, the _body_ and
_blood_, together with the _soul_
and _divinity_, of our Lord Jesus
Christ; and that there is made
a conversion of the whole
substance of the bread into the
body, and of the whole substance
of the wine into the
blood; which conversion the
Catholic Church calls
transubstantiation.

"I confess, also, that under
_either kind_ alone, Christ is
received whole and entire, and a
true sacrament.

"I constantly hold that there
is a _purgatory_, and that the
souls detained therein are helped
by the suffrages of the faithful.

"Likewise, that the _saints_
reigning together with Christ
are to be honoured and invocated,
and that they offer
prayers to God for us; and that
their _relics_ are to be held in
veneration.

"I most firmly assert that
the _images_ of Christ, and of the
Mother of God, ever Virgin,
and also of the other saints,
are to be had and retained, and
that due honour and veneration
are to be given to them.

"I also affirm that the power
of _indulgences_ was left by
Christ in the Church, and that
the use of them is most wholesome
to _Christian_ people.

"I acknowledge the holy
catholic and apostolical Roman
Church, _The Mother and Mistress
of all Churches; And I Promise
[and Swear] True Obedience to
the Bishop of Rome_, successor
to St. Peter, Prince of the
Apostles, and Vicar of Jesus
Christ.

"I likewise undoubtedly receive
and profess all other things
delivered, defined, and declared
by the sacred Canons and
General Councils, and particularly
by the holy Council of
Trent. And I condemn, reject,
and anathematise all things
contrary thereto, and all heresies
which the Church has condemned,
_rejected_, and anathematised.

"This true Catholic faith, _Out
of Which None Can Be Saved_,
which I now freely profess, and
truly hold, I, N., promise, vow,
and swear most constantly to
hold and profess the same whole
and entire, with God's assistance,
to the end of my life; _and
to procure, as far as lies in my
power, that the same shall be
held, taught, and preached by all
who are under me, or are entrusted
to my care by virtue of my
office. So help me God and these
Holy Gospels of God_."

Among the seven hundred men who repeated this set of propositions, unknown to Holy Scripture, we may feel assured that there were not wanting some who as they approached the end of the old, thought, That was the faith as it was professed before Luther; and as they entered upon the new, thought Where was this religion before Luther?

What a contrast between the old and the new! If ever it was true, it is here true, that the old is better. Under the old creed, the conscience is not hampered by any question about the authority of traditions, either apostolic so-called, or such as were confessedly ecclesiastical. The conscience is not perplexed with a fear of interpreting Holy Scripture differently from the unanimous opinion of the Fathers. It is not weighted with seven sacraments, not contracted with scruples about mere rites and modes of administration, not burdened by having to take for gospel every word which some past Council has said on some specified doctrine; not bewildered by a professed repetition ofttimes of the sacrifice once offered up forever, full, perfect, and sufficient; not materialized by transubstantiation of the substance of the bread and wine, not mystified by taking half a sacrament for a whole one, and by asserting that the deliberate evasion of Christ's sacramental command was a true performance of it; not secularized by the mercantile reckonings of purgatory; not let down from filial Christianity towards servile polytheism by the worship of saints, relics, and images; not demoralized by the traffic in indulgences; not narrowed by the domination of one municipal Church over all others; not cramped and degraded by identification with the sins and follies of one human head, much less by an allegiance to that head, as a lord of the faith and a sovereign of the conscience; not envenomed by anathematizing all who do not accept every article that we ourselves accept.

Trent diminished the comprehensiveness of the Papal Society by many new and some grotesque conditions. The present Pontiff has added others, and so far has the shrinking process been now carried that a _reductio ad absurdum_ cannot be logically far off. Believing too much, which comes to believing too little, ends in believing nothing. All these successive submissions of conscience to "authority," of spiritual inquiry and private judgment to priestly dictation, end in the paralysis of the believing faculty. They render a man capable of nothing but submitting.

The ordinary oath of the Papal bishops has often been shown to be in substance the oath of a feudal vassal to his liege lord. It has but a flavour of any evangelical office or work of the soul-winning ministry of Christ. The Emperor Joseph II clearly saw that any man bound to the Pope by that oath could not be reckoned as the subject of any other prince, except by one of those generous fictions which on behalf of the Pope, by way of exception, governments have admitted. But even that oath was not enough; the confession of faith in God must, for all the clergy, be turned into an oath of loyalty to the Bishop of Rome--an oath to a human head in a creed!

The process of taking the oath lasted, as we have said, two hours. The crowd was not great. The session did not raise enthusiasm in any one. Friedrich, who viewed the act of homage from the gallery for theologians, said that nothing could be more tedious. He did not feel flattered with his company in that gallery. Formerly, only doctors were known at Councils as theologians, and, as we have seen, they had real work to do. Now, he says, the chaplains and secretaries of bishops, and even the men who carry the red caps of the Cardinals, figure as theologians--"an edifying company." Even the _Stimmen_ had only a few sentences for this session; and the _Civiltá_, though read principally by persons who may be supposed to have already seen the creed of Pius IV, filled up room by printing it at full. Quirinus wondered whether this "profusion of superfluous oaths was reconcilable with the scriptural prohibition of needless oaths." They had seven hundred and forty-seven oaths taken.

Only the genius of M. Veuillot sufficed, so far as we remember, to cheer the gloom of the day. It was the Epiphany, and in the portions of Scripture included in the offices of the day, he saw the interpretation of the ceremony. The royally robed potentates who bowed before the enthroned priest-king were _the kings of the Gentiles_ prostrating themselves and worshipping the Church, presenting their gold, and frankincense and, myrrh. The words of Isaiah, "The nations shall come to Thy light, and the kings to the brightness of Thy rising," had the same grand meaning. So he cries (i. 79):--

Behold St. Peter's! The throne of the Pontiff and the Cardinal at
the altar, and between throne and altar eight hundred bishops!
Behold the prophecy and behold the fact!

M. Veuillot remarks that in the galleries were present diplomatists and princes who had fallen; but the Church abides! In the crowd, he says, was an Italian "revolutionist, Signor Minghetti, once a subject and minister of the Pope. He bowed with propriety under the benediction of his Father and his master, who was betrayed by him; but he abides!" The fallen princes represented those who, having supported the Papacy, both temporal and spiritual, had been brought to ruin by its bad teaching and worse example. Signor Minghetti and his bow represented those who, rejecting the temporal Papacy, wished to conserve at least the show of the spiritual Papacy. It is for future time to tell whether they to whom he will bequeath the tangled undertaking, will take their place with ex-kings, ex-dukes, ex-princes, and so forth, in the gallery of failures, or whether they will take their place among the wise men who, rejecting the spiritual as worse than the temporal Papacy, and risking all to found States on the principles of the Word of God, have built up great and happy realms. Italy not does think a principle worth running any risk for. She thinks it practical to say to the Papacy, We have found thee unfaithful in the unrighteous mammon, and therefore do we take it from thee, but we commit to thy trust the true riches.

The _Acta Sanctæ Sedis_ say that no date was fixed for the next session. The confidence in the readiness of the Fathers to swallow a large pamphlet of creed in a few days was shaken. "No one," is it pensively added, "could foresee when Decrees would be in readiness, because many Fathers might probably be lengthy in their discourses."[269] The learned editor seems as if he would fain emulate the flight of M. Veuillot, but he soars with weighted wing. In a long apostrophe to Rome, he styles Pius IX "the captain who gloriously fills the place of thine ancient Caesars."[270] In one of his speeches made to Roman professors, Pius IX calls himself "the Cæsar who now addresses you,[271] and to whom alone are obedience and fidelity due."

It is evident that the Curia left this session under the damping effects of a disappointment. It is also evident that some of the bishops felt that they had now performed two sessions, with a month between them, and that the only distinct impression left upon the mind was that they had been twice exhibited, before the whole world, at the feet of a man more richly robed than themselves, seated on a throne in the house of God, and calling himself Father of kings and princes, and Governor of the world. Canon Pelletier points out the great advantage which the Church had obtained by having the Creed of Pius IV "consecrated" in a General Council.

FOOTNOTES:

[Footnote 266: The Dean of the Sacred College, Cardinal Mattei, was unable to attend the sittings.]

[Footnote 267: _Acta Sanctæ Sedis._]

[Footnote 268: _The Grounds of the Catholic Faith_, p. 3. The obedience clause in Challoner, not being meant for the clergy, does not contain the word _swear_. For the same reason is the final clause, which implies authority, omitted. The translation of that clause given here is from Mr. Butler's version.]

[Footnote 269: _Acta S.S._, v. 327.]

[Footnote 270: "Sub co duce qui locum veturum tuorum Cæsarum gloriose occupat."--_Ibid._ 324.]

[Footnote 271: _Discorsi_, i. p. 255.]