Chapter IV: Reproduction (1)

1. REPRODUCTION BY ASCOSPORES

A. HISTORICAL SURVEY

The earliest observations as to the propagation of lichens were made by Malpighi[525] who recorded the presence of soredia on the lichen plant and noted their function as reproductive bodies. He was followed after a considerable interval by Tournefort[526] who placed lichens in a class apart owing to the form of the fruit: “This fruit,” he writes, “is a species of bason or cup which seems to take the place of seeds in these kinds of plants.” He figures _Ramalina fraxinea_ and _Physcia ciliaris_, both well fruited specimens, and he represents the “minute dust” contained in the fruits as subrotund in form. The spores of _Physcia ciliaris_ are of a large size and dark in colour and were undoubtedly seen by Tournefort. Morison[527], in his _History of Oxford Plants_, published very shortly after, dismissed Tournefort’s “seeds” as being too minute to be of any practical interest.

Micheli[528], with truer scientific insight, made the fruiting organs the subject of special study. He decided that the apothecia were floral receptacles, _receptacula florum_, and that the spores were the “flowers” of the lichen. He has figured them in a vertical series in situ, in a section of the disc of _Solorina_ saccata[529] and also in a species of _Pertusaria_[529], in both of which plants the ascospores are unusually large. He adds that he had not so far seen the “semina.”

Micheli’s views were not shared by his immediate successors. Dillenius[530] scarcely believed that the spores could be “flowers” and, in any case, he concluded that they were too minute to be of any real significance in the life of the plant.

Linnaeus[531], and after him Necker[532], Scopoli[533] and others describe the apothecia as the male, the soredia as the female organs of lichens. These old time botanists worked with very low powers of magnification, and easily went astray in the interpretation of imperfectly seen phenomena.

Koelreuter[534], a Professor of Natural History in Carlsruhe, who published a work on _The discovered Secret of Cryptogams_, next hazarded the opinion that the seeds of lichens originated from the substance of the pith, and that the overlying cortical layer supplied the fertilizing sap. Hoffmann[535] devoted a great deal of attention to lichen fructification and he also thought that fertilization must take place within the tissue of the lichens. He regarded the soredia as the true seeds, while allowing that a second series of seeds might be contained in the scutellae (apothecia).

A distinct advance was made by Hedwig[536], a Professor of Botany in Leipzig, towards the end of the eighteenth century. He followed Tournefort in selecting _Physcia ciliaris_ for research, and in that plant he describes and figures not only the apothecia with the dark-coloured septate spores, but also the pycnidia or spermogonia which he regarded as male organs. The soredia, typically represented and figured by him on _Parmelia physodes_, he judged to be “male flowers of a different type.”

Acharius[537] did not add much to the knowledge of reproduction in lichens, though he takes ample note of the various fruiting structures for which he invented the terms _apothecia_, _perithecia_ and _soredia_. Under still another term _gongyli_ he included not only spores, but the spore guttulae as well as the gonidia or cells forming the soredia.

Hornschuch[538] of Greifswald described the propagation of the lower lichens as being solely by means of a germinating “powder”; the more highly organized forms were provided with receptacles or apothecia containing spores which he considered as analogous to flowers rather than to fruits. The important contributions to Lichenology of Wallroth[539] and Meyer[540] close this period of uncertainty: the former deals almost exclusively with the form and character of the vegetative thallus and the function of the “reproductive gonidia.” Meyer, a less prolix writer, very clearly states that the method of reproduction is twofold: by spores produced in fruits, or by the germinating granules of the soredia.

B. FORMS OF REPRODUCTIVE ORGANS

From the time of Tournefort, considerable attention had been given to the various forms of _scutellae_, _tuberculae_, etc., as characters of diagnostic importance. Sprengel[541] grouped these bodies finally into nine different types with appropriate names which have now been mostly superseded by the comprehensive terms, apothecia and perithecia. A general classification on the lines of fruit development was established by Luyken[542], who, following Persoon’s[543] classification of fungi, and thus recognizing their affinity, summed up all known lichens as _Gymnocarpeae_ with open fruits, and _Angiocarpeae_ with closed fruits.

_a._ APOTHECIA. As in discomycetous fungi, the lichen apothecium is in the form of an open concave or convex disc, but generally of rather small size, rarely more than 1 cm. in diameter (Fig. 88); there is no development in lichen fruits equal to the cup-like ascomata of the larger _Pezizae_. In most cases the lichen apothecium retains its vitality as a spore-bearing organ for a considerable period, sometimes for several years, and it is strengthened and protected by one or more external margins of sterile tissue. Immediately surrounding the fertile disc there is a compact wall of interwoven hyphae. In some of the shorter-lived soft fruits, as in _Biatora_, this hyphal margin may be thin, and may gradually be pushed aside as the disc develops and becomes convex, but generally it forms a prominent rim round the disc and may be tough or even horny, and often hard and carbonaceous. This wall, which is present, to some extent, in nearly all lichens, is described as the “proper margin.” A second “thalline margin” containing gonidia is present in many genera[544]: it is a structure peculiar to the lichen apothecium and forms the _amphithecium_.

At the base of the apothecium there is a weft of light- or dark-coloured hyphae called the _hypothecium_, which is continued up and round the sides as the _parathecium_ merging into the “proper margin.” It forms the lining of a cup-shaped hollow which is filled by the paraphyses, which are upright closely packed thread-like hyphae, and by the spore-containing asci or _thecae_, these together constituting the thecium or hymenium. The paraphyses are very numerous as compared with the asci; they are simple or branched, frequently septate, especially towards the apex, and mostly slender, varying in width from 1-4µ, though Hue describes paraphyses in _Aspicilia atroviolacea_ as 8-12µ thick. They may be thread-like throughout their length, or they may widen towards the tips which are not infrequently coloured. Small apical cells are often abstricted and lie loose on the epithecium, giving at times a pruinose or powdered character to the disc. In some genera there is a profuse branching of the paraphyses to form a dense protective epithecium over the surface of the hymenium as in the genus _Arthonia_.

The apothecia may be sessile and closely adnate to or even sunk in the thallus, or they may be shortly stalked. The thalline margin shares generally the characters of the thallus; the disc is mostly of a firm consistency and is light or dark in colour according to genus or species; most frequently it is some shade of brown. Marginate apothecia, _i.e._ those with a thalline margin, are often referred to as “lecanorine,” that being a distinctive feature of the genus _Lecanora_. In the immarginate series, with a proper margin only, the texture may be soft and waxy, termed “biatorine” as in _Biatora_; or hard and carbonaceous as in the genus _Lecidea_, and is then described as “lecideine.”

In the subseries Graphidineae, the apothecium has the form of a very flat, roundish or irregular body entirely without a margin, called an “ardella” as in _Arthonia_; or more generally it is an elongate narrow “lirella,” in which the disc is a mere slit between two dark-coloured proper margins. The hypothecium of the lirellae is sometimes much reduced and in that case the hymenium rests directly on a thin layer above the thalline tissue as in _Graphis elegans_ (Fig. 89).

Lichen fruits require abundant light, and plants growing in the shade are mostly sterile. Naturally, therefore, the reproductive bodies are to be found on the best illuminated parts of the thallus. In crustaceous and in most foliose forms, they are variously situated on the upper surface, wherever the light falls most directly. In the genera _Nephromium_ and _Nephromopsis_, on the contrary, they arise on the under surface, though at the extreme margin, but as the fertile lobes eventually turn upwards the apothecia as they mature become fully exposed. In shrubby or fruticose lichens their position is lateral on the fronds, or more frequently at or near the tips.

_b._ PERITHECIA. The small closed perithecium is characteristic of the Pyrenocarpeae which correspond with the Pyrenomycetes among fungi. It is partially or entirely immersed in the thallus or in the substratum on which the lichen grows, and is either a globose or conical body wholly surrounded by a hyphal wall, when it is described as “entire” (Fig. 90), or it is somewhat hemispherical in form and the outer wall is developed only on the upper exposed part: a type of perithecium usually designated by the term “dimidiate.” As the perithecial wall gives sufficient protection to the asci, the paraphyses are of less importance and are frequently very sparingly produced, or they may even be dissolved and used up at an early stage. The thallus of the Pyrenocarpeae is often extremely reduced, and the perithecia are then the only visible portion of the lichen.

A few lichens among Graphidineae and Pyrenocarpeae grow in a united body generally looked on as a stroma; but Wainio[545] has demonstrated that as the fruiting bodies give rise to this structure by agglomeration—by the cohesion of their margins—it can only be regarded as a pseudostroma. Two British genera of Pyrenolichens, _Mycoporum_ and _Mycoporellum_, exhibit this pseudo-stromatoid formation.

C. DEVELOPMENT OF REPRODUCTIVE ORGANS

As most known lichens belong to the Ascolichens, the study of development has been concentrated on that group. Tulasne[546] was the first to make a microscopic study of lichen tissues and he described in considerable detail the general anatomical structure of apothecia and perithecia. Later, Fuisting[547] traced the development of a number of perithecia through their different stages of growth, but his most interesting discovery was made in _Lecidea fumosa_, a crustaceous Discolichen with an areolate thallus in which the apothecia are seated on the fungal hyphae between the areolae. In the very early stages represented by a complex of slender hyphae, he observed an unbranched septate filament with short cuboid cells, richer in contents than the surrounding filaments and somewhat similar to the structure known to mycologists as “Woronin’s hypha,” which is an ascogonial structure. These specialized cells disappeared as the hymenium began to form.

1. DISCOLICHENS

_a._ CARPOGONIA OF GELATINOUS LICHENS. Stahl’s[548] work on various Collemaceae followed on the same lines as that of Fuisting. The first species selected by him for examination, _Collema_ (_Leptogium_) _microphyllum_’ is a gelatinous lichen which grows on old trunks of poplars and willows. It has a small olive-green thallus which, in autumn, is crowded with apothecia; the spermogones or pycnidia appear as minute reddish points on the edge of the thallus. Within the thallus, and midway between the upper and lower surface, there arises, as a branch from a vegetative hypha, a many-septate filament coiled in spiral form at the base, with the free end growing upwards and projecting a short distance above the surface and occasionally forked (Fig. 91). The tip-cell is slightly swollen and covered with a mucilaginous coat continuous with the mucilage of the thallus. The whole structure, characterized by the larger size and by the richer contents of its cells, was regarded by Stahl as a carpogonium, the coiled base representing the ascogonium, the upright hypha functioning as the receptive organ or trichogyne, comparable to that of the Florideae. The spermatia, which mature at this early stage of carpogonial development, are expelled from a neighbouring spermogonium on the addition of moisture and easily reach the protruding trichogyne. They adhere to the mucilaginous wall of the end-cell, and, in two or three instances, Stahl found that copulation had taken place. As the affixed spermatium was empty, he concluded that the contents had passed over into the trichogyne, and that the nucleus had travelled down to the ascogonium. Certain degenerative changes that followed seemed to confirm the view that there had been fertilization: the cells of the trichogyne had lost their turgidity and at the same time the cross-walls had swollen considerably and stood out like knots in the hypha (Fig. 92). The ascogonial cells had also increased not only in size but in number by intercalary division, so that the spiral arrangement became obscured. Ascogenous hyphae arose from the ascogonial cells, and asci cut off by a basal septum were finally formed from these hyphae. Lateral branches from below the septum also formed asci.

Stahl’s observations were repeated and extended by Borzi[549] on another of the Collemaceae, _Collema nigrescens_. In that plant the foliaceous thallus is of thin texture and has a distinct cellular cortex. The carpogonia were found at varying depths near to the cortical region; the ascogonium, of two and a half to four spirals, consisted of ten to fifteen cells with very thin walls, the trichogyne of five to ten cells, the terminal cell projecting above the thallus. Borzi also found spermatia fused with the tip-cell.

A further important contribution was made by Baur[550] in his study of _Collema crispum_[551]. There occur in nature two forms of this lichen, one of them crowded with apothecia and spermogonia, the other with a more luxuriant thallus, but with few apothecia and no spermogonia. On the latter almost sterile form Baur found in spring and again in autumn immense numbers of carpogonia—about one thousand in a medium sized thallus—which nearly all gradually lost the characteristics of reproductive organs, and, anastomising with other hyphae, became part of the vegetative system. In a few cases in which, presumably, a spermatium had fused with a trichogyne, very large apothecia had developed.

As the first-mentioned form was always crowded with apothecia in every stage of development, as well as with carpogonia and spermogonia, it seemed natural to conclude that the difference was entirely due to the presence or absence of spermatia in sufficient numbers to ensure fertilization. The period during which copulation is possible passes very rapidly, though subsequent development is slow, occupying about half-a-year from the time of fertilization to the formation of the first ascus.

Baur confirmed Stahl’s observations on the various developmental changes. In several instances he found a spermatium fused with the trichogyne, though he could not see continuity between the lumina of the fusing cells. After copulation with the spermatium the trichogyne nucleus, which occupied the lower third of the terminal cell, had disappeared, and the plasma contents had acquired a deeper tint; the other trichogyne cells, which had also lost their nuclei, were partly collapsed owing to the pressure of the surrounding tissue, and openings were plainly visible through some of the swollen septa, especially of the lower cells. In addition the ascogonial cells, all of which were uninucleate, had increased in number by intercalary division. Plasma connections were opened from cell to cell, but only in the primary septa, the later formed cell-membranes being continuous. Ascogenous hyphae had branched out from the ascogonium as a series of uninucleate cell rows from which the asci finally arose.

Baur’s interpretation was that the first cell of the ascogonium reached by the male nucleus after its passage down through the cells of the trichogyne represented the egg-cell, and that, after fusion, the resultant nucleus divided, and a daughter nucleus passed on to the other auxiliary-cells. No male nucleus nor fusion of nuclei was, however, observed by him, and his deductions rest on conjecture.

Krabbe[552] and after him Mäule[553] found in _Collema pulposum_ reproductive organs similar to those described by Stahl, but in a recent paper on an American form of that species a peculiar condition has been described by Freda Bachmann[554]. She[555] found that the spermatia originated, not in spermogonia, but as groups of cells budded off from vegetative hyphae within the tissue of the lichen and occupying the same position as spermogonia, _i.e._ the region close below the upper surface. The trichogynes, therefore, never emerged into the open, but travelled towards these internal spermatia, and fusion with them was effected. The changes that afterwards took place in the carpogonial cells were similar to those that had been recognized by Stahl and Baur as consequent on fertilization.

Additional cytological details have been published in a subsequent paper[556]: after fusion with the spermatium the terminal cell of the trichogyne collapsed, its nucleus became disintegrated and the cross septa of the lower trichogyne cells became perforated, these perforations being closed again at a later stage by a gelatinous plug. The nuclear history is more doubtful: the disappearance of the nuclei from the spermatium and from the terminal cell of the trichogyne was noted; two nuclei were seen to be present in the penultimate cell, and these the author interpreted as division products of the original cell nucleus. In the same cell, lying close against the lower septum and partly within the opening, there was a mass of chromatin material which might be the male nucleus migrating downwards. The next point of interest was observed in the twelfth cell from the tip in which there were two nuclei, a larger and a smaller, the latter judged to be the male cell, the small size being due to probable division of the spermatium nucleus either before or after leaving the spermatium. It is stated however that the spermatium was always uninucleate. Meanwhile the cells of the ascogonium had increased in size, the perforations of the septa between the cells became more evident, and their nuclei persisted. In one cell at this stage two nuclei were present, one of the two presumably a male nucleus; no fusion of nuclei was observed in the ascogonial cells. Later the cross walls between the cells were seen to have disappeared more completely and migration of nuclei had taken place, so that some of the cells appeared to be empty while others were multinucleate. Considerable multiplication of the nuclei occurred before the ascogenous hyphae were formed: twelve nuclei were observed in a part of the ascogonium which was just beginning to give off a branch. Several branches might arise from one cell, and their cells were either uni- or binucleate, the nuclei being larger than those of the vegetative hyphae. The formation of the asci was not distinctly seen, but young binucleate asci were not uncommon. The fusion of the two nuclei was followed by the enlargement of the ascus and the subsequent nuclear division for spore formation. In the first heterotypic division twelve chromosomes, double the number observed in the vegetative nucleus, were counted on the equatorial plate. In the third division they were reduced to the normal number of six, from which F. Bachmann concludes that a twofold fusion must have taken place—in the ascogonium and again in the ascus.

Spiral or coiled ascogonia were observed by Wainio[557] in the gelatinous crustaceous genus _Pyrenopsis_, but the trichogynes did not reach the surface. In _Lichina_[558], a maritime gelatinous lichen where the carpogonia occur in groups, trichogynes have not been demonstrated.

A peculiarity of some gelatinous lichens noted by Stahl[559] and others in species of _Physma_, and by Forssell[560] in _Pyrenopsis_ and _Psorotichia_, is the development of carpogonia at the base of, and within the perithecial walls of old spermogonia. No special significance is however attached to this phenomenon, and it is interesting to note that a similar growth was observed by Zukal[561] in a pyrenomycetous fungus, _Pleospora collematum_, a harmless parasite on _Physma compactum_ and other Collemaceae. The structures invaded were true pycnidia of the fungus as the minute spores were seen to germinate. A “Woronin’s hypha” at the base of several of these pycnidia developed asci which pushed up among the spent sporophores.

_b._ CARPOGONIA OF NON-GELATINOUS LICHENS. The soft loose tissue of the gelatinous lichens is more favourable for the minute study of apothecial development than the closely interwoven hyphae of non-gelatinous forms, but Borzi[562] had already extended the study to species of _Parmelia_, _Anaptychia_, _Sticta_, _Ricasolia_ and _Lecanora_, and in all of them he succeeded in establishing the presence of ascogonia and trichogynes. After him a constant succession of students have worked at the problem of reproduction in lichens.

Lindau[563] published results of the examination of a considerable series of lichens. In _Anaptychia_ (_Physcia_) _ciliaris_, _Physcia stellaris_, _Ph. pulverulenta_, _Ramalina fraxinea_, _Placodium_ (_Lecanora_) _saxicolum_, _Lecanora subfusca_ and _Lecidea enteroleuca_ he demonstrated the presence of ascogonia with trichogynes. In _Parmelia tiliacea_ and in _Xanthoria parietina_ he found ascogonia but failed to see trichogynes. In none of the species examined by him did he observe any fusion between the trichogyne and a spermatium.

In _Anaptychia ciliaris_ he was able to pick out extremely early stages by staining with a solution of chlor-zinc-iodine. Mäule[564] applied the same test to _Physcia pulverulenta_, but found that to be successful the reaction required some time. Certain cells of the hyphae—mostly terminal cells—in the lower area of the gonidial zone and even occasionally in the pith (according to Lindau) coloured a deep brown, while the ordinary thalline hyphae were tinted yellow. He assumed that these were initial ascogonial cells on account of the richer plasma contents, and also because of the somewhat larger size of the cells. In the same region of the thallus young carpogonia were observed as outgrowths from vegetative hyphae, though the trichogynes had not yet reached the surface.

At a more advanced stage the carpogonia were seen to be embedded in the gonidial zone and occurred in groups. The cells of the ascogonium, easily recognized by the darker stain, were short and stout, measuring about 6-8µ in length and 4·4µ in width. They were arranged in somewhat indistinct spirals; but the crowding of the groups resulted in a confused intermingling of the various generative filaments. The trichogynes composed of longer narrower cells rose above the hyphae of the cortex; they also stained a deep brown and the projecting cell was always thin-walled. Lindau frequently observed spermatia very firmly attached to the trichogyne cell but without any plasma connection between the two. The changes in the trichogyne described by Stahl and Baur in Collemaceae were not seen in _Anaptychia_; the peculiar swelling of the septa seems to be a phenomenon confined to gelatinous lichens. During the trichogyne stage in this lichen the vegetative hyphae from the medulla grow up and surround the young carpogonia, and, at the same time, very slender hyphae begin to branch upwards to form the paraphyses. Darbishire’s[565] examination of _Physcia pulverulenta_ demonstrated the presence of the coiled ascogonium and the trichogyne in that species (Fig. 93).

Baur[566] has also given the results of an examination of _Anaptychia_. He frequently observed copulation between the spermatium and the tip of the trichogyne, but not any passage of nucleus or contents. After copulation the ascogonial cells increased in size and became irregular in form, and open communication was established between them (Fig. 94). There was no increase in their number by intercalary division as in _Collema_. After producing ascogenous hyphae the cells were seen to have lost their contents and then to have gradually disappeared. The fertile hyphae, which now took a blue colouration with chlor-zinc-iodine, gradually spread out and formed a wide-stretching hymenium. Several carpogonia took part in the formation of one apothecium.

The tissue below the ascogonium meanwhile developed vigorously, forming a weft of encircling hyphae, while the upper branches grew vertically towards the cortex. Gonidia in contact with the developing fruit also increased, and, with the hyphae, formed the exciple or thalline margin. The growth upward of the paraphyses raises the overlying cortex which in _Anaptychia_ is “fibrous”; it gradually dies off and allows the exposure of the disc, though small shreds of dead tissue are frequently left. In species such as those of _Xanthoria_ where the cortex is of vertical cell-rows, the apothecial hyphae simply push their way between the cell-rows and so through to the open.

Baur found the development of the apothecium somewhat similar in the crustaceous corticolous lichen, _Lecanora subfusca_. After a long period of sterile growth, spermogonia appeared in great abundance, and, a little later, carpogonia in groups of five to ten; the trichogynes emerged very slightly above the cortex; they were now branched. The ascogonia were frequently a confused clump of cells, though sometimes they showed distinct spirals. The surrounding hyphae had taken a vertical direction towards the cortex at a still earlier stage, and the brown tips were visible on the exterior before the trichogynes were formed. The whole growth was extremely slow.

In _Physcia stellaris_ the carpogonia occurred in groups also, though Lindau[567] thinks that, unlike _Anaptychia_ (_Physcia_) _ciliaris_, only one is left to form the fruit. Only one, according to Darbishire[568], entered into the apothecium in the allied species, _Physcia pulverulenta_. In the latter plasma connections were visible from cell to cell of the trichogyne, and, after copulation with the spermatium, the ascogonial cells increased in size—though not in number—and the plasma connections between them became so wide that the ascogonium had the appearance of an almost continuous multinucleate cell or coenogamete[569]. As in gelatinous lichens, each of these cells gave rise to ascogenous hyphae.

_c._ GENERAL SUMMARY. The main features of development described above recur in most of the species that have been examined.

(1) The carpogonia arise in a complex of hyphae situated on the under side of, or immediately below the gonidial zone. Usually they vary in number from five to twenty for each apothecium, though as many as seventy-two have been computed for _Icmadophila ericetorum_[570], and Wainio[571] describes them as so numerous in _Coccocarpia pellita_ var., that their trichogynes covered some of the young apothecia with a hairy pile perceptible with a hand lens, though at the same time other apothecia on the same specimens were absolutely smooth.

(2) The trichogynes, when present, travel up through the gonidial and cortical regions of the thallus; Darbishire[572] observes that in _Physcia pulverulenta_, they may diverge to the side to secure an easier course between the groups of algae. They emerge above the surface to a distance of about 15µ or less; after an interval they collapse and disappear. Their cells, which are longer and narrower than those of the ascogonium, are uninucleate and vary in number according to species or to individual lichens. Baur[573] thought that possibly several trichogynes in succession might arise from one ascogonium.

(3) How many carpogonia share in the development of the apothecium is still a debated question. In _Collema_ only one is functional. Baur[574] was unable to decide if one or more were fertilized in _Parmelia acetabulum_, and in _Usnea_ Nienburg[575] found that, out of several, one alone survived (Fig. 95). But in _Anaptychia ciliaris_ and in _Lecanora subfusca_ Baur[574] considers it proved that several share in the formation of the apothecium. In this connection it is interesting to note that, according to Harper[576] and others, several ascogonia enter into one _Pyronema_ fruit.

(4) The ascogonial cells, before and after fertilization, are distinguished from the surrounding hyphae by a reaction to various stains, which is different from that of the vegetative hyphae, and also by the shortness and width of their cells. The whole of the apothecial primordium is generally recognizable by the clear shining appearance of the cells.

(5) The ascogonia do not always form a distinct spiral; frequently they lie in irregular groups. Each cell is uninucleate and may ultimately produce ascogenous hyphae, though in _Anaptychia_ Baur[574] noted that some of the cells failed to develop.

(6) The hyphae from the ascogonial cells spread out in a complex layer at the base of the hymenium, and send up branches which form the asci, either, as in most Ascomycetes, from the penultimate cell of the fertile branch, or from the last cell, as in _Sphyridium_ (_Baeomyces rufus_)[575] and in _Baeomyces roseus_. The same variation has been observed in fungi—in a species of _Peziza_[577], in which it is the end-cell of the branch that becomes the mother-cell of the ascus; but this deviation from the normal is evidently of rare occurrence either in lichens or fungi.

_d._ HYPOTHECIUM AND PARAPHYSES. The hypothecium is the layer of hyphae that subtends the hymenium, and is formed from the complex of hyphae that envelope the first stages of the carpogonia. It is vegetative in origin and distinct from the generative system.

In lichens belonging to the Collemaceae, the paraphyses rise from the branching of the carpogonial stalk-cell immediately below the ascogonium[578], but have no plasma connection with it. They are thus comparable in origin with the paraphyses of many Discomycetes.

In several genera in which the algal constituents are blue-green, such as _Stictina_, _Pannaria_, _Nephroma_, _Ricasolia_ and _Peltigera_, Sturgis[579] found that reproduction was apogamous and also that asci and paraphyses originated from the same cell-system: a tuft of paraphyses arose from the basal cell of the ascus, or an ascus from the basal cell of a paraphysis. These results are at variance with those of most other workers, but the figures drawn by Sturgis seem to be clear and convincing.

Again in _Usnea barbata_, as described by Nienburg[580], the ascogonial cells, after the disappearance of the trichogyne, branch profusely not only upwards towards the cortex but also downwards and to each side. The upward branches give rise normally to the asci, the lower branches produce the subhymenium and later the paraphyses, and the two systems are thus genetically connected, though they remain distinct from each other, and asci are never formed from the lower cells.

In most heteromerous lichens, however, the origin of the paraphyses is exclusively vegetative: they arise as branches from the primordial complex that forms the covering hyphae of the ascogonium both above and below. Schwendener[581] had already pointed out the difference in origin between the two constituents of the hymenium in one of his earlier studies on the development of the apothecium, and this view has been repeatedly confirmed by recent workers, except by Wahlberg[582] who has insisted that they rise from the same cells as the asci, a statement disproved by Baur[583]. The paraphyses originate not only from the covering hyphae, but from vegetative cells in close connection with the primordium. In this mode of development, lichens diverge from fungi, but even in these a vegetative origin for the paraphyses has been pointed out in _Lachnea scutellata_[584] where they branch from the hyphae lying round the ascogonium.

There is no general rule for the order of development. In _Lecanora subfusca_ Baur[583] found that vertical filaments had reached the surface by the time the trichogyne was formed, and their pointed brown tips gave a ready clue to the position of the carpogonia. In _Lecidea enteroleuca_[585] they show their characteristic form and arrangement before there is any trace of ascus formation. In _Solorina_[585] they are well formed before the ascogenous hyphae appear. In other lichens such as _Placodium saxicolum_[586], _Peltigera rufescens_[587] and _P. malacea_[587] the two systems—paraphyses and ascogonium—grow simultaneously, though in _P. horizontalis_ the ascogonium has disappeared by the time the paraphyses are formed. In the genus _Nephroma_, in _Physcia stellaris_ and in _Xanthorina parietina_ the paraphyses are also late in making their appearance.

In most instances, the paraphyses push their way up between the cortical cells which gradually become absorbed, or they may stop short of the surface as in _Nephromium tomentosum_[587]. The overlying layer of cortical cells in that case dies off gradually and in time disappears. Such an apothecium is said to be “at first veiled.” Later formed paraphyses at the circumference of the apothecium form the parathecium, which is thus continuous with the hypothecium.

_e._ VARIATIONS IN APOTHECIAL DEVELOPMENT. Lichens are among the least stereotyped of plants: instances of variation have been noted in several genera.

_aa._ _PARMELIAE._ A somewhat complicated course of development has been traced by Baur[588] in _Parmelia acetabulum_. In that lichen the group of three to six carpogonia do not lie free in the gonidial tissue, but originate nearer the surface (Fig. 96) and are surrounded from the first by a tissue connected with, and resembling the tissue of the cortex. In the several ascogonia, there are more cells and more spirals than in _Collema_ or in _Physcia_, and all of them are somewhat confusedly intertwined. The trichogynes are composed of three to five cells and project 10 to 15µ above the surface. When further development begins, the ascogonial cells branch out and form a primary darker layer or hypothecium above which extends the subhymenium, a light-coloured band of loosely woven hyphae. Branches from the ascogonial hyphae at a later stage push their way up through this tissue and form above it a second plexus of hyphae—the base of the hymenium. Baur considers this a very advanced type of apothecium; he found it also present in _Parmelia saxatilis_, though, in that species, the further growth of the first ascogonial layer was more rapid and the secondary plexus and hymenium were formed earlier in the life of the apothecium. He has also stated that a similar development occurs in other genera such as _Usnea_, though Nienburg’s[589] work scarcely confirms that view.

In the brown _Parmeliae_, Rosendahl[590] found the same series of apothecial tissues, but he interprets the course of development somewhat differently: the basal dark layer or hypothecium he found to be of purely vegetative origin; above it extended the lighter-coloured subhymenium; the ascogenous hyphae were present only in the second layer of dark tissue immediately under the hymenium.

In most lichens the primordium of the apothecium arises towards the lower side of the gonidial zone, the hyphae of which retain the meristematic character. In _Parmeliae_, as was noted by Lindau[591] in _P. tiliacea_, and by Baur[592] and Rosendahl[590] in other species, the carpogonial groups are formed above the gonidial zone, either immediately below the cortex as in _P. glabratula_, or in a swelling of the cortex itself as in _P. aspidota_, in which species the external enlargement is visible by the time the trichogynes reach the surface. In _P. glabra_, with a development entirely similar to that of _P. aspidota_, no trichogynes were seen at any stage. The position of the primordium close under the cortex is also a feature of _Ramalina fraxinea_ as described by G. Wolff[593]. The trichogynes in that species are fairly numerous.

A further peculiarity in _Parmelia acetabulum_ attracted Baur’s[592] attention. Carpogonia with trichogynes are extremely numerous in that species as are the spermogonia, the open pores of which are to be found everywhere between the trichogynes, and yet fertilization can occur but rarely, as disintegrating carpogonia are abundant and very few apothecia are formed. Baur makes the suggestion that possibly cross-fertilization may be necessary, or that the spermatia, in this instance, do not fertilize and that development must therefore be apogamous, in which case the small number of fruits formed is due to some unknown cause. Fünfstück[594] thought that degeneration of the carpogonia had not gone so far, but that a few had acquired the power to develop apogamously. In _Parmelia saxatilis_ only a small percentage of carpogonia attain to apothecia, although spermogonia are abundant and in close proximity, but in that species, unlike _P. acetabulum_, a large number reach the earlier stages of fruit formation; the more vigorous apothecia seem to inhibit the growth of those that lag behind.

_bb._ _PERTUSARIAE._ In _Pertusaria_, the apothecial primordium is situated immediately below the gonidial zone; the cells have a somewhat larger lumen and thinner walls than those of the vegetative hyphae. In the ascogonium there are more cells than in _Parmelia acetabulum_; the trichogynes are short-lived, and several carpogonia probably enter into the formation of each apothecium; the paraphyses arise from the covering hyphae. So far the course of development presents nothing unusual. The peculiar pertusarian feature as described by Krabbe[595], and after him by Baur[596], does not appear till a later stage. By continual growth in thickness of the overlying thallus, the apothecia gradually become submerged and tend to degenerate; meanwhile, however, a branch from the ascogonial hyphae at the base of the hymenium pushes up along one side and forms a secondary ascogonial cell-plexus over the top of the first-formed disc. A new apothecium thus arises and remains sporiferous until it also comes to lie in too deep a position, when the process is repeated. Sometimes the regenerating hypha travels to the right or left away from the original apothecium, it may be to a distance of 2 mm. or according to Fünfstück even considerably farther. Fünfstück[597] has gathered indeed from his own investigations that such cases of regeneration are by no means rare: ascogenous hyphae, several centimetres long, destined to give rise to new apothecia are not unusual, and their activity can be recognized macroscopically by the linear arrangement of the apothecia in such lichens as _Rhizocarpon_ (_petraeum_) _concentricum_ (Fig. 97).

In _Variolaria_, a genus closely allied to or generally included in _Pertusaria_, Darbishire[598] has described the primordial tissue as taking rise almost at the base of the crustaceous thallus: strands of delicate hyphae, staining blue with iodine, mount upwards from that region through the medulla and gonidial zone[599]. The ascogonium does not appear till the surface is almost reached.

_cc._ _GRAPHIDEAE._ Several members of the Graphidaceae were studied by G. Wolff[600]: she demonstrated the presence of carpogonia with emerging trichogynes in _Graphis elegans_, a species which is distinguished by the deeply furrowed margins of the lirellae (Fig. 89). Before the carpogonia appeared it was possible to distinguish the cushion-like primordial tissue of the apothecium in the thallus which is almost wholly immersed in the periderm layers of the bark on which it grows. The trichogynes were very sparingly septate, and a rather large nucleus occupied a position near the tip of the terminal cell. The dark carbonaceous outer wall makes its appearance in this species at an early stage of development along the sides of the lirellae, but never below, as there is always a layer of living cells at the base. After the first-formed hymenium is exhausted, these basal cells develop a new apothecium with a new carbonaceous wall that pushes back the first-formed, leaving a cleft between the old and the new. This regenerating process, somewhat analogous to the formation of new apothecia in _Pertusaria_, may be repeated in _Graphis elegans_ as many as five times, the traces of the older discs being clearly seen in the channelled margins of the lirellae.

_dd._ _CLADONIAE._ The chief points of interest in the _Cladoniae_ are the position of the apothecial primordia and the function of the podetium, which are discussed later[601]. Krabbe[602] determined not only the endogenous origin of the podetium but also the appearance of fertile cells in the primordium (Fig. 98). Both frequently take rise where a crack occurs in the cortex of the primary squamule, the cells of the gonidial tissue being especially active at these somewhat exposed places. The fertile hyphae elongate and branch within the stalk of the developing podetium, sometimes very early, or not until there is a pause in growth, when carpogonia are formed. As a rule trichogynes emerge in great numbers[600], generally close to, or rather below, the spermogonia. In _Cl. pyxidata_[603] the carpogonia are characterized by the large diameter of the cells—three to five times that of the vegetative hyphae. Though most of the trichogynes disappear at an early stage, some of them may persist for a considerable period. As development proceeds, the vegetative hyphae interspersed among the ascogonial cells grow upwards, slender branches push up between them and gradually a compact sheath of paraphyses is built up. The ascogenous hyphae meanwhile spread radially at the base of the paraphyses and the asci begin to form. The apothecia may be further enlarged by intercalary growth, and this vigorous development of vegetative tissue immediately underneath raises the whole fruit structure well above the surface level.

Sättler[604] in his paper on _Cladoniae_[605] cites as an argument in favour of fertilization the relative positions of carpogonia and spermogonia on the podetia. The carpogonia with their emerging trichogynes being situated rather below the spermogonia. Both organs, he states, have been demonstrated in eleven species; he himself observed them in the primordial podetia of _Cladonia botrytes_ and of _Cl. Floerkeana_.

2. PYRENOLICHENS

_a._ DEVELOPMENT OF THE PERITHECIUM. It is to Fuisting[606] that we owe the first account of development in the lichen perithecium. Though he failed to see the earlier stages (in _Verrucaria Dufourii_), he recognized the primordial complex of hyphae in the gonidial zone of the thallus, from which originated a vertical strand of hyphae destined to form the tubular neck of the perithecium. Growth in the lower part is in abeyance for a time, and it is only after the neck is formed, and the fruiting body is widened by the ingrowth of external hyphae, that the asci begin to branch up from the tissue at the base.

_b._ FORMATION OF CARPOGONIA. Stahl[607] had indicated that not only in gymnocarpous but also in angiocarpous lichens, it would be found that carpogonia were formed as in _Collema_. Baur[608] justified this surmise, and demonstrated the presence of ascogonia in groups of three to eight, with trichogynes that reached the surface in _Endocarpon_ (_Dermatocarpon_) _miniatum_ (Fig. 99). It is one of the few foliaceous Pyrenolichens, and the leathery thallus is attached to the substratum by a central point, thus allowing in the thallus not only peripheral but also intercalary growth, the latter specially active round the point of basal attachment; carpogonia may be found in any region where the tissue is newly formed, and at any season. The upper cortex is composed of short-celled thick-walled hyphae, with branching vertical to the surface, and so closely packed that there is an appearance of plectenchyma; the medullary hyphae are also thick-walled but with longer cells. The carpogonia of this species arise as a branch from the vegetative hyphae and are without special covering hyphae, so frequent a feature in other lichens. The trichogynes bore their way through the compact cortex and rise well above the surface. After they have disappeared—presumably after fertilization—the vegetative hyphae round and between the ascogonia become active and travel upwards slightly converging to a central point. The asci begin to grow out from the ascogenous hyphae of the base before the vertical filaments have quite pierced the cortex.

_Pyrenula nitida_ has also been studied by Baur[609]. It is a very common species on smooth bark, with a thin crustaceous thallus immersed among the outer periderm cells. Unlike most other lichens, it forms carpogonia in spring only, from February to April. A primordial coil of hyphae lies at the base of the gonidial layer, and, before there is any appearance of carpogonia, a thick strand of hyphae is seen to be directed upwards, so that a definite form and direction is given to the perithecium at a very early stage. The ascogonial cells which are differentiated are extremely small, and, like those of all other species examined, are uninucleate. There are five to ten carpogonia in each primordium; the trichogynes grow up through the hyphal strand and emerge 5-10 µ above the surface. After their disappearance, a weft of ascogenous tissue is formed at the base, and, at the same time, the surrounding vegetative tissue takes part in the building up of a plectenchymatous wall of minute dark-coloured cells. Further development is rapid and occupies probably only a few weeks.

In many of the pyrenocarpous lichens—_Verrucariae_ and others—the walls of the paraphyses dissolve in mucilage as the spores become mature, a character associated with spore ejection and dispersal. In some genera and species, as in _Pyrenula_, they remain intact.

D. APOGAMOUS REPRODUCTION

Though fertilization by an externally produced male nucleus has not been definitely proved there is probability that, in some instances, the fruit may be the product of sexual fusion. There are however a number of genera and species in which the development is apogamous so far as any external copulation is possible and the sporiferous tissue seems to be a purely vegetative product up to the stage of ascus formation.

In _Phlyctis agelaea_ Krabbe[610] found abundant apothecia developing normally and not accompanied by spermogonia; in _Phialopsis rubra_ studied also by him the primordium arises among the cells of the periderm on which the lichen grows, and he failed to find any trace of a sexual act. In his elaborate study of Gloeolichens Forssell[611] established the presence of carpogonia with trichogynes in two species—_Pyrenopsis phaeococca_ and _P. impolita_, but without any appearance of fertilization; in all the others examined, the origin of the fruit was vegetative. Wainio[612] records a similar observation in a species of _Pyrenopsis_ in which there was formed a spiral ascogonium and a trichogyne, but the latter never reached the surface.

Neubner[613] claimed to have proved a vegetative origin for the asci in the Caliciaceae; but he overlooked the presence of spermogonia and his conclusions are doubtful.

Fünfstück[614] found apogamous development in _Peltigera_ (including _Peltidea_) and his results have never been disputed. The ascogonial cells are surrounded at an early stage by a weft of vegetative hyphae. No trichogynes are formed and spermogonia are absent or very rare in the genus, though pycnidia with macrospores occur occasionally.

Some recent work by Darbishire[615] on the genus supplies additional details. The apothecial primordium always originated near the growing margin of the thallus, where certain medullary hyphae were seen to swell up and stain more deeply than others. These at first were uninucleate, but the nuclei increased by division as the cells became larger, and in time there was formed a mass of closely interwoven cells full of cytoplasm. “No coiled carpogonia can be made out, but these darkly stained cells form part of a connected system of branching hyphae coming from the medulla further back.” Long unbranched multi-septate hyphae—evidently functionless trichogynes—travelled towards the cortex but gradually died off. Certain of the larger cells—the “ascogonia”—grew out as ascogenous hyphae into which the nuclei passed in pairs and finally gave rise to the asci.

These results tally well with those obtained by M. and Mme Moreau[616], though they make no mention of any trichogyne. They found that the terminal cells of the ascogenous hyphae were transformed into asci, and the two nuclei in these cells fused—the only fusion that took place. In _Nephromium_, one of the same family, the case for apogamy is not so clear; but Fünfstück found no trichogynes, and though spermogonia were present on the thallus, they were always somewhat imperfectly developed.

Sturgis[617] supplemented these results in his study of other lichens containing blue-green algae. In species of _Heppia_, _Pannaria_, _Hydrothyria_, _Stictina_ and _Ricasolia_, he failed to find any evidence of fertilization by spermatia.

_Solorina_, also a member of Peltigeraceae, was added to the list of apogamous genera by Metzger[618] and his work was confirmed and amplified by Baur[619]: certain hyphae of the gonidial zone branch out into larger ascogonial cells which increase by active intercalary growth, by division and by branching, and so gradually give rise to the ascogenous hyphae and finally to the asci. Baur looked on this and other similar formations as instances of degeneration from the normal carpogonial type of development. Moreau[620] (Fernand and Mme) have also examined _Solorina_ with much the same results: the paraphyses rise first from cells that have been produced by the gonidial hyphae; later, ascogenous hyphae are formed and spread horizontally at the base of the paraphyses, finally giving rise at their tips to the asci. Metzger[618] had further discovered that spermogonia were absent and trichogynes undeveloped in two very different crustaceous lichens, _Acarospora_ (_Lecanora_) _glaucocarpa_ and _Verrucaria calciseda_, the latter a pyrenocarpous species and, as the name implies, found only on limestone.

Krabbe[621] had noted the absence of any fertilization process in _Gyrophora vellea_. At a later date, _Gyrophora cylindrica_ was made the subject of exact research by Lindau[622]. In that species the spermogonia (or pycnidia) are situated on the outer edge of the thallus lobes; a few millimetres nearer the centre appear the primordia of the apothecia, at first without any external indication of their presence. The initial coil which arises on the lower side of the gonidial zone consists of thickly wefted hyphae with short cells, slightly thicker than those of the thallus. It was difficult to establish their connection with the underlying medullary hyphae since these very soon change to a brown plectenchyma. From about the middle of the ascogonial coil there rises a bundle of parallel stoutish hyphae which traverse the gonidial zone and the cortex and slightly overtop the surface. They are genetically connected at the base with the more or less spirally coiled hyphae, and are similar to the trichogynes described in other lichens. Lindau did not find that they had any sexual significance, and ascribed to them the mechanical function of terebrators or borers. The correctness of his deductions has been disputed by various workers: Baur[619] looks on these “trichogynes” as the first paraphyses. The reproductive organs in _Stereocaulon_ were examined by G. Wolff[623], and the absence of trichogynes was proved, though spermogonia were not wanting. She also failed to find any evidence of fertilization in _Xanthoria parietina_, in which lichen the ascogenous hyphae branch out from an ascogonium that does not form a trichogyne.

Rosendahl[624], as already stated, could find no trichogynes in _Parmelia glabra_. In _Parmelia obscurata_, on the contrary, Bitter[625] found that carpogonia with trichogynes were abundant and spermogonia very rare. In other species of the subgenus, _Hypogymnia_, he has pointed out that apothecia are either absent or occur but seldom, while spermogonia are numerous, and he concludes that the spermatia must function as spores or conidia. Baur[626] however does not accept that conclusion; he suggests as probable that the male organs persist longer in a functionless condition than do the apothecia.

Still more recently Nienburg[627] has described the ascogonium of _Baeomyces_ sp. and also of _Sphyridium byssoides_ (_Baeomyces rufus_) as reduced and probably degenerate. His results do not disprove those obtained by Krabbe[628] on the same lichen (_Sphyridium fungiforme_). The apothecia are terminal on short stalks in that species. When the stalk is about ·5mm. in height, sections through the tip show numerous primordia (12 to 15) ranged below the outer cortex, though only one, or at most three, develop further. These ascogonial groups are connected with each other by delicate filaments, and Nienburg concluded that they were secondary products from a primary group lower down in the tissue. Spirals were occasionally seen in what he considered to be the secondary ascogonia, but usually the fertile cells lie in loose uncoiled masses; isolated hyphae were observed to travel upwards from these cells, but they never emerged above the surface.

_Usnea macrocarpa_—if Schulte’s[629] work may be accepted—is also apogamous, though in _Usnea barbata_ Nienburg[627] found trichogynes (Fig. 95) and the various developments that are taken as evidence of fertilization. Wainio[630] had demonstrated emergent straight trichogynes in _Usnea laevis_ but without any sign of fertilization.

E. DISCUSSION OF LICHEN REPRODUCTION

In Ascolichens fertilization by the fusion of nuclei in the ascogonium is still a debated question. The female organ or carpogonium, as outlined above, comprises a twisted or spirally coiled multi-septate hypha, with a terminal branch regarded as a trichogyne which is also multi-septate, and through which the nucleus of the spermatium must travel to reach the female cell. It is instructive to compare the lichen carpogonium with that of other plants.

_a._ THE TRICHOGYNE. In the Florideae, or red seaweeds, in which the trichogyne was first described, that organ is merely a hair-like prolongation of the egg-cell and acts as a receptive tube. It contains granular protoplasm but no nucleus and terminates in a shiny tip covered with mucilage. The spermatium, unlike that of lichens, is a naked cell, and being non-motile is conveyed by water to the tip of the trichogyne to which it adheres; the intervening wall then breaks down and the male nucleus passes over. After this process of fertilization a plug of mucilage cuts off the trichogyne, and it withers away.

In _Coleochaete_, a genus of small freshwater green algae, a trichogyne is also present in some of the species: it is again a prolongation of an oogonial cell.

In the Ascomycetes, certain cells or cell-processes associated with the ascogonium have been described as trichogynes or receptive cells. In one of the simpler types, Monascus[631], the “trichogyne” is a cell cut off from the ascogonial cell. When fertilization takes place, the wall between the two cells breaks down to allow the passage of the male nucleus, but closes up when the process is effected. In _Pyronema confluens_[632] it is represented by a process from the ascogonial cell which fuses directly with the male cell. A more elaborate “trichogyne” has been evolved in _Lachnea stercorea_[633], another Discomycete: in that fungus it takes the form of a 3-5-septate hypha with a longer terminal cell; it rises from some part of the ascogonial cell but has no connection with any process of fertilization, so that the greater elaboration of form is in this case concomitant with loss of function.